My wife wants the Midnight Blue sport band for the 38mm rose gold watch. Without spending $50 on the Apple one which is the best brand to get?
There are two problems with the 3rd party sport bands:
1) every one I've seen has been silicone, while the Apple bands are fluoroelastomer, which really does feel different - you might not mind the difference, or might even end up preferring the silicone, but they
are different; and,
2) Apple wins on consistency - the band you buy from them today will be nearly exactly the same as the band you could buy from them two years ago - in comparison, many of the third-party companies selling through eBay and Amazon will be replaced by different companies six months on; that, combined with many of them using Apple's pictures of the bands (rather than taking pictures of their own products) can make it really hard to know exactly what you're getting until it arrives. It also means that a recommendation from someone about a great band they got six months ago might be useful or might be quite misleading.
As well, recommendations from others of "it's
exactly the same as the Apple ones" can run all the way from it really being exactly the same (
highly doubtful because of silicone issue), to it being merely mostly capable of successfully attaching to the Apple Watch (seriously, I recall seeing claims of "just as good as the Apple ones" accompanied by pictures with the band clearly overhanging the channel where it attaches to the watch). People seem to have widely varying opinions of what the word "exactly" means.
So... consider recommendations with some amount of caution. (I'm not saying "
don't get a 3rd party band", just... caveat emptor.)