Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Vegastouch

macrumors 603
Jul 12, 2008
6,185
992
Las Vegas, NV
Quirks is the appropriate description. Android just does strange things at times, and you need to be aware of it and prepared to deal with it if you intend on being satisfied on any level.

Thus far though the S5 is very good, and coming from me that is high praise.

The S4 I had was basically a debacle from day one and I was back with the iPhone in about 2 months.
Thats for sure. You are one of the biggest Android bashers around who yet keeps buying them anyways.

I loved my GS3. The only thing i didnt like about it was i couldnt see the screen at all in daylight. So if the GS5 is getting this much praise from you...lol, ill have to check it out. I didnt think the GS4 was worth buying.

I have a Nexus 5 and it is a really good phone that ive had for 5 months and i dont need an upgrade but if i try the GS5 and love it, i can give my Nexus to my Wife who is using an older HTC Windows 7 phone.
 

Max(IT)

Suspended
Dec 8, 2009
8,551
1,662
Italy
What I'm realizing now is that I like Android quite a bit, but the hardware and Samsung´s Touchwiz leave much to be desired. The phone is to difficult to use one handed and there are quirks about the UI that probably aren't in stock Android. Android itself is quite wonderful if I may say so myself. It's come a long way. But this Samsung is going back to the store.

I'm with you.
I like my nexus 7 experience, but I won't buy a bloated Samsung ...
For me android truly experience is nexus. Unfortunately nexus 5 is a good phone with some corners cut to keep it low priced.
Maybe nexus 6 will be the right one for me.
 

mib1800

Suspended
Sep 16, 2012
2,859
1,250
Did those who said the S5 lag ever tried it or they are just regurgitate the same old anti samsung anti touchwiz lag nonsense?

I tried the S5 extensively and there were no lag. It is very fast. Anyone who said the S5 lagged is just not being truthful. If the standard is s5 lagged then in comparison the iPhone 5s lag even more.
 

Switchback666

macrumors 68000
Nov 16, 2012
1,600
67
SXM
Did those who said the S5 lag ever tried it or they are just regurgitate the same old anti samsung anti touchwiz lag nonsense?

I tried the S5 extensively and there were no lag. It is very fast. Anyone who said the S5 lagged is just not being truthful. If the standard is s5 lagged then in comparison the iPhone 5s lag even more.

I didn't notice any lag on my friends s5, imo the experience was the same like my note 3 minus the bigger screen.
 

blackhand1001

macrumors 68030
Jan 6, 2009
2,600
37
What I'm realizing now is that I like Android quite a bit, but the hardware and Samsung´s Touchwiz leave much to be desired. The phone is to difficult to use one handed and there are quirks about the UI that probably aren't in stock Android. Android itself is quite wonderful if I may say so myself. It's come a long way. But this Samsung is going back to the store.

Have a look at the moto x or hold out for the second gen model. The first one excellent, I can imagine the second one will be even better.

----------

Thats for sure. You are one of the biggest Android bashers around who yet keeps buying them anyways.

I loved my GS3. The only thing i didnt like about it was i couldnt see the screen at all in daylight. So if the GS5 is getting this much praise from you...lol, ill have to check it out. I didnt think the GS4 was worth buying.

I have a Nexus 5 and it is a really good phone that ive had for 5 months and i dont need an upgrade but if i try the GS5 and love it, i can give my Nexus to my Wife who is using an older HTC Windows 7 phone.

Other than battery life, I don't see the galaxy s5 being a big upgrade over the nexus 5. The SOC is pretty much identical. Its just clocked different. The advanatages of the nexus 5 outweigh the galaxy s5 in my opinion since you'll have to deal with Samsung's heavy skin which has gotten heavier since the s3.
 

Max(IT)

Suspended
Dec 8, 2009
8,551
1,662
Italy
Did those who said the S5 lag ever tried it or they are just regurgitate the same old anti samsung anti touchwiz lag nonsense?

I tried the S5 extensively and there were no lag. It is very fast. Anyone who said the S5 lagged is just not being truthful. If the standard is s5 lagged then in comparison the iPhone 5s lag even more.

