I like both.. but I'd never swim with a sport loop. Actually I don't even use my OEM Sport bands in the pool. I use cheap 3rd party sport bands
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Sport Loop or Sport Band?
- Thread starter AppleHater
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I laughed when I read this because I feel it's so true. It's a great idea the leather loop. In theory leather to make it look good, and the magnetics for practicality and ease of use, but somehow the look doesn't work. Using thicker leather might help, probably not.
I felt the same way, I only had Sport Bands the first year.
Now that I have some Loops, I think everyone should have at least one Loop. They're even more comfortable.
I love the sport bands and have a slew of them. I wasn't all that wild about sport loops but have since been converted. Despite the fact that I don't like the way they loop through the lug and thus you have a double up of the band, they are incredibly comfortable. I much prefer the look of the woven bands, one strap per side, but the lack of buckle on the loops makes really adds to the comfort of them.
I bought my watch with the sport band, and wore it for a while, but I eventually found it to be not that comfortable. I tended to sweat underneath it, and it eventually started itching and smelling. I probably could have washed it more often, but it was enough to get me to try something else. I didn't like the look of the sport loop, so I searched around and found an old Apple Woven Nylon Band. It is made from the same woven nylon as the sport loop, but it has a classic style buckle like regular watches instead of the hook and loop fastener. I like this look much better.
Overall I am happier with this band. It does absorb water and stays wet for a bit after you wash your hands, etc, but it will dry out on it's own eventually. It breathes on the wrist much better so I don't tend to sweat under it like the sport band, and I don't find it near as irritating on my skin. I found that it did start to smell eventually, especially after I wore it while mowing the lawn and doing other yard work. I tried just washing it in the sink with dish soap a few times, and it helped, but the smell seemed to come back pretty quick. Eventually I decided to try throwing it in the laundry. I put it in one of those washable mesh garment bags for delicates and threw it in with a load of dark colors, then let it air dry. This worked much better and I have found I only need to do this about once a month or so now that I haven't been out mowing the lawn with it. So far it has been holding up fine.
My wife has the same issue with her sport band too. She recently quit wearing her watch for a couple weeks because she had developed a bit of a rash on her wrist. I just bought her the black leather classic buckle for Christmas for her to try out. I'm also going to have her look at the Sport Loop, and Woven Nylon bands if we can find any. I figure the leather will be nice for work and when we go out, and she can switch to the Nylon when working out/doing yard work etc.
Overall I am happier with this band. It does absorb water and stays wet for a bit after you wash your hands, etc, but it will dry out on it's own eventually. It breathes on the wrist much better so I don't tend to sweat under it like the sport band, and I don't find it near as irritating on my skin. I found that it did start to smell eventually, especially after I wore it while mowing the lawn and doing other yard work. I tried just washing it in the sink with dish soap a few times, and it helped, but the smell seemed to come back pretty quick. Eventually I decided to try throwing it in the laundry. I put it in one of those washable mesh garment bags for delicates and threw it in with a load of dark colors, then let it air dry. This worked much better and I have found I only need to do this about once a month or so now that I haven't been out mowing the lawn with it. So far it has been holding up fine.
My wife has the same issue with her sport band too. She recently quit wearing her watch for a couple weeks because she had developed a bit of a rash on her wrist. I just bought her the black leather classic buckle for Christmas for her to try out. I'm also going to have her look at the Sport Loop, and Woven Nylon bands if we can find any. I figure the leather will be nice for work and when we go out, and she can switch to the Nylon when working out/doing yard work etc.
Last edited:
as every owners kingdom will have to decide this on their own, based on the particular preferences. This question might be hard to answer generically..
I do it all the time (I want the fall detection in the shower). Getting the Sport Loop wet doesn't result in any smell. (It's fast-drying). I throw mine in the washing machine every few weeks.
I have run them through the "light wash" cycle of the dishwasher in the past... just lay them out in the third (silverware) rack, and they come out perfect... they lay them out to finish drying before wearing again.
I wash my husband's ball caps in the dishwasher...never thought of doing the same with my watch bands. Love it!!