Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

CooperBox

macrumors 68000
I'd be much interested to see such a write up. Since I'm new to vintage or classic watches I'm not even sure what 'homage' really means in this aspect. So go ahead take the time and do a full write up as I'm sure many here would appreciate it.
I will in due course do a write-up together with photos on the homage watch that was gifted to me earlier this year. I’d read much about the history of the make and it's founder, and the watch is certainly exceeding my expectations in terms of quality and accuracy.
In the meantime, to learn a little more about homage watches in general, there’s a fascinating article HERE from a very respected industry professional on his watch website ‘Hodinkee', and he openly admits he wouldn't be where he is today without having owned an homage model. Entitled ’There’s Nothing Wrong With An Homage Watch’, yourself and others may wish to check it out for more info on why these watches tick so many boxes for first-time buyers and collectors alike.
I don’t propose for a second that the article will change ‘myscrnnm’s’ views about these watches, but nevertheless there are some particularly interesting points raised in the article. Especially take note of his closing paragraph.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DeepIn2U

DMG35

Contributor
May 27, 2021
2,526
8,162
Ordered this a while ago and it finally came in. Love it.

IMG_1760.JPG
 

CooperBox

macrumors 68000
Ordered this a while ago and it finally came in. Love it.

View attachment 2043002

A pleasant looking Rolex, and like most owners I'm sure you'll be happy with it. My experience however was a little different.
I purchased a SeaDweller 16600 in 1999. It came as a full set, i.e. original box, little anchor, all papers etc. The previous owner stated he'd worn it less than 5 times and as I couldn't see a mark on it thought it was too good to pass over, especially at the amazing price I was able to negotiate. Up until that time I still had a s/s Datejust 1601 purchased new and which I'd worn daily for at least 40years.
The SeaDweller was nice but I wore it so infrequently. One often hears the comment, "Just wear it and forget it" and that's fine imho for those who can easily afford to replace or have their expensive watches serviced, repaired if damaged or even lost. Just last month I read of someone who'd been mugged outside Covent Garden in London and had his Daytona stolen from him. Ouch! I can't help wondering if he replaced it for another or opted for a similar looking 'homage'.;)

I probably wore the SeaDweller no more than a total of 10 times, simply because I became almost 'paranoid' about damaging it. That may sound crazy but I never felt that with the Datejust, maybe due to having paid relatively less for it and especially for it not having the stratospheric valuation of the SeaDweller. I thought seriously about keeping the latter looking 'as new' and giving to my son in later years. A short time later his apartment was broken into and several valuables taken, including another rather expensive watch I'd previously gifted to him - he hadn't locked the valuables away safely as I'd often suggested he should. So not wanting the SeaDweller to suffer a similar fate in years ahead, a short time time later I decided to sell it. And no regrets whatsoever.
All my other less expensive collectable watches I do rotate, plus most get reasonable wrist time and I don't worry the slightest if they pick up the odd scratch on the clasp, the bezel or even the case itself - and that even includes my El Primo and also original ST 105.012 'pre-moon' c.321 Moonwatch. Fortunately that SeaDweller crazy 'paranoid' feeling is now behind me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe

Saritune

macrumors newbie
Nov 14, 2017
12
18
Hello! Thank you everyone for this thread; reading through these posts is a great way to learn more about the world of horology and your stories connecting timepieces to traditions & personal significance is really wonderful. Here is my collection. I treasure all of these because they've marked the different phases of my life thus far and looking back at them helps me remember and reconnect with the past.

Saritune's timepieces.png
 

myscrnnm

macrumors 68000
Sep 16, 2014
1,941
1,660
Seattle, WA
28B56E7B-D0F7-43DF-8580-4358DA44E469.jpeg
Not a nice watch from a quality perspective, in fact by far the worst watch I own; but based on the hype around the Moonswatch you’d think it was. I had tried finding it at the New York and Las Vegas boutiques earlier this year with no luck, but happened to be in Vancouver this last weekend and they had almost all the Moonswatches at the Metrotown store. I only got the Mission to Mars because it’s my favorite out of all the designs, being inspired by the Speedmaster Alaska Project, and also the only Moonswatch with lumed chronograph hands. For such a cheap watch, it actually has a pretty interesting movement. The chronograph is accurate to one-tenth of a second and it also has a zero-reset when the crown is pulled. Here it is next to a watch that has actually been used in space, and also the one I was wearing this weekend.
 