Do you need YouTube videos ? There are several ...
TouchWiz is just a ridiculous piece of crapware.

The good S5 will be the GPE.

----------

Have a look at the moto x or hold out for the second gen model. The first one excellent, I can imagine the second one will be even better.

----------



Other than battery life, I don't see the galaxy s5 being a big upgrade over the nexus 5. The SOC is pretty much identical. Its just clocked different. The advanatages of the nexus 5 outweigh the galaxy s5 in my opinion since you'll have to deal with Samsung's heavy skin which has gotten heavier since the s3.
Well a s5 GPE would be a significant upgrade.
Battery and camera are far better.
I do agree that the price difference is just too much to be worth a change.
 

kasakka

macrumors 68020
Oct 25, 2008
2,389
1,084
The questions I'd ask are if you can find an Android equivalent of every app you use often on the phone and if you are fine with the larger size of the S5.

I moved from iPhone 4 to Galaxy S4 and don't really like the size of the phone. While the big, high res screen is a joy to read, the placement of the back button and the physical size of the phone makes for very awkward one handed use.

I tried the S5 a few days ago and can't find any redeeming values in it. It is even larger (even more so when you account for the bezels that seem a bit larger on it) while everything else is largely unchanged. The S4 was already way fast for me and the camera was good enough. The only thing I wanted for the camera was OIS and that's nowhere to be seen on the S5.
 

mib1800

Suspended
Sep 16, 2012
2,859
1,250
Do you need YouTube videos ? There are several ...
TouchWiz is just a ridiculous piece of crapware.

The good S5 will be the GPE.

----------


Well a s5 GPE would be a significant upgrade.
Battery and camera are far better.
I do agree that the price difference is just too much to be worth a change.

Want me to show a video of iPhone 5s lag? Unlike you I am not so blinded and clueless to label 5s always lag. It is just foolish to believe videos that show s5 lag and say that is the typical. I can make the ip5s lag like no tomorrow when I open safari with a few heavy background pages.

I
 

Max(IT)

Suspended
Dec 8, 2009
8,551
1,662
Italy
Want me to show a video of iPhone 5s lag? Unlike you I am not so blinded and clueless to label 5s always lag. It is just foolish to believe videos that show s5 lag and say that is the typical. I can make the ip5s lag like no tomorrow when I open safari with a few heavy background pages.

I

What the heck has iPhone 5s to do with this thread or my post ?
Btw I was speaking about lag and stuttering in the UI , it has NOTHING to do with the browser loading heavy pages.
Could you show me an iPhone 5S lagging in the UI ?
 

mib1800

Suspended
Sep 16, 2012
2,859
1,250
What the heck has iPhone 5s to do with this thread or my post ?
Btw I was speaking about lag and stuttering in the UI , it has NOTHING to do with the browser loading heavy pages.
Could you show me an iPhone 5S lagging in the UI ?

The video you shown mainly show the lag in the magazine app isn't it? And isn't safari an app?

And you are not being objective here. The magazine app is loading huge data online as well as rendering much more info on screen. So your bias is to compare this to moving between homescreen on your ios devices with just pathetic icons already cached in Ram.
 

MacNut

macrumors Core
Jan 4, 2002
22,998
9,976
CT
I played around with the S5 at the store for a while. I like the new back, feels a lot better and less slimey. But the phone is far to big. The N5 or Moto x seem to be the sweet spot.
 

Surface2Owner

macrumors member
Nov 18, 2013
48
1
If larger screen size is important to you, then yes. For that reason (among others but this is the primary one), I am returning my iPhone 5s. In terms of looks, I personally find the Galaxy S5 to have been beaten by an ugly stick. However, looks is in the eye of the beholder I guess.
 

DanGoh

macrumors 6502
Apr 6, 2014
366
506
I'm scared to switch. The last month I've contemplated on trying Android for a year. I like the bigger screen the GS5, LG G2, and Moto X have to offer but in the back of my mind I'm afraid they'll let me down when I'm text messaging, taking a picture, web browsing, gaming (threes, scrabble, wheres the water) or listening to music (I listen to music a lot on my 64GB iPhone 5).

