I've purchased and sampled quite a few so far for my 12 Pro in graphite, keeping some and sending back others (not sure at what point Amazon prohibits free returns on your account, but I wouldn't be shocked if I was getting close):
Tried and Returned:
- Apple leather in saddle and baltic blue (liked the Mag Safe and fit, but felt the leather quality was sorely lacking compared to prior Apple leather cases I've had)
- Apple silicone in Cyprus Green (really liked this case, and especially the color - just hard justifying the price)
- Mujjo leather in slate green (leather was okay, but the buttons were sub par)
- Tech 21 Evo Clear (liked it fine, but not for the price when other clear cases seemed just fine)
- Otterbox Symmetry Clear (fit well - not as difficult to install and remove as some have said, IMO - but didn't think the price was justified)
- ESR Cloud Series (didn't like it at all - too flimsy)
- Spigen Ultra Hybrid clear (not bad, but liked the ESR Tough Clear better and they were the same price)
- Spigen Thin Fit in Red (liked the case but returned the red and ordered a different color - see below)
- CYRILL Color Brick (overall, solid case, good grip, fingerprint magnet on back cover; had bought a very similar one that basically made this a duplicate, so no need to keep)
- TORRAS Crystal Clear (case looks good and is nice and thing, but the buttons were terrible)
- Tech21 Evo Slim (really liked this case, as it had a nice feel in the hand - not too slick, but nice and smooth - but couldn't justify keeping it for the price when I have other black cases already. Had I ordered it prior to the Spigen Liquid Air Armor, might have kept this one instead).
Kept:
- TORRAS Shockproof (basically the same as the Color Brick - grippy sides with the matte, translucent back. Wish I'd kept the box longer and I would have returned this and potentially kept the Color Brick since it was a few buck less and they seem to basically be the same case)
- ESR Tough Clear (good little clear case - nothing special, but looks pretty good, fits well, buttons are good, and was inexpensive)
- Ringke Onyx (ordered gray, green, black, and navy - kept the Navy and returned the other colors)
- Spigen Thin Fit in Navy Blue (really like this case - back is fairly slick but has a great color and feel, but sides are grippy enough. Fits well, buttons work great, and the navy blue color is great. These seem to come in somewhat different materials depending on the color - my wife has this one in the mint green color and it's more of a silicone feel across the full case, versus this that fees more plastic/metallic on the back)
- Spigen Liquid Air Armor (like this case overall - texture is pretty good, buttons work well, allegedly provides a bit of drop protection)
- Bullstrap leather in Sienna color (love this case and is on par with the prior Apple leather cases that I've had. Smells great, buttons are great.)
On the way to try out:
- Urban Armor Gear Civilian in Mallard - wanting something with a bit more protection when needed than the others I've got/have kept, and after seeing a lot of folks talk about it, couldn't resist with the 25% end of year discount. It's supposed to be here Wednesday.
- Caudabe Sheath in Ocean Blue for me and Sea Green for the wife - everyone who has one seems to rave about it, and I am a sucker for all things blue, so wanted to give it a try, and seemed like a decent deal with the 20% off they've been doing the last week or so.