For me to ever consider buying an Apple Watch, the absolute must have, is durability.
It must be able to survive being repeatedly smacked against engine blocks, rocks, concrete, power tools, stacks of lumber, and anything else.
It must be able to endure the above daily, repeated impacts against the screen without breaking, or scratching, just like my cheap $30 watches do.
It also needs to be able to survive (as in perfectly unharmed no chance of damage) being submerged under standing and running water daily. I’m not taking my watch off every time I wash grease off my hands. And I’m not taking it off every time I stick my hands to standing water to work on something. Or if I reach into the river, waterfall, etc.
I don’t care what the band looks like. The functional part of the watch, the body and face would have to be built as solid as my cheap Timex stainless steel watch.
For me, anything that isn’t built to survive life, isn’t ready to be a wearable device. If I wear it, then it must be built to survive the same impacts that my body receives.
Once it can survive daily life as well as my cheap Timex, then I’ll start considering what features it might have. Until then, it’s not worth anything to me, because it wouldn’t survive an hour in my life.