PinkyMacGodess

Suspended
Mar 7, 2007
10,271
6,227
Midwest America.
View attachment 2101432 Not a nice watch from a quality perspective, in fact by far the worst watch I own; but based on the hype around the Moonswatch you’d think it was. I had tried finding it at the New York and Las Vegas boutiques earlier this year with no luck, but happened to be in Vancouver this last weekend and they had almost all the Moonswatches at the Metrotown store. I only got the Mission to Mars because it’s my favorite out of all the designs, being inspired by the Speedmaster Alaska Project, and also the only Moonswatch with lumed chronograph hands. For such a cheap watch, it actually has a pretty interesting movement. The chronograph is accurate to one-tenth of a second and it also has a zero-reset when the crown is pulled. Here it is next to a watch that has actually been used in space, and also the one I was wearing this weekend.

Heuer came out with some 'cheap watches' back in the 80's. Kind of based on the 'standard chronograph', but with a plastic covered metal case. They sold a bunch of them and I owned at least three. And can't find a damned on today. Sad... I can't figure out what happened to them. Weird. They were great looking watches that came in an array of colors and were pretty durable, but sadly I can't find a damn one of them. 😞
 

Saritune

macrumors newbie
Nov 14, 2017
12
18
View attachment 2101432 Not a nice watch from a quality perspective, in fact by far the worst watch I own; but based on the hype around the Moonswatch you’d think it was. I had tried finding it at the New York and Las Vegas boutiques earlier this year with no luck, but happened to be in Vancouver this last weekend and they had almost all the Moonswatches at the Metrotown store. I only got the Mission to Mars because it’s my favorite out of all the designs, being inspired by the Speedmaster Alaska Project, and also the only Moonswatch with lumed chronograph hands. For such a cheap watch, it actually has a pretty interesting movement. The chronograph is accurate to one-tenth of a second and it also has a zero-reset when the crown is pulled. Here it is next to a watch that has actually been used in space, and also the one I was wearing this weekend.
Both of those are really cool. I dig the Mars edition :D
 

myscrnnm

macrumors 68000
Sep 16, 2014
1,941
1,660
Seattle, WA
Heuer came out with some 'cheap watches' back in the 80's. Kind of based on the 'standard chronograph', but with a plastic covered metal case. They sold a bunch of them and I owned at least three. And can't find a damned on today. Sad... I can't figure out what happened to them. Weird. They were great looking watches that came in an array of colors and were pretty durable, but sadly I can't find a damn one of them. 😞
That reminds me of the Formula 1 watches they did in the 90s with plastic bezels, which were very much a product of their time...
Both of those are really cool. I dig the Mars edition :D
Thanks! Would love to add the Apollo 8 Speedmaster to the collection next. A lot of the watch collecting community often criticizes Omega for doing too many Speedmaster editions, but I think the variety is great for us consumers. Certainly makes more sense than going ga-ga anytime Rolex releases a new dial color.🙄
IMG_0372.jpg
 

PinkyMacGodess

Suspended
Mar 7, 2007
10,271
6,227
Midwest America.
That reminds me of the Formula 1 watches they did in the 90s with plastic bezels, which were very much a product of their time...

That's what they were. I had the yellow and a blue one. Loved the look, loved the fit, but they didn't last long. The batteries ran out pretty quickly. Getting the batteries swapped wasn't inexpensive either. I tried to open one with a hammer and chisel. Spent the next hour in the ER. (Maybe that's why they disappeared? Freudian, or wifeian? I felt so stupid, showing up with my hand wrapped in a couple washcloths. Get professional help, even if it is expensive. It's usually less embarrassing, humiliating :D:rolleyes::cool:)
 

PinkyMacGodess

Suspended
Mar 7, 2007
10,271
6,227
Midwest America.
I would try wearing more of my 'other watches', but given how many I've damaged, I keep the Apple Watch because, so far, it seems far more durable. Surprising considering how many people insist it's not. *shrug* Plus it seems, weirdly, that my world is on my wrist. :rolleyes::cool:
 

