Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
im in a position where I like the M2 design overall and its screen and design enhancements, still not a fan of the SSD slowdown on the 256gb model, but cant bring myself to get rid of my M1 even if it resold for well and still appreciate the 'dated' tapered look.

I have a 2016 intel MBP 13" I dual boot that I won't get rid of either.
this M1
and I dont really want a third laptop

I think common sense should be to keep using my 2020 base M1 for a while.
I saw the new MacBook Air a few days after it first came out and thought to myself: "I like the M1 design better for the air...but...I like all of the updates and power (except the lack of a fan) of the new." If I had to get a new general laptop, it would be a good choice regardless.

I still have a MacBook Air i7 2013 (maxed) and I still use it on occasion and like it still, even in 2022. EVEN though I have MacBook Pro 2018 & the best laptop overall ever: 16" MacBook Pro 2021. I don't know why...but I still prefer that design, feel etc. (the bezels I don't mind either). MacBook Air 2013 actually feels like it is on air compared to the weight of the last few. It also feels very balance in the hand. I even had the first MacBook Air 2008...and loved it too. Apple actually asked for it and swapped it out for a new 2010 when I brought it into a store...it was in perfect condition and they were shocked that there was not a scratch and no finger prints etc. (I was fanatical at the time to keep it looking "like new". They wanted it for whatever reason. At the time I said, "yeah...better tech, specs and a swap and not paying...oh yeah, take it". And I got a new laptop with newer tech. :)

The Air does not have to be just a smaller cheaper version of the MacBook Pro. I liked the difference in designs to distinguish the Air from Pro...but...can live (or have too) with it if I need the new MacBook Air (I don't right now). It's still a great option regardless of my preferences.
 
That’s quite some ability you have there, twisting all of the obvious truths around just enough to validate your argument! True internet warrior. Alas, you haven’t either seen or used one though have you.
Interesting. That’s the first time someone called facts twisting the truth.
 
That’s not true though is it? 20% faster in almost all cases, so much faster in others (media rendering) and the Nand Flash issue effects the base model only and 99% of people wouldn’t notice it.
You’re too focused on outliers. The majority of people who bought the M1 Air purchased the base model so we can assume an even greater % of users will purchase the base M2 Air model due to the big price jump and the fact that 14” and 16” MBP’s didn’t exist when the M1 Air launched. Not to mention, by the time you bump it to 16/512 it’s almost the same price as the 14” MBP (street price) so you’d need to be someone with more money than sense to buy an M2 Air at that point.

20% faster “in almost all cases” is a fantasy. It’s even faster than Apple’s marketing claims, and they claim a lot! Sure, it’s faster if you’re running single apps and/or synthetic benchmarks for 5 minutes at a time, but single core is what’s used for most basic computing tasks and that’s closer to 10% faster which in real world use is not noticeable. Anyone who renders anything on a regular basis will have bought/be buying a 14” MBP or better… or even th 13” MBP.
 
Interesting. That’s the first time someone called facts twisting the truth.
Fact- new chipset
Fact- faster chipset
Fact- redesigned body

Your claim- redesign is a thinner rehash of a 20 year old design.
Yep. It’s a clamshell laptop. Every laptop on the planet is that.
Your claim- it’s ‘much’ slower.
No, it isn’t. The base model ssd is a bit slower.
Your claim- it has minimal differences in weight, screen size and performance.
The screen is bigger. It’s lighter. It’s a higher performance chipset.
Your claim- it’s 20% higher priced.
🤷‍♀️ it is yes. Don’t buy it if you don’t want it. Stuff’s pretty pricey these days. My phone was a grand. That said I earn enough so I buy what I want to use. Plenty of cheaper options around, including the last gen MacBook Air.
 
"everything"...
I have two older wedge Airs. 9 year old ones that still work. not great screens but usable. at a pinch. fine for travel as they get thrown in a bag without too much worry or too big a theft risk in a hotel.

This new MBA feels better.
go pick one up and see. the added top screen bit lets menus move up too. so more content area.
I also own a 2010 MacBook Air which still works. I used it through all of the years that Apple struggled with it’s “butterfly” keyboard issues which proves that new is not necessarily better. I just picked up a M1 MacBook Pro. No significant difference to me and the notch is the stupidest design mistake ever made.
 
