I switched from a Droid 3 (verizon) to 4s. The 4s is much much better than my Droid 3, but I do miss some features on Android.
This is no comparison, the Galaxy S3 is superior.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Convince me to stay with iPhone 4s
- Thread starter Mrg02d
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I switched from a Droid 3 (verizon) to 4s. The 4s is much much better than my Droid 3, but I do miss some features on Android.
This is no comparison, the Galaxy S3 is superior.
real world experience.....everything was easier for me with the iphone b.c the apple eco system. I have appletv, a mac, airport express, and I buy a lot of things at the apple store (the easy checkout is awesome!). A phone is more than just a phone when it is tied to every device in your house, and the alternative google products (nexus Q and android tablets) and trash compared to ATV and ipads.
Last edited by a moderator:
People read magazine reviews and other owner reviews to decide a purchase. Why could the OP not get suggestions and user reviews from you guys? Unless this is a not a enthusiast site but a fan site
Good you have a true non-biased 4s user here. I would wait to see what the iphone 5 has in store.
But since you need to decide quickly, without doubt the mighty Galaxy S3.
People read magazine reviews and other owner reviews to decide a purchase. Why could the OP not get suggestions and user reviews from you guys? Unless this is a not a enthusiast site but a fan site
agreed. I can see how the title may make people butt hurt, but he really is just asking for opinions about the two phones. Yes, there are a ton of threads, but it is a forum and another thread does not kill anyone.
+1
I guess the title does look a bit like a "This phone sucks and so do you" thread....I didnt mean it that way. I like my Iphone 4s, but this is going to wind up a 2 year deal and want to make sure I made the right choice while I still have time to turn back (although Ill have to pay an extra $71.00 in fees to do so).
I just didnt realize how small the screen is on these things. You really need to use one for more than 10mins to understand what you are getting in to. The GS3 is very large and is android. My experience with android is that it sucks, badly but I see these articles describing the GS3 as being an outstanding job of android.
I feel like I left the party before it got good.
The GS3 is a very, very nice device. No doubt about it. Probably the best Android phone yet. I'm using a white Verizon LTE model right now in fact. It's fast, smooth and the VZW LTE really zooms. And for a mobile device with a 4.8" screen (basically the size of the entire iPhone itself), it has very good battery life. Excellent camera (imaging element and OS's camera software).I guess the title does look a bit like a "This phone sucks and so do you" thread....I didnt mean it that way. I like my Iphone 4s, but this is going to wind up a 2 year deal and want to make sure I made the right choice while I still have time to turn back (although Ill have to pay an extra $71.00 in fees to do so).
I just didnt realize how small the screen is on these things. You really need to use one for more than 10mins to understand what you are getting in to. The GS3 is very large and is android. My experience with android is that it sucks, badly but I see these articles describing the GS3 as being an outstanding job of android.
I feel like I left the party before it got good.
It all comes down to your OS preference.
However, when all tallied up, feature for feature, I (me, I, myself) think the GS3 probably bests the iPhone 4S - though who knows about the iPhone "5". I'd presume Apple still has some surprises in store.
But again, it's personal preference. These are two very high-end devices... best in their respective categories. Which one is better is a mater of personal choice.
Yea the S3 rocks! All my iPhone friends thought I would come crawling back but I don't even really think twice about Apple now. When I pick up my iPhone 4 I find myself holding it really close to my face now and it just looks so tiny and not to mention trying to go back to 3G after experiencing LTE!
See, Im on sprint and all we have is 3G right now. I also have the new Ipad. How well do these things hold their value? I probably could sell the Iphone later if I am not happy and buy a used GS3 huh? Probably even an even swap too and not have to pay any fees since a used one should have been activated on Sprint at some point. I guess I have a few months before the price drops due to Iphone 5 (which I am not excited about).
Maybe I will Jailbreak the iphone, add some eye candy, and see how I feel in a month?
Maybe I could get Sprint to unlock it and up the value since I would be adding a phone back (not ending service early). Iphones are all the same, just locked to different carriers right? (Ive got a slot for a SIM on mine despite Sprint being CDMA). Id just need it unlocked and in good condition/fairly new.
Anyone here Jailbroken the Iphone 4s? Maybe another reason to stick it out with the Iphone 4s for now?In other words, would you be more inclined to stick with the 4s jailbroken rather than stock over getting the GS3?
----------
Both work fine, except Android has the eye candy I love. In the past, this eye candy was also the demise of Android as noone wanted to do it right. Just release a new phone every 3 months, whereas Apple spends a year doing it right. Now, from what I see, Samsung decided to do it right. Too bad I didnt think to check it out first. (I wasnt aware Sprint had the GS3 when I got the 4s).