OllyW

Moderator
Staff member
Oct 11, 2005
17,196
6,800
The Black Country, England
I would try wearing more of my 'other watches', but given how many I've damaged, I keep the Apple Watch because, so far, it seems far more durable. Surprising considering how many people insist it's not. *shrug* Plus it seems, weirdly, that my world is on my wrist. :rolleyes::cool:
I still wear my Apple Watch for sleep tracking, cycling, walking and when I’m at work and have no worries about its durability. I’m just enjoying wearing something that’s different and a bit more stylish after 5 years of having a digital screen on my wrist.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PinkyMacGodess

PinkyMacGodess

Suspended
Mar 7, 2007
10,271
6,227
Midwest America.
I still wear my Apple Watch for sleep tracking, cycling, walking and when I’m at work and have no worries about its durability. I’m just enjoying wearing something that’s different and a bit more stylish after 5 years of having a digital screen on my wrist.

I love my auto TAG Carrera, but after wearing it to just three months, the case was covered with small scratches. I was horrified, and probably skipped a few beats. It was definitely NOT for everyday wearing, but it looked SO AWESOME! A beautiful blue face, a crystal covered back to see the innards, an elegant band, it was/is a great watch. Covered with small scratches. It has that 'lived in/on look'.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OllyW

rain111

macrumors 65816
Sep 19, 2012
1,322
663
UK
My Collection so far... don't judge, but I hardly wear them, 90% of the time, they are in a watch winder, and I mostly wear my Apple Watch... mad?

Note: Oak & Nautilus Perpetual are fakes, so there is no confusion.
 
Last edited:

myscrnnm

macrumors 68000
Sep 16, 2014
1,941
1,660
Seattle, WA
My Collection so far... don't judge, but I hardly wear them, 90% of the time, they are in a watch winder, and I mostly wear my Apple Watch... mad?

View attachment 2113082
Are all of these fakes? Or just most of them? The date window on the Royal Oak is way too small; and there is no Royal Oak that has a combination of a white date wheel and lumed 3 o'clock marker. The hands on the subdials for the Nautilus Perpetual Calendar are way too fat. And the typeface on the Datejust date wheel is wrong.

Edit: Also the case and bracelet finishing on the Nautilus Perpetual Calendar looks like it was done by a blind man.
 
Last edited:

rain111

macrumors 65816
Sep 19, 2012
1,322
663
UK
Are all of these fakes? Or just most of them? The date window on the Royal Oak is way too small; and there is no Royal Oak that has a combination of a white date wheel and lumed 3 o'clock marker. The hands on the subdials for the Nautilus Perpetual Calendar are way too fat. And the typeface on the Datejust date wheel is wrong.
Oak & Nautilus Perpetual are fake, the rest are real, although I am on the waiting list in my AD to get a real Oak for while now.

updated my post to reflect a few details.
 

Madhatter32

macrumors 65816
Apr 17, 2020
1,476
2,946
My Collection so far... don't judge, but I hardly wear them, 90% of the time, they are in a watch winder, and I mostly wear my Apple Watch... mad?

Note: Oak & Nautilus Perpetual are fakes, so there is no confusion.

View attachment 2113100
I think I would wear any of these (except the fakes) over an Apple Watch unless I am exercising or need to monitor my heart because I have heart disease or something. Nice selection.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rain111

rain111

macrumors 65816
Sep 19, 2012
1,322
663
UK
I think I would wear any of these (except the fakes) over an Apple Watch unless I am exercising or need to monitor my heart because I have heart disease or something. Nice selection.
I exercise 6 days a week, which is why I wear my apple watch most the time, mostly wear them when i go out with the wife or special event, it is too risky to go out with them all day and expensive, but I try.

And thanks, also right about the fake ones, Oak will be gone soon when my AD calls when I can collect my reservation ( its been over a year), Nautilus Perpetual just out of reach, keeping it for the sake of it lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Madhatter32

rain111

macrumors 65816
Sep 19, 2012
1,322
663
UK
honestly, I would wear the Apple Watch on the other arm if I had a heart condition. There's no class in an Apple Watch.
I tried that a while back, but it felt weird and uncomfortable wearing a watch on my right hand, even forced myself to have it on for a month straight and couldn't get used to it.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.