I have these two as well. I like the color of the abyss, but I don’t like the way it attracts dust and lint. The Dark Cherry leather case is perfect as usual. I also have the Midnight Blue. I usually buy light colors in silicone and dark colors in leather, I need them to sell the Product Red leather again.
Yeah I would have went with a leather Product Red so was disappointed when that wasn't available. The silicone version of it is too bright for me when I checked it out in the Apple Store.