Definitely go for the GS3. If you jailbreak the iphone to make it more Android, you would be disappointed, because at the end of the day, it won't look as good and still stuck with a small screen.
I don't like to jailbreak my 4s because I like it how it is right now. But there is no reason to jailbreak, when you can go to an Android phone. It just doesn't make sense, cause the whole point of jailbreaking was to get the features from the Android, iphone users would like.
I don't like to jailbreak my 4s because I like it how it is right now. But there is no reason to jailbreak, when you can go to an Android phone. It just doesn't make sense, cause the whole point of jailbreaking was to get the features from the Android, iphone users would like.
Yea, but at this point, Id have to pay $35.00 restocking fee, $36.00 to activate the GS3 (all on top of me already paying $36.00 to activate the 4s), and $40.00 for a new case+clip (minus whatever I could get from selling my current one). I really wish I knew Sprint had the GS3 before I got the 4s. I was on Tmobile with a highly rooted HTC Sensation. Great phone, but I moved to where Tmobile is near awful. My parents have Sprint and I offered to take over their spare line (which had been upgradeable for a long time). I got the 4s and saw a commercial for the GS3 for Sprint and was all "uh oh". Looked up the reviews (on my 4s of all things) and began to question my decision.
If you're into gaming that might be reason to stay. The quality of games on the iPhone is still better than android. Although I hear Gameloft is getting ready to release their first unreal engine game on android.
Kind of the same deal with me, but a few months earlier. I just decided to live with it for now. I don't do hardcore gaming, nor watch movies. The 4s is for me right now a perfect size for checking email, web, and ipod.
If you sell it you probably only gonna get around $400 and then since you used your upgrade, you'll have to pay full price on another phone.
If you exchange it, I would think of the fees as paying $300 for GS3 rather than $200. my 2 cents.
I cannot, in good faith, convince you to stay with an inferior product. My conscience wont allow it.
I'm listening to Spotify on my GS3 right now but sometime over the next two weeks I plan to return it and wait for the new iPhone. As far as power is concerned it's a truly fast phone. It would be faster if it were running stock Jelly Bean, but that's not going to happen with Samsung. Not while this crap called Touchwiz exists. Plus, I REALLY like Google Now and offline speech to text and I can almost guarantee that it won't make it to the GS3, not while S-Voice is here. S-Voice sucks. Siri wasn't much better, but with iOS 6 the integration was going to be more complete. Maps is a wash- both get you from one place to another. And in 3D now. On my 4s I was running a beta of iOS6 and I found Maps to be about the same across both platforms.
I have beef's with messaging. I enjoyed being on the group texts at work, the ones where we all sit in the cubes and be open, brutally honest and pretty nasty. And if you weren't in the "know" you never knew about it. You had to get invited. I liked iMessage for that. I've tried 3 different messaging apps and haven't found one that works as well or as smoothly. I'm running Apex as my launcher and it stutters occasionally. Probably because it's running over Touchwiz. The size of the phone is great, has great battery life too.
Partly, I blame my friends. They all have iPhones and I feel more connected thanks to iMessage and to be honest, I like the way Notes now syncs to Mountain Lion. I take a prolific amount of notes in my weekly meetings and I don't use Evernote, so the sync function is pretty big. The Galaxy S3 is a GREAT phone. I love it, but the Apple ecosystem has me pretty well in their corner. I also prefer iCloud and the backing up and syncing.
The best thing about all this is that I know where I stand. I tried the GS3 and have no negative things to say about it. It just didn't fit in with me as well as the iPhone and iOS functionality. So for the OP, it's just about deciding which works best for you. It's very easy to be swayed by a large, excellent display, tons of horsepower, superb battery life and a different experience.
As a side note- the 4S feels positively tiny now and not in a good way. Looking forward to a larger form factor. Too bad I gave the 4S to my wife. Have to use a very crappy go phone in the interim weeks leading up to the new iPhone release.
I have beef's with messaging. I enjoyed being on the group texts at work, the ones where we all sit in the cubes and be open, brutally honest and pretty nasty. And if you weren't in the "know" you never knew about it. You had to get invited. I liked iMessage for that. I've tried 3 different messaging apps and haven't found one that works as well or as smoothly. I'm running Apex as my launcher and it stutters occasionally. Probably because it's running over Touchwiz. The size of the phone is great, has great battery life too.
Partly, I blame my friends. They all have iPhones and I feel more connected thanks to iMessage and to be honest, I like the way Notes now syncs to Mountain Lion. I take a prolific amount of notes in my weekly meetings and I don't use Evernote, so the sync function is pretty big. The Galaxy S3 is a GREAT phone. I love it, but