No kidding. There's a lot of artificial sharpening in the iPhone images, - the edge enhancement is not great.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Camera Comparison: iPhone 15 Pro Max vs. Pixel 8 Pro
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I’m so confused with these comments. The iPhone wins out in literally every single one! More vivid, more contrast, more true to life, sharper, they’re all iPhone.
Lack of desire? They’ve only had the feature for less than a month now. Haha, they haven’t even had an iPhone release since then to “address” the zoom gap.
True, I’ve never been inspired by anything taken on a smartphone /s
If you ever hear a “photographer” say anything like that, do not hire, all they care about is their expensive DLSR, and don’t know anything about taking a good picture.
I’ve seen amazing photography taken with a smartphone and some horrible photoshoots taken with professional hardware.
Agreed, a future pixel won’t even have a camera, you’ll just say, I’m taking a picture of my kids playing in the pool, and it’ll generate the best version of that for you.
Google addressed the zoom gap right away with Fusion Zoom when they introduced a 5x telephoto on the Pixel 7 Pro last year. Now with the 15 Pro Max we go from 2x lossless zoom all the way to 5x with nothing in between besides further digital cropping from the 1x camera. Apple could have addressed it knowing Google already did last year.
Superb photo's from both phones.
The Pixel does show some extra clarity in some areas, where it's hard to see anything in the iPhone shots, and if I'm honest, whilst it looks a interesting effect I do feel the iPhone is making those clouds look a bit too dramatic. So much s the clouds actually draw your eyes away from the rest of the photo.
If Apple can perhaps tone down the cloud effect and lighten up the dark areas to show detail then that would help a lot
The Pixel does show some extra clarity in some areas, where it's hard to see anything in the iPhone shots, and if I'm honest, whilst it looks a interesting effect I do feel the iPhone is making those clouds look a bit too dramatic. So much s the clouds actually draw your eyes away from the rest of the photo.
If Apple can perhaps tone down the cloud effect and lighten up the dark areas to show detail then that would help a lot
As MKBHD says, “fix in post”, and Pixel 8 really brings this to a whole new stratosphere: your photo can be essentially the alternate reality and casual eyes would not be able to tell the difference.
In the old days, good camera hardware generally produced good results, assuming the same skill level of the person taking the photo. Nowadays, good software can produce good results, backed with largely ok-ish hardware. I have to wonder how far Pixel 8 has brought this trend over to smartphone photography, and how much further it can go.
In the old days, good camera hardware generally produced good results, assuming the same skill level of the person taking the photo. Nowadays, good software can produce good results, backed with largely ok-ish hardware. I have to wonder how far Pixel 8 has brought this trend over to smartphone photography, and how much further it can go.
Pixel looks better, the pic is more "real".
In case of iPhone, if I'd like oversaturation or yellowish color I'd add it in post processing, even in the default photo editor.
In case of iPhone, if I'd like oversaturation or yellowish color I'd add it in post processing, even in the default photo editor.
Yeah, the Pixel seems to have the edge. Maybe Apple will bring this camera race to a tie with the 16 Pro/Pro Max given the stacked camera/48mp ultra-wide setup is coming?
I'm team iPhone, and I'll forever be.
That said, since gen-6 I always liked the Pixel.
If I had to get an android as well for whatever reason, that'd be a Pixel.
I also like the look, with its distinctive bar on the back.
That said, since gen-6 I always liked the Pixel.
If I had to get an android as well for whatever reason, that'd be a Pixel.
I also like the look, with its distinctive bar on the back.
Is having these mega-zooms really that necessary in day-to-day use?
Not trying to be sarcastic, I'm just genuinely interested in knowing.
Honestly I'd prefer seeing smartphone manufacturers updating the sensors on the ultra-wide cameras, as I think they're much more useful in daily use.
I can't stand the fact the ultra wide on iPhones is still much worse than the main camera, making it borderline unusable in many contexts.
you probably watched it on a bad monitor..
not even close. all washed our over exposed skies etc.. not "real" at all.
This right here. It would be amazing to see the results because at least 50% of MR users are going to say that the iPhone photos are better no matter what, because they have the photos marked as being shot by an iPhone.
it's wild how the images change year to year... for the last several years apple has WAY, WAY over-boosted the shadows so there weren't really any shadows... it made the images look very flat and people on these comparison's complained... now suddenly the 15 Pro/Max has much, much deeper shadows that look much more natural (but obviously hide detail in the shadow, a good thing in my opinion because it looks right) and Pixel which had much deeper shadows has suddenly done what iPhone used to do and is now overboosting the shadows! It really seems like Google copied iPhone photo processing from the last few years at the same time Apple copied Pixel photo processing and the two ended up swapping their looks!
They’re both fine. I’d be content with either one.
Since I have the choice, the iPhone wins out of the gate due to superior contrast (those thinking the Pixel has better contrast are noting the brighter and more saturated highlights that the Google device defaults to) and better detail resolve. I can use a photo editor to improve the iPhone images more as lost details in blown highlights are irretrievable.
Which is why I have the iPhone.
Since I have the choice, the iPhone wins out of the gate due to superior contrast (those thinking the Pixel has better contrast are noting the brighter and more saturated highlights that the Google device defaults to) and better detail resolve. I can use a photo editor to improve the iPhone images more as lost details in blown highlights are irretrievable.
Which is why I have the iPhone.
There are several reputable photographers who have provided those contrasts on YouTube. Have a hunt.
I just participated in a photoshoot where the photographer switched between his iPhone and his full frame SLR. These will become prints and we shall see…