Being open, it forces you to give up desk space, resize windows across disparate sized screens, contend with color accuracy/profiles and brightness differences.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Why do people use clamshell mode?
- Thread starter LiE_
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Do you bring your Air in addition to a work-provided machine? Does your office do BYOD (device)? Or when you say “my” is it actually the company’s laptop?
It does if your desk is small or doesn't have a lot of extra space. Do you want to know why people use clamshell, or do you want to tell people they are wrong for doing so?
So you want a small screen that uses up a disproportionate amount of desk space.
It’s a work provided Mac, I can choose freely which computer and setup I want however.
Isn't it nice to be able to sit further than 2 feet away and still be able to see? 😂
How is a tiny-looking screen next to my 27” monitor going to help me? I’m going to have to have it closer to me so I don’t have to squint, it’ll take up more desk space, and it’s not ergonomic visually or physically. It would feel more like a hindrance than a help.
I need a desktop 90% of the time. I need a laptop 10% of the time. Therefore, I must have a laptop. I only need 1 screen 99% of the time (there is ONE use case where I use dual screens, only a few times per year, having laptop is advantageous because it has a screen built in), especially when using my LG UltraFine 5K (The "Apple" one).
My 16" MBP Intel is in Clamshell mode 90% of the time. But, i do need a laptop occasionally. And the second screen occasionally.
So that is why i have a laptop and use it in clamshell mode most of the time. I have a feeling that is a common reason and answer to this question.
My 16" MBP Intel is in Clamshell mode 90% of the time. But, i do need a laptop occasionally. And the second screen occasionally.
So that is why i have a laptop and use it in clamshell mode most of the time. I have a feeling that is a common reason and answer to this question.
lol this is such a Mac Rumors thread.
If you had a more valid question, then you might expect more answers.
Yours is a statement - making a point - with a question mark at the end. That does not make it a question by itself, -- but it fits perfectly with the definition for a rhetorical question, which, like your statement, does not usually need an answer. Answering your statement with either a yes or no suggests acceptance of the statement that you made.
(I hope I am not being too pedantic about this... )
One one reason is that until the Mac Studio was released (and is STILL hard to get), the 14" and 16" MacBook Pros were the most powerful computers.
There is practically no performance difference between the M1 iMac, Mac Mini and the M1 MacBook Air.
I do not use my M1 MacBook Air in clamshell mode.
I have it sitting on top of a monitor riser stand and use a 4K monitor as my primary display. I park the keyboard and mouse under the riser stand when not in use to free up desk clutter.
Now even though my MacBook Air is open, the screen really doesn't do much. It is too small to do a lot with, and I might keep mail or Music app in the foreground while I do my work on the main screen. I am also used to working with multiple displays and will often have working apps on one screen and research/web apps on the other.
I have it sitting on top of a monitor riser stand and use a 4K monitor as my primary display. I park the keyboard and mouse under the riser stand when not in use to free up desk clutter.
Now even though my MacBook Air is open, the screen really doesn't do much. It is too small to do a lot with, and I might keep mail or Music app in the foreground while I do my work on the main screen. I am also used to working with multiple displays and will often have working apps on one screen and research/web apps on the other.
I have two Dell 4K Displays. They are very easy on my old eyes and 27" each. So the laptop stays closed because it's just in the way at that point. I also use a Logi MX Keys Wireless keyboard and Mouse. They are nice and support switching to other computers on my desk with one click.
My M1 MBP is in Clamshell mode 90% of the time. Clamshell Mode is a very elegant solution when using a slide-in dock like the one from brydge. And still being able to use the MBP as a laptop occasionally is a nice bonus...
Performance - specifically for Intel models - is a big consideration. In clamshell mode the MacBook is driving only one display, but when open it is two. This affects both VRAM and GPU usage.
Kinda seems like you’re just trying to upset the guy. This whole thread seems kinda pointless. Why do people use a computer for the lap at a desk… because they want to?
Well this is a dumb thread but why not. I use my laptop in clamshell mode when I'm at my desk, and as a laptop when I'm anywhere else. I don't want to look at more than one screen at my desk, so I use clamshell mode instead of leaving it open.
It's been said before but if you have a job typically you are issued a laptop which you dock at your desk, carry around and use in laptop mode for meetings in boardrooms, then dock it at home for remote work, or use in laptop mode when on vacation in case of work emergencies.
Connected t 2 x colour accurate 27" screens. Apple glossy screens aren't for me. Only time I use it as a laptop is in meetings or when travelling.