I think the Dynamic Island is a great way to make better use of the space around the camera and FaceID sensors but after using it for a year, not sure I'd miss it if all of a sudden it was gone. If anything, I appreciate the Lock Screen live actiivities more. Little blurbs of info updated from the Island is great but, not really a huge difference over just getting a notification.
Don't get wrong, it's an improvement, but just not any sort of paradigm shift versus what we had prior to its existence.