Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
SoftRAID doesn't seem to work well on iMP. Their website lists a problem of infinite loop of driver updates. I encountered that. I also had terrible performance on writing under RAID5. (Reading performance is fine. Writing is 5x slower, which is not acceptable.) I was hoping that I could use SoftRAID's RAID5 to give some protection to the data. But given the poor RAID5 performance and its driver issue, I went back to Apple's RAID0.

1. The driver update issue is a combo of High Sierra and the iMP ‘s Security enclave, this will get sorted out in an official capacity but in the meantime there is a workaround in that you go into recovery mode and change the security setting and the update works fine, it did for me.

2. Degraded write performance is specific to High Sierra’s sporadic and yet inadvertent choice to quarantine certified developers. There is a thread on Softraid’s site that gives the terminal commands to correct it. Again, not the final fix to be sure but until the next OS update it does the trick.

For what it’s worth, I have 5 Thunderbay cases running various sizes of Softraid RAID-5 and RAID-0. For the most part, all seem fine on my iMac Pro in terms of performance. There have been odd slow downs on writes at times but usually they are pretty consistent.

I did a backup of some 12TB of data in chunks that varied between 300GB to 6TB of data between two 4 drive 40TB RAID-5 arrays. Average speeds were between 500-750mb write and 700-950mb read.

Brand new hardware+ an OS that is pretty damn buggy and you will have issues. I’m in this for the long haul and can work with it as long as progress is made. I am also getting my work done very fast, did a full day ad shoot today with my Nikon D850, about 60GB of raw files. I manually turned up my fans to 2,000 rpms and blasted through it, client got the deliverables 24 hours early and I got my invoice in early as a result.

So far so good and well worth the coin.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Bryan Bowler
1. The driver update issue is a combo of High Sierra and the iMP ‘s Security enclave, this will get sorted out in an official capacity but in the meantime there is a workaround in that you go into recovery mode and change the security setting and the update works fine, it did for me.

2. Degraded write performance is specific to High Sierra’s sporadic and yet inadvertent choice to quarantine certified developers. There is a thread on Softraid’s site that gives the terminal commands to correct it. Again, not the final fix to be sure but until the next OS update it does the trick.

This definitely grabbed my attention since I currently use two ThunderBays. I will head over to SoftRAID's site and look this up. Thanks for the heads-up! I recently ordered my iMP and it is still inbound from China, but I want to be prepared for the transition.

Brand new hardware+ an OS that is pretty damn buggy and you will have issues. I’m in this for the long haul and can work with it as long as progress is made. I am also getting my work done very fast, did a full day ad shoot today with my Nikon D850, about 60GB of raw files. I manually turned up my fans to 2,000 rpms and blasted through it, client got the deliverables 24 hours early and I got my invoice in early as a result.

So far so good and well worth the coin.

I love hearing reports like this!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Macshroomer
On a different note, I keep setting up my iMP (slowly) these days, and the first frustrating thing appeared yesterday. SoftRAID doesn't seem to work well on iMP. Their website lists a problem of infinite loop of driver updates. I encountered that. I also had terrible performance on writing under RAID5. (Reading performance is fine. Writing is 5x slower, which is not acceptable.) I was hoping that I could use SoftRAID's RAID5 to give some protection to the data. But given the poor RAID5 performance and its driver issue, I went back to Apple's RAID0. Now I have to completely rely on external backup(s) to help protecting my data. This is what I did with my MP. Hopefully it can work equally well on my iMP.
As far as I know the SoftRaid problems are related to HS and they will be fixed in the next version 6.
This was another reason to not upgrade our Macs to HS.
 
Thanks for all the info about SoftRAID. (I am aware of the driver update workaround, but it's just annoying.) Once all the issues are officially sorted out, I can go back to use soft RAID5. Now I will just stay with Apple's RAID0. I have 3 TB-3 enclosures, each with 4 SSDs. I am happy with their RAID0 performance so far.

For Photography, I am using Pentax 645z for astrophotography. Soon I will have a chance to feed many 645z files to the new iMP and see how it goes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fathergll
Thanks for all the info about SoftRAID. (I am aware of the driver update workaround, but it's just annoying.) Once all the issues are officially sorted out, I can go back to use soft RAID5. Now I will just stay with Apple's RAID0. I have 3 TB-3 enclosures, each with 4 SSDs. I am happy with their RAID0 performance so far.

For Photography, I am using Pentax 645z for astrophotography. Soon I will have a chance to feed many 645z files to the new iMP and see how it goes.

Just be careful with Apple's Raid, last time I have checked it was like abandoned, as they have to update it for several years. If something changed lately and I have missed it, please let me know.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlexMaximus
Just be careful with Apple's Raid, last time I have checked it was like abandoned, as they have to update it for several years. If something changed lately and I have missed it, please let me know.

It was once removed from the Disk Utility, but then Apple put it back in the later version of OSX. Even during the short period when the RAID function was not a part of the Disk Utility, existing RAID volumes could still be used. Also, creating RAID volumes could still be done in the command line, I believe. So Apple hasn't really abandoned its RAID. Just for a short period (for whatever reason), it was hidden from the GUI. Now it's part of the Disk Utility and is as good as before. I wouldn't worry about that.
 
It was once removed from the Disk Utility, but then Apple put it back in the later version of OSX. Even during the short period when the RAID function was not a part of the Disk Utility, existing RAID volumes could still be used. Also, creating RAID volumes could still be done in the command line, I believe. So Apple hasn't really abandoned its RAID. Just for a short period (for whatever reason), it was hidden from the GUI. Now it's part of the Disk Utility and is as good as before. I wouldn't worry about that.
Thank you. Yes, I Know about these but I think that Apple's RAID drivers were not updated for many many years.
Just found a, SoftRaid's employee I guess, post from 2016 confirming this:
"Mark James @ 2:31 pm on July 22, 2016
Chris;
We at SoftRAID approve the accuracy of the text in this blog post.

The Apple RAID driver is open source. We actively compare the code and look for enhancements with each OS release. Until this year, the driver had not changed until 2009 and the only change made was to make the driver slightly more secure against hackers.

That is what is meant by “stopped actively working on AppleRAID”. Its true.

Yes, RAID is available via command line, but no, it is not being worked on.
(Some of the Apple RAID GUI functionality is apparently coming back in Sierra)

There are still bugs and data corruption issues in the Apple RAID driver implementation. These kinds of issues have not been addressed by Apple in over 7 years.

Free is great, but if you have mission critical data, consider investing in a product that has been continually improving for over 20 years.

thanks!"
https://blog.macsales.com/37143-beyond-appleraid-softraid-gives-data-a-new-software-raid-home
It's the last post.
Anyway, good luck...
 
Does anyone have any experience in using 3D with their iMac Pro? I glanced quickly through all the replies but didn’t see anyone say anything about 3D...
I will be purchasing the new iMac Pro soon for 3D freelance work and have had a few people provide positive feedback on another forum, but was curious to hear from people here.
 
There are still bugs and data corruption issues in the Apple RAID driver implementation. These kinds of issues have not been addressed by Apple in over 7 years.
.

Thats popular softraid FUD. We've had more softraid corruption than disk utility. Now there may be more features available that are useful for some use cases.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.