Additionally, there is a huge stigma surrounding playing "what's appropriate for the repertoire," and "getting down to the last staccato marking in the score." Okay, I think there's something to be said and appreciated about both those things, but I don't necessarily think they apply well in all contexts. The reason why this is promoted in classical tradition is because:
Let me make myself clear though: this - what I have said above - is FINE. Where the issue lies is the fact that this kind of stuff is promoted - from what I have observed in my own experience - EVERYWHERE. It is promoted at conservatories (speaking generally, not of any specific institution), during artist residencies, and "by the laws of the trade," so to speak.
My point is that this concept - what I have just described - either didn't exist, or was not promoted as much as it is now, 300 years ago. Since I don't study this and I'm not a musicologist, I don't know the answer. But I have heard, not only from some YouTube videos made by professional musicians, and by some of my own music instructors - that improvisation was not only allowed in the classical realm 300 years ago, but it was ENCOURAGED.
So clearly this whole "no improvisation allowed!" and "you must follow a specific repertoire!" thing is rather recent.
- According to some people, it is necessary to devise a program where everything fits together perfectly.
- According to some people, a performer needs to appreciate every single element of what the composer wrote, with no room for interpretation.
Let me make myself clear though: this - what I have said above - is FINE. Where the issue lies is the fact that this kind of stuff is promoted - from what I have observed in my own experience - EVERYWHERE. It is promoted at conservatories (speaking generally, not of any specific institution), during artist residencies, and "by the laws of the trade," so to speak.
My point is that this concept - what I have just described - either didn't exist, or was not promoted as much as it is now, 300 years ago. Since I don't study this and I'm not a musicologist, I don't know the answer. But I have heard, not only from some YouTube videos made by professional musicians, and by some of my own music instructors - that improvisation was not only allowed in the classical realm 300 years ago, but it was ENCOURAGED.
So clearly this whole "no improvisation allowed!" and "you must follow a specific repertoire!" thing is rather recent.