I find it pretty annoying when people post such strong opinions against something (anything) without explaining. I use SimplyTweet and find it much better (and prettier) than Tweetie. I am a casual user so maybe there's something I'm missing in Tweetie that I don't use that makes it so amazing...
Okay, I'll test the newest version of SimplyTweet and "live blog" my experience here.
Let's start with the name. SimplyTweet? Terrible. Sounds like an artificial sweetener or some sort of Martha Stewart segment. Right off the bat when I hear "try SimplyTweet" I'm thinking to myself "oh, great, lets humor this oaf and try it out."
It's $5!? I've already tried the free version, but for this I'll pirate it and check it out.
Installed. Wow, check out that boring icon. I can tell already that this is going to be one hell of a boring UI, with little to no thought put into it.
Push notifications? I already have boxcar, but whatever. Haha, after I typed my info in to log in, the progress was indicated by dimming the keyboard? Why?
Okay, first thing I notice is the blue dot. Is this some sort of unread indication? What's the point of this? I scroll to the top and the dots don't disappear. The only way to get them to disappear is to scroll them off the screen and scroll back. I would be doing that ALL DAY LONG as I use this client. That's already a deal breaker.
Second thing I notice is this refresh button at the top. Makes no sense, I'm already at the top. Just reload when I get to the top or try to scroll up. Same with the "older" button at the bottom. I'm at the bottom because I'm looking at old tweets, don't give me a button to push, just load older ones automatically.
Third thing I notice is the absolutely hideous chat bubbles. Who made these? I want to ban them from ever designing anything ever again.
Looking at single tweet view makes me want to scoop my eyeballs out. What made the designer put that gross gradient at the top? Oh, good, an "rt" button, it doesn't even support the new retweets.
Gunna make a tweet now. Oh, god, why? The toolbar attached to the keyboard is blue and the keyboard is gray. They should match. This is ugly.
Back to timeline. Swipe a tweet. Oh that's cool, they copied Tweetie, only ... the buttons are ugly and the gray thing is like 99% opaque. Great.
Hahaha, it doesnt have threaded direct messages? This is a deal breaker for me.
Yeah, I can't take any more of this. It's just terrible.
So basically you're here to bash an app because you don't like how it looks.
A twitter client is a user interface for using twitter. The ONLY thing that matters about it is what it looks like and how you interact with it.
If the UI of a twitter client sucks, then the twitter client sucks. There are no performance based ratings here.
Yes, a geo metro will get you from point A to point B, but wouldn't you rather drive a Lotus?