Today marks a week since I’ve gotten the AirPods Max. I’m undecided if I will keep them or not.
The sound quality + convenience of Apple ecosystem + $429 price I bought them at was my motivation for buying. Before the Max, I used AirPods Pro basically everywhere (office, exercising outside, at the gym, at home while doing chores, at home while relaxing), while I reserved my Sennheiser HD 650s + Schiit DAC and Amp for when I wanted to truly get the best music quality and was willing to sacrifice convenience, comfort, and portability for audio quality. I bought APM hoping that it could provide me a middle ground where I could get the convenience of AirPods, yet get much better audio quality while relaxing around the house, getting work done, etc.
The APM live up to that goal for me, but I‘m worried it creates too much redundancy for an expensive price. For example, I basically only use my AirPods Pro for exercise now, which makes me feel like I’m wasting the money I’ve spent on them (even though I’ve already used them religiously since launch day). The AirPods Pro are also a more comfortable and convenient form factor. Your ears don’t get hot/sweaty, you can put them in your pocket, they take up less space in bag, there’s less concern about damaging them, and they attract less attention. Speaking of sweat, I also do get condensation pretty often when wearing the APM for 40+ minutes (while stationary, indoors, in a non-humid ~70 degrees environment), which makes me a little concerned for their longevity.
Additionally, the AirPods Max sound great, but when I’m listening to music while working, I’m so distracted with work that I’m not even fully appreciating/noticing the sound most of the time anyways. This makes me wonder why I don’t just stick with the AirPods Pro. When I do relax in bed with my iPhone and AirPods Max (way more convenient than moving DAC, Amp, HD 650s, all their cords, and my large 12.9” iPad Pro to my bedroom) and focus purely on the music, I can’t help but be thinking about how much nicer the music would sound on my HD 650s. Don’t get me wrong, the APM sounds great, but the HD 650s have so much clarity and balance that it makes you feel like you‘re listening to the “source material” of the song whereas APM kinda feels like there‘s a filter or processing layer over everything if you really pay attention.
I really enjoy the AirPods Max, but I just can’t decide if it’s worth it to spend almost $500 (with taxes) while also creating redundancy with the expensive headphones I already own.