Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

oblomow

macrumors 601
Apr 14, 2005
4,508
18,899
Netherlands
3ca737d493714c9b75a5efdf42cc1084.jpg


Spiegelwaal ( mirror-Waal), a bypass of the river Waal to protect the city from high levels of water
see https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spiegelwaal#/media/File:Spiegelwaal.jpg for a birds perspective
 
Last edited:

Hughmac

macrumors 603
Original poster
Feb 4, 2012
6,001
32,567
Kent, UK
Is it still July 2nd on your side of the pond?
No, it's the 3rd, and I've just realised this has been running a day longer than it should have :eek:

As I've given a 12 hour warning, perhaps we could just carry on until 20.00 UK time? A little over two hours away...

Cheers :)

Hugh
 
  • Like
Reactions: mollyc

Hughmac

macrumors 603
Original poster
Feb 4, 2012
6,001
32,567
Kent, UK
OK, the challenge is now finished.

Back in a while with results (as long as it takes ;))

Cheers :)

Hugh
 

Hughmac

macrumors 603
Original poster
Feb 4, 2012
6,001
32,567
Kent, UK
What a lovely set of entries and a good effort from everybody.
Apologies for getting the timing wrong ;)
The following comments are my own opinion as an amateur and should be taken with a pinch of salt:-

@deep diver - A lovely happy sunny scene. I like the distortion in the reflection which one usually tries to correct in photographs, but in this case it is intentional and effective.

@AllergyDoc - Plenty of fragmentation and distortion going on here, giving an interesting point of view. However I fear there's a little too much brightness in places.

@Darmok N Jalad - Still water makes a good mirror, and the black and white treatment does it justice. A little more contrast might make it even better.

@malofx - Oh if only you hadn't mentioned the feet; I wouldn't have noticed anything amiss in an otherwise great photo. If you can't clone in a pair of feet at the top the only other way I can think of dealing with this is to crop your feet off at the bottom, but I think that doesn't look quite right.

@The Bad Guy - I've seen this one before and it's more than just making up the numbers. Great as always; I especially like the post processing treatment.

@mollyc - A real mirror as you say, and another reflection within the reflection. Lovely.

@akash.nu - Thanks for being brave enough to enter; this one works well.

@inkmich - It's always worth submitting a photo even if it looks similar to another entry. I like the mix of blue shades and sunny reflections.

@Alexander.Of.Oz - Lovely. I like the lighting and the way the woodlouse's texture shows up. Quite a muted reflection, visible but works well.

@Apple fanboy - I love a nice rose; the way this hangs in the air against its reflection is nicely done.

@Janichsan - Clever. Not sure how you got yourself into this shot but it comes out well.

@anotherscotsman - Full of Beans today, this one mind boggling with so many versions of yourself in view. Nice.

@needfx - Not sure I get this as there's no obvious mirror image. However it's a lovely photo.

@Donka - Well positioned shot to get perfect symmetry. I like it.

@oblomow - A nice shot of a reflection in twilight. Looks like a great sunset is brewing in the background.

As usual difficult to judge as there was such a high standard of entries, which makes it only the worse to split hairs and disappoint people.

However, my personal picks are:-

1st - @Alexander.Of.Oz

2nd - @The Bad Guy

3rd - @mollyc

Very well done to everyone...

Cheers :)

Hugh
 

deep diver

macrumors 68030
Jan 17, 2008
2,711
4,521
Philadelphia.
What a lovely set of entries and a good effort from everybody.
Apologies for getting the timing wrong ;)
The following comments are my own opinion as an amateur and should be taken with a pinch of salt:-

@deep diver - A lovely happy sunny scene. I like the distortion in the reflection which one usually tries to correct in photographs, but in this case it is intentional and effective.

@AllergyDoc - Plenty of fragmentation and distortion going on here, giving an interesting point of view. However I fear there's a little too much brightness in places.

@Darmok N Jalad - Still water makes a good mirror, and the black and white treatment does it justice. A little more contrast might make it even better.

@malofx - Oh if only you hadn't mentioned the feet; I wouldn't have noticed anything amiss in an otherwise great photo. If you can't clone in a pair of feet at the top the only other way I can think of dealing with this is to crop your feet off at the bottom, but I think that doesn't look quite right.

@The Bad Guy - I've seen this one before and it's more than just making up the numbers. Great as always; I especially like the post processing treatment.

