To me the only issue was how wide that it felt. I would say like a Tech 21 from last year. Just skinny wide on the edgesYes this Catalyst case is great. The buttons are very tactical and easy to press. The case has firm TPU rubber that keeps the phone tight in the case but easy to remove. Every thing about this case is great, no sagging or loose top or bottom and sides. The sound forward speakers sound great, overall this case is a keeper.