My iPhone 5 has never let me down, and I hear a lot of negatives about android. Especially with battery and app issues. Who is me........
 

Fanaticalism

macrumors 6502a
Apr 16, 2013
908
158
I'm scared to switch. The last month I've contemplated on trying Android for a year. I like the bigger screen the GS5, LG G2, and Moto X have to offer but in the back of my mind I'm afraid they'll let me down when I'm text messaging, taking a picture, web browsing, gaming (threes, scrabble, wheres the water) or listening to music (I listen to music a lot on my 64GB iPhone 5).

My iPhone 5 has never let me down, and I hear a lot of negatives about android. Especially with battery and app issues. Who is me........

When you say "let you down", do you mean as in crash and become inoperable? If that is the case, you have nothing to worry about.

I'll share my wife' current state of transition from an iPhone 5 to an S5. Her usage was extremely simple in that all she does is Facebook, surf, calls,Tango, Skype, photos/videos and text. She didn't even know how to crop a photo on her iPhone. She would literally zoom in on the image and take a screen shot... lol.

She is currently 10 days in, and by far the first 5 were the most difficult. I did nothing to help her other than setup backups for photos and contacts.I wanted her to try and find her way to discover what she didn't like as opposed to me adjusting to what I like. Things that annoyed her:

Did not like the autocorrect of the Samsung keyboard. She is bilingual and it constantly messed up her words.

Didn't understand the slide to call or message from contacts or missed calls so it frustrated her that she had to click multiple times (she also didn't realize how Android handles notifications so she didn't use the NC. to return calls/texts/FB messages).

Why the different folders in the gallery? I'd share a photo which goes into the downloads folder but she'd be in the camera roll, so naturally couldn't find it.

Likes:

Larger screen. This is the most obvious and the main reason for people switching.

Notification center and LED. Once she realized she no longer had to scan for badges or look for banners on the lock screen, it made things much easier for her. The notification center really is the core for Android and makes things much more seamless. Return calls, messages and reply to emails right from within it, impressed her because in her words, "I like it, it's simple".

Keyboard: I installed Swiftkey, gave her a pink theme, installed the Latin American version of the spanish keyboard and she couldn't be happier. She used to peck at the keyboard on her iPhone. She now types with both thumbs and is much faster.

Photo Gallery: She just had to learn here. :). What is interesting, is that for some reason she wants to actually learn the features of the phone. So she learned how to crop the photos and enjoys the ability to share to other apps from within a single place. She even made her first NFC payment using ISIS wallet with the free $50 she got for setting it up at the ATT store. That kind of amazed her.

Video: Absolutely loves the UHD video with HFR and the fact she never runs out of space with the MSD card. She was constantly backing up and deleting since icloud has a cap for storage you can purchase.


I know I kind of went on a tangent, but it seems like your uses are pretty basic and wanted to point out that those things won't be an impact. It is the even more fundamental things that frustrate due to being different.
 

Max(IT)

Suspended
Dec 8, 2009
8,551
1,662
Italy
The video you shown mainly show the lag in the magazine app isn't it? And isn't safari an app?

And you are not being objective here. The magazine app is loading huge data online as well as rendering much more info on screen. So your bias is to compare this to moving between homescreen on your ios devices with just pathetic icons already cached in Ram.

I showed just one .... There are many others showing lags and stuttering in multitasking and gallery ...
The one biased it's not me ....
 

mib1800

Suspended
Sep 16, 2012
2,859
1,250
I showed just one .... There are many others showing lags and stuttering in multitasking and gallery ...
The one biased it's not me ....

Nope. You are bias because you are mixing different scenario / logic and equating them as equal and then labeling one device lag.

Your criticism is as ridiculous as the following:
When i open multiple tabs in Safari some tabs keeps reloading and i have to wait and wait. The Ip5s lags so much that it is so substandard compared to my other xx device which can load the calculator app immediately without delay. So I have to conclude ip5s is a lag fest .
 

Max(IT)

Suspended
Dec 8, 2009
8,551
1,662
Italy
Nope. You are bias because you are mixing different scenario / logic and equating them as equal and then labeling one device lag.

