With or without the widgets, navigating around the home screen to and from apps is slower and more inefficient than I would like.
The root cause of this is that the widgets need a place to live.
Even if you remove all the widgets you still have 6 blank pages. Ergo, I don't like widgets.
Long before I ever used iOS, I used MiUI. I found the launcher of that ROM to be a decent compromise between apps and widgets. But most other launchers bury your apps in a drawer. At least many nowadays allow you some level of organization in the drawer.
I don't think this topic really deserves this level of discussion, either.