Launchers
Now it seems to me that there are three primary players in the alternative launcher category, each with its own loyal user base but all accomplishing essentially the same purpose: giving you instant access to your computer, files, and applications, without having to navigate Finder to find and use them. I'm particularly curious to see how Spotlight will hold its ground against these guys... when, in effect, it sounds like Spotlight is designed to do the exact same thing, just perhaps with more sophisticated metadata and complete integration with OS X.
There's
Objective Development's LaunchBar (shareware, $39);
Peter Maurer's Butler (freeware, previously called "Another Launcher"); and
BlackTree's QuickSilver (freeware).
Although I'd heard of LaunchBar previously, I've never used it until today; a few weeks ago, I discovered QuickSilver (v. B24) and have thoroughly enjoyed it. Today, I both heard about and installed Butler, and revisited LaunchBar as well, to compare.
Perhaps somebody would be interested in doing a complete comparison between the three applications? From my brief experience with the three together, they all seem to do the basic functions equally well and similarly fast. They all seem to take up about the same processing in the Activity Monitor -- all take up 2 threads (which is far better than the process-hog Konfabulator). All three pull up their "search" box with a shortcut key (QuickSilver's and LaunchBar's default with Command-Space; I'm having a bit of a time trying to find where it specifies that Butler's is Ctrl-Space and how I might change it).
Upon a cursory glance, a few things that interested me:
LaunchBar has... extensive configuration to offer, though it can all seem quite daunting. It also has very robust integration with iTunes, and I was able to pull up any individual song, or an Artist, Album, Playlist (or even Composer) quickly. It does have internet searching capability (somewhat), but it's a bit nestled away in the program and not very convenient. It also has the tremendously nifty feature to not only scan Photo Albums in iPhoto, but the actual photos and names of photos themselves, though it opens them in Preview and not iPhoto as I would like. It's also not terribly appealing visually, and pricey for shareware. Overall, I'm not terribly impressed and don't think I'll be using it too much in the future.
Butler has... probably the most profound and cool features, not to mention the most of them, after a bit of customization. Not only does it offer the shortcut key to pull up a little window to search for things, but it plants a little search box in the Toolbar. Click the drop-down arrow, and you can select where to search... Google, IMDB, Dictionary.com, some news sites, etc. It also places two other small icons on the toolbar, next to the search. One is for the Internet -- basically a Bookmark bar -- and the other gives you complete access to your computer, with menus within to show your Applications, Documents, System Preferences, Volumes, Pasteboard (clipboard, essentially -- sounds promising in its uses), and lastly, allowing you to Switch Users on the fly. It also offers tremendous customization; for instance, with just a little bit of effort, I was able to place Next Track and Last Track "smart buttons" for iTunes in my toolbar. Hit any iTunes related smart button, I've found, and it also displays a brief Info window about the song. Already, it seems like this functionality could be a great (and free!) Synergy replacement.
QuickSilver has... pretty much the standard keyboard shortcut/search thing, but it does it all with such style. Apparently, BlackTree has released a v. B25, which outdates my v. B24 -- so I can't say quite yet whether Butler can beat it. (Apparently v. B25 offers further web integration and searching capabilities, likely to match Butler's.) It also offers a fair bit of customization, and thankfully in a less confusing and more simplistic manner than both LaunchBar and Butler do. But the thing I've loved the most about this little piece of software is how it does everything with sheer style. I have it set on Bevel appearance right now (though it does have three other views), which is very akin to Panther's Alt-Tab application switching in appearance (on purpose, I believe). It takes full advantage of the glorious beauty of OS X's icons (application and otherwise), like the Panther switcher, and one real neat thing is when you start typing in your friend's name and -- if you have a Thumbnail image for him in Address Book -- it'll display his image. Very, very sleek. It also has a Clipboard and a Shelf, for you to keep things on as you need them. Finally, it seems to manage things better than Butler, too -- search for a name in your Address Book, and it doesn't spill all out all his information right there, with multiple results for "Joey," "Joey's Cell Phone," "Joey's Work Phone," etc. Instead, it simply displays "Joey," and requires you to hit the right arrow key to see his various phone numbers, emails, and such. With applications and documents, this right arrow key function allows you to define what you want to do with said application or document -- open it, reveal it in the Finder, open it with another application, etc. Cleans up the mess nicely, without a load of results with your search.
All in all, while I still have to download the latest version of QuickSilver, on my cursory review I'm most impressed with both Butler and QuickSilver. I'm very impressed with Butler's fine search thingy that it inserted on the toolbar (though it is removeable), and I also am quite fancying the "smart buttons" I've managed to place up there as well. Still, QuickSilver seems to have it's act more together, and provides a far more appealing experience. LaunchBar I was less than pleased with, and the fact that it costs money while the others are free kinda turns me off.
I'll definitely try to spend more time with Butler, and the new version of QuickSilver, over the next few days, though, and give a report.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c4fb/1c4fb4a004ac374ae735c210f8560be0dce354ac" alt="Smile :) :)"