Your criticism is as ridiculous as the following:
When i open multiple tabs in Safari some tabs keeps reloading and i have to wait and wait. The Ip5s lags so much that it is so substandard compared to my other xx device which can load the calculator app immediately without delay. So I have to conclude ip5s is a lag fest .

I have demonstrated on many threads, with YouTube videos posted and done by myself, that the "safari keeps reloading tabs" is a false myth , especially after iOS 7.1 release.
I can browse multiple tabs without reloading, and if I use Mercury Browser, my favorite, I have a better browsing experience on my iPad than on my nexus 7.
But you clearly have no idea of that because you probably don't own an iPad/iPhone and are just trying to bash Apple to defend Samsung based on rumors you read on this forum.
 

mib1800

Suspended
Sep 16, 2012
2,859
1,250
I have demonstrated on many threads, with YouTube videos posted and done by myself, that the "safari keeps reloading tabs" is a false myth , especially after iOS 7.1 release.
I can browse multiple tabs without reloading, and if I use Mercury Browser, my favorite, I have a better browsing experience on my iPad than on my nexus 7.
But you clearly have no idea of that because you probably don't own an iPad/iPhone and are just trying to bash Apple to defend Samsung based on rumors you read on this forum.

Backpedalling? :p
So only apple know how to fix bugs and optimize safari or an app and the rest of the world are just idiots? That's how ridiculous you sound.

Safari doesn't reload tabs on 7.1? Really? Btw: so do want want to bet that I don't have iPad?
 

Max(IT)

Suspended
Dec 8, 2009
8,551
1,662
Italy
Backpedalling? :p
So only apple know how to fix bugs and optimize safari or an app and the rest of the world are just idiots? That's how ridiculous you sound.

Safari doesn't reload tabs on 7.1? Really? Btw: so do want want to bet that I don't have iPad?

Safari is far from being optimized, especially in its 64 bits flavor .... That is the reason I switched to Mercury since iOS 7 launch.
Nevertheless l demonstrated to another naysayer like you, using self made videos, that you can have multiple tabs browsing also on safari, after 7.1 installation.
Apple isn't perfect, but surely is far better than Samsung in software development.
You can have tabs reloads on every device: I can make my Nexus a mess opening the right webpages.

I don't care what you have and what you have not.
 
Last edited:

mib1800

Suspended
Sep 16, 2012
2,859
1,250
Safari is far from being optimized, especially in its 64 bits flavor .... That is the reason I switched to Mercury since iOS 7 launch.
Apple isn't perfect, but surely is far better than Samsung in software development.
You can have tabs reloads on every device: I can make my Nexus a mess opening the right webpages.

I don't care what you have and what you have not.

So what you are saying? That performance of moving between homescreen on ios with just pathetic icons CANNOT be compared to moving between heavily loaded dynamic screens in magazine app or homescreen loaded with widgets on samsung galaxy.

btw: apple better software developer? How? Maybe Apple came out with super fantastic idea of putting settings centrally or an email app that can't do attachments without restrictions or wipe your important data without notice when you uninstall an app etc etc.
 

Max(IT)

Suspended
Dec 8, 2009
8,551
1,662
Italy
So what you are saying? That performance of moving between homescreen on ios with just pathetic icons CANNOT be compared to moving between heavily loaded dynamic screens in magazine app or homescreen loaded with widgets on samsung galaxy.

btw: apple better software developer? How? Maybe Apple came out with super fantastic idea of putting settings centrally or an email app that can't do attachments without restrictions or wipe your important data without notice when you uninstall an app etc etc.

I'm done with you.
Enjoy your wonderful Samsung with the world awarded touchwiz.
Speak with someone that can even start to compare Samsung to Apple as a software developer is a waste of my time.
 
Last edited:

ariso

macrumors newbie
Apr 29, 2014
1
0
I am also coming from iPhone5 n it worth a go IMO. Impressive battery life& camera.
 

dosdog

macrumors newbie
May 6, 2014
1
0
Decent phone for sure, but I personally really hate its design. I don't know but it doesn't capture my attention.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.