I'm a male and I think its a great show, one of my favorites, can't seem to get enough of Violet, Dowager Countess of Grantham. She always has me in stitches
Yes, she is a wonderful character and Dame Maggie Smith is an outstanding actress. There are times, - and this is one of them - where you get the sense that an actor/actress is hugely enjoying themselves while playing particular role.
Downton Abbey? Great show. Reminds me of a 1910s/1920s British Aristocratic version of Dynasty. That, and Call the Midwife. It doesn't help that my wife is looking into becoming a doula.
However, I still keep itching for Violet Crawley to pop someone upside the head with an Expeliarmus.
BL.
But that is exactly what it is! Downton Abbey is almost like a chemistry experiment - what combination of ingredients, or elements, in what ratios, will give a certain (desired) outcome? What is the formula for success?
Julian Fellowes had almost cracked it with the movie 'Gosford Park' where he toyed with a number of the same elements under the narrative disguise of a 1920s country house murder mystery. So, in essence, what you have here is an outstanding cast thoroughly enjoying themselves, a great script, some terrific stories, ensemble playing (as with a good theatre company) rather than everything focussed on one or two leads, a period setting, meticulous and lavishly appointed production values, (which allow you to overlook the sheer implausibility of some of the story lines) and the narrative verve and dash and story telling discipline of a classy soap opera. You cannot lose with this formula .