Fact- new chipset
Fact- faster chipset
Fact- redesigned body

Your claim- redesign is a thinner rehash of a 20 year old design.
Yep. It’s a clamshell laptop. Every laptop on the planet is that.
Your claim- it’s ‘much’ slower.
No, it isn’t. The base model ssd is a bit slower.
Your claim- it has minimal differences in weight, screen size and performance.
The screen is bigger. It’s lighter. It’s a higher performance chipset.
Your claim- it’s 20% higher priced.
🤷‍♀️ it is yes. Don’t buy it if you don’t want it. Stuff’s pretty pricey these days. My phone was a grand. That said I earn enough so I buy what I want to use. Plenty of cheaper options around, including the last gen MacBook Air.
So basically if it’s something you care about it’s fact, but a 50% slowdown in SSD performance is considered a claim and only “a bit slower”?

Here’s a fact for you: just because something is new doesn’t make it better, and it certainly doesn’t make it a better value when the price jumps by 20%.

I obviously won’t be buying it. I’m just warning people who might not have done their research from making a mistake and giving their money to Apple which will only encourage them to take advantage of its customers.

The fact that you’re taking my comments so personally now makes sense. You’re going through pre or post-purchase dissonance and you’re doing everything you can to justify your purchase. If you didn’t have doubts about your purchase, you’d be too busy enjoying your M2 Air instead of defending it every chance you get.
 
So basically if it’s something you care about it’s fact, but a 50% slowdown in SSD performance is considered a claim and only “a bit slower”?

Here’s a fact for you: just because something is new doesn’t make it better, and it certainly doesn’t make it a better value when the price jumps by 20%.

I obviously won’t be buying it. I’m just warning people who might not have done their research from making a mistake and giving their money to Apple which will only encourage them to take advantage of its customers.

The fact that you’re taking my comments so personally now makes sense. You’re going through pre or post-purchase dissonance and you’re doing everything you can to justify your purchase. If you didn’t have doubts about your purchase, you’d be too busy enjoying your M2 Air instead of defending it every chance you get.
Personally 😂 good one.
 
I also own a 2010 MacBook Air which still works. I used it through all of the years that Apple struggled with it’s “butterfly” keyboard issues which proves that new is not necessarily better. I just picked up a M1 MacBook Pro. No significant difference to me and the notch is the stupidest design mistake ever made.
the butterfly keyboard with three attempts right the issues was a definite fail by Apple.
althought my Macbook Pro has it and seems fine. fingers crossed it continues.

the notch gets so much hate. i dont love it but the extra screen space on either side is well used.
and as i said before, withthe right wallpaper, it disappears.
like all the phones (not just Apple ones) that use somewhat cunning wallpapers in their ads to minimise the notches or punch holes or teardrops that chew screen. the one under screen camera I have in an Oppo is dreadful. no notch but the front facing cam is horrible.

so i dont see the notch as a design fail. current tech under screen not mature enough to remove it. this is a workaround.
 
Go to Apple's store website:

MBAir M2 16GB/512GB SSD 8 core CPU 10 Core GPU 16 core Neural - $1,699 before tax

14" MBPro M1 Pro 16GB/512GB SSD 8 core CPU 14 core GPU 16 core Neural - $1,999 before tax

So a ProMotion screen with higher resolution, additional USB-C port, HDMI port, & SD card slot more graphics power, more speakers is not worth $300?
You can get the 14” even cheaper than that now. So many deals on it. That’s why I canceled my Air M2 preorder and went for a MacBook Pro.
 
  • Like
Reactions: turbineseaplane
Exactly... love to know which ones.
I havent noticed anything crawling. In fact, most tasks are darn right snappy.

The video benchmark test showed simulated web page work and M2 easily trounced the M1.

This the BASE laptop (for new design).
Sure we would all have loved it to be the old price.
But that's never been Apple's way.
Occasionally they surprise us (remember experts were predicting $1000 price on initial iPad which came out at $499? but few experts could see a reason for such a silly named device either ...)
Actually, after a lifetime of Apple devices I can state that prices don't change so much as value keeps increasing exponentially. E.g. my 2011 MBP (4 GB RAM) cost about $4k, my 2016 MBP cost ~$4k and when I buy an M2 MBP (64 GB RAM) it will cost me ~$4k.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wbeasley
Actually, after a lifetime of Apple devices I can state that prices don't change so much as value keeps increasing exponentially. E.g. my 2011 MBP (4 GB RAM) cost about $4k, my 2016 MBP (16 GB RAM) cost ~$4k pre-discounting and when I buy an M2 MBP (64 GB RAM) it will cost me ~$4k.
 
Last edited:
Another bogus review. No review should be recommending the M2 over the M1 Air outside of very few use cases.

Especially when you factor in the big price difference, minimal performance gains, massive drop in performance for some basic real world tasks, M2 throttling issues, and most importantly, the audience they are targeting and the basic computing tasks they are likely to perform.

Watching the video w/out reading it was a "review", I thought it was PR.
Especially the end, instead of criticizing the lack of storage or RAM, he recommends $$$$ paying more $$$$ and "you'll thank me later."

At least he's got a sense of humor.
 
Another bogus review. No review should be recommending the M2 over the M1 Air outside of very few use cases.

Especially when you factor in the big price difference, minimal performance gains, massive drop in performance for some basic real world tasks, M2 throttling issues, and most importantly, the audience they are targeting and the basic computing tasks they are likely to perform.
A computer/phone company ventures into chipmaking for the first time and comes out with its first chip series called the M1, which works very well. Then they come out with a second generation called M2 a year and a half later.

Anyone who does not believe that there are myriad improvements (many unannounced) in that company's v2 chip does not understand the world of high tech at all. Buying last generation tech - especially version 1 last generation tech - may save some $$, but it will always be tech a very important generation behind.

Edit: TBH the M1 is technically not Apple's first foray onto chipmaking, but that does not change my argument at all.
 
Last edited:
Another bogus review. No review should be recommending the M2 over the M1 Air outside of very few use cases.

Especially when you factor in the big price difference, minimal performance gains, massive drop in performance for some basic real world tasks, M2 throttling issues, and most importantly, the audience they are targeting and the basic computing tasks they are likely to perform.
Your brain has been wormed by clickbait. Seek help.
 
I think Dan's review was good and I agree with what he said. Even if I hadn't agreed, I still think it was a solid review, even if it was subjective.

M2 pluses for me coming from the M1 MBA.
1) No speaker grills which means easier to keep clean
2) Bigger display with better camera. While I don't use the camera on the Mac very often, the times I do for family and work make the new 1080p camera upgrade worth it.
3) Bigger SSD. My M1 MBA was the base model and I got tired of doing a lot of offloading on a regular basis.
4) The keyboard on the M2 definitely has a different feel to it versus the M1. The tracking is a little more shallow and not as spongy as the M1. I also appreciate the full size function keys.
5) MagSafe did factor in. I do like the feature and it has rescued me in the past. If it helps save the M2 again from unforeseen trouble, then that is more personal reaffirmation.
6) There have been times I got the M1 to heat up with my normal use and it kept chugging along. The M2 will be no different. Much ado about nothing with what amounts to normal behavior.
7) I don't foresee being able to tell a noticeable difference between the two in speed and that is fine with me. I am still able to get my workflow done as smooth on the M2 as with the M1.

*Price didn't factor into the equation for me and I think too many here are ranting too much over $200 and the bulk of the complaining is coming from MBP folks. I am already spending X amount for what I want. If $200 more was going to blow the purchase, that tells me I shouldn't have been considering it in the first place.
For $200 more, you can get the M1 with 16GB RAM or 512 GB upgrade. The M2 is $200 more with slower SSD and same the 8GB/256GB as the base M1. Apple is very stingy with RAM and storage for a $1200 laptop.
 
  • Like
Reactions: compwiz1202
For $200 more, you can get the M1 with 16GB RAM or 512 GB upgrade. The M2 is $200 more with slower SSD and same the 8GB/256GB as the base M1. Apple is very stingy with RAM and storage for a $1200 laptop.
But you get a bigger, brighter and better screen, better battery life, gpu, lighter, faster in everything but a swap file. No brainer to get the m2 air over the m1 unless you ‘demand’ a $1000 price point.
 
But you get a bigger, brighter and better screen, better battery life, gpu, lighter, faster in everything but a swap file. No brainer to get the m2 air over the m1 unless you ‘demand’ a $1000 price point.
But wasn’t the point you can get more RAM m1 unit for less than m2 base cost? and therefore end up w a more useful machine?

We don’t all have piles of money lying around..
 
  • Like
Reactions: compwiz1202
You only have to do it once to make it worth it. If you ever worked in IT you would know the answer to this question. I’ll give you a hint it’s yes yes they do 😂😂😂😂
I have worked in IT for over 30 years. In all of those years, I have never encountered a single laptop fallen to the ground because somebody tripped over a cable. So the answer is No.
 
But wasn’t the point you can get more RAM m1 unit for less than m2 base cost? and therefore end up w a more useful machine?

We don’t all have piles of money lying around..
How is it more useful?

From memory, my M1 in 2020 (16GB Ram with 512GB SSD) was the same price as the current M2 with 512GB SSD GB RAM. And I’ve found out that 16GB Ram was overkill. The M2 would beat it in every metric.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.