Glad everyone seems to be enjoying their new MacBook Airs.
Mine arrived on Wednesday... which I ordered in the hope that it would be the goldilocks MacBook I've been waiting for: one with some of the lightweight qualities of the 12" MacBook combined the performance of a higher-end machine.
On the plus side, it is nicely built as we would expect, and, assuming you can get by on 128GB, is a good value for money as far MacBooks go, with the latest industrial design, advanced architecture courtesy of the T2 chip, and Touch ID.
But sadly this is not the goldilocks machine I was hoping for:
It is not a thin and light computer by 2018 Jony Ive standards. It's actually thicker than the 13" MacBook Pro at its thickest point - noticeably thicker. On paper it's only 8.5% lighter than the Pro - in the hand it feels about the same weight. The footprint of the Air is actually larger than the Pro.
Its screen is poor. The 13" MacBook Pro without Touch Bar is just £50 more yet ships with a beautiful, P3, 500-nit display. The Air's screen isn't terrible, but after being spoiled by beautiful screens in the latest iPads, iPhones, and Macs, the Air really underwhelms. Not to mention, it doesn't have True Tone like the 2018 Pros. More than
two years since a £1249 device with a great screen launched - two years in which technology has marched on and prices have presumably fallen - you would hope a £1199 device could ship with a screen at least as good as the two year old one.
The overall hardware performance is acceptable, but a MacBook of this bulk and a fan should
either be equipped with the 15W class quad core processors (if they want to prioritise capability), or be even lower power and have a the same legendary battery life of the old MacBook Air (if they want to prioritise usability).
As it stands, I just wonder, what are they using all this space for?!
Minor observations that I've not seen in the reviews:
- The FaceTime HD camera - while finally "HD" - is not as good as the one found in the Pro.
- The speakers distort a bit at max volume.
- The trackpad is the 'first generation' Force Touch trackpad. The 2016 MacBook Pro introduced a revised style with a more natural click, but the Air uses the type from 2015. They're functionally the same and it's a personal preference thing, but I do wonder why Apple is still shipping different incarnations of trackpads in brand new products.
- The hinge is the 12" MacBook style - not the Pro style liquid metal hinge. I wonder if this will be less reliable over time.
Overall it is still a great laptop. I'm just hoping within a year or so the price will drop to £999 and start at 256GB of storage. For now, I'm still a bit homeless in the MacBook lineup.