@mollyc - A real mirror as you say, and another reflection within the reflection. Lovely.

@akash.nu - Thanks for being brave enough to enter; this one works well.

@inkmich - It's always worth submitting a photo even if it looks similar to another entry. I like the mix of blue shades and sunny reflections.

@Alexander.Of.Oz - Lovely. I like the lighting and the way the woodlouse's texture shows up. Quite a muted reflection, visible but works well.

@Apple fanboy - I love a nice rose; the way this hangs in the air against its reflection is nicely done.

@Janichsan - Clever. Not sure how you got yourself into this shot but it comes out well.

@anotherscotsman - Full of Beans today, this one mind boggling with so many versions of yourself in view. Nice.

@needfx - Not sure I get this as there's no obvious mirror image. However it's a lovely photo.

@Donka - Well positioned shot to get perfect symmetry. I like it.

@oblomow - A nice shot of a reflection in twilight. Looks like a great sunset is brewing in the background.

As usual difficult to judge as there was such a high standard of entries, which makes it only the worse to split hairs and disappoint people.

However, my personal picks are:-

1st - @Alexander.Of.Oz

2nd - @The Bad Guy

3rd - @mollyc

Very well done to everyone...

Cheers :)

Hugh


Great entries. Great judging. The wins are all well deserved. I thought Alex' image was the winner from the moment I saw it. The subtleness of the reflection is what makes this so striking.

Can't wait for the next one. I wonder if it will have anything to do with puppy names. :confused:
 
Last edited:

Apple fanboy

macrumors Ivy Bridge
Feb 21, 2012
57,003
56,024
Behind the Lens, UK
What a lovely set of entries and a good effort from everybody.
Apologies for getting the timing wrong ;)
The following comments are my own opinion as an amateur and should be taken with a pinch of salt:-

@deep diver - A lovely happy sunny scene. I like the distortion in the reflection which one usually tries to correct in photographs, but in this case it is intentional and effective.

@AllergyDoc - Plenty of fragmentation and distortion going on here, giving an interesting point of view. However I fear there's a little too much brightness in places.

@Darmok N Jalad - Still water makes a good mirror, and the black and white treatment does it justice. A little more contrast might make it even better.

@malofx - Oh if only you hadn't mentioned the feet; I wouldn't have noticed anything amiss in an otherwise great photo. If you can't clone in a pair of feet at the top the only other way I can think of dealing with this is to crop your feet off at the bottom, but I think that doesn't look quite right.

@The Bad Guy - I've seen this one before and it's more than just making up the numbers. Great as always; I especially like the post processing treatment.

@mollyc - A real mirror as you say, and another reflection within the reflection. Lovely.

@akash.nu - Thanks for being brave enough to enter; this one works well.

@inkmich - It's always worth submitting a photo even if it looks similar to another entry. I like the mix of blue shades and sunny reflections.

@Alexander.Of.Oz - Lovely. I like the lighting and the way the woodlouse's texture shows up. Quite a muted reflection, visible but works well.

@Apple fanboy - I love a nice rose; the way this hangs in the air against its reflection is nicely done.

@Janichsan - Clever. Not sure how you got yourself into this shot but it comes out well.

@anotherscotsman - Full of Beans today, this one mind boggling with so many versions of yourself in view. Nice.

@needfx - Not sure I get this as there's no obvious mirror image. However it's a lovely photo.

@Donka - Well positioned shot to get perfect symmetry. I like it.

@oblomow - A nice shot of a reflection in twilight. Looks like a great sunset is brewing in the background.

As usual difficult to judge as there was such a high standard of entries, which makes it only the worse to split hairs and disappoint people.

However, my personal picks are:-

1st - @Alexander.Of.Oz

2nd - @The Bad Guy

3rd - @mollyc

Very well done to everyone...

Cheers :)

Hugh
Well done everyone. Even those that shot with mirrorless and therefore should have been disqualified :D

Great set of images and good critique for all Hugh.

Here's a set up shot.
IMG_3888.JPG


Notice Mrs AFB was kind enough to lend a hand as well as let me borrow one of her photo boards I bought her!
[doublepost=1530660260][/doublepost]
Congratulations to the winners - Alexander’s was certainly my favourite with AFB a close second. Good theme Hugh
Very kind of you to say so.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.