I always thought the dots were just a bad design choice for that reason. Not a huge deal at the top left, but it was definitely the opposite of intuitive, when it first came out.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Signal bars or dots?
- Thread starter jabingla2810
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I always thought the dots were just a bad design choice for that reason. Not a huge deal at the top left, but it was definitely the opposite of intuitive, when it first came out.
I prefer the dBm readout above all else. I'm certainly hoping to get that back in a near future beta release.
Bars, and by a lot.
I don't care much for the design of bars vs dots, but one necessity for me is the fact that the dots needed to be blank when not filled in.
I'll show an example below.
My previous jailbroken status bar theme on iOS 8 (below):
Current iOS 8/10 dots:
View attachment 703446
I personally found the border of the empty dots to be kind of hard to read at a glance, with a small screen and crowded area up top. I like the jailbreak theme's implementation better.
Either way, I welcome bars back again, which to be honest is even better. I don't have terrible memories of super old android, so I'm not opposed to it.
Seems pretty clear to me, but it might be the background that helps.
Attachments
The bars give a false impression of having stronger signal due to their gradually increasing size, while dots maintain the same size, which is why I prefer the dots.
Pictures shown are as good as it gets (blown up screenshot, and black background). Add any other background color, and a sunny day, IRL viewing distances, and it can become less easy to read at a glance. Bars are intuitive and easy to discern. Like I said, imo the jailbroken theme solves the issues by itself. Bars make it even better though.
Bars if I couldn't use Field Test Mode. I use FTM, so have the decibels instead of the current dots.
every does still says how many bars do you have not dotsdocent really matter but welcome back bars!
Some people say how many circles. I'm like wtf are you talking about, lol
There's no numerical reading in the top left anymore. It's just the signal bars now.
IOS 6 and earlier used a signal strength bar which was replaced with dots in IOS 7 and what apple has been using ever since. Why has IOS 11 gone back to using the signal strength bar instead of the dots? I like the dots better as its easier to tell my signal strength that way than the bars.
Rats! I like the dots better. I may not upgrade to IOS 11 because of this.
I'm glad somebody else noticed that!
So now we have less granularity and a less detailed signal strength indicator which is so important.
So they took away our headphone jack, home button, and now one bar.
The 5 dots of course which represents the unique look of an apple ...the signal bars looks like an android which is horrible!
You mean they look like what Apple used to look like for quite a while before the dots and what pretty much all other phones (well before and beyond Android) looked and look like.
Any company can imitate the look, they just didn't decide to do it. Even Apple decided to go back to the more standard and known look. As far as preference, well, that's certainly a personal thing.
Totally agree
[doublepost=1509605531][/doublepost]
So what? here we are not counting the majority of ios upgrades.. but its all about what you are comfortable with though...i'd always prefer dots instead of bars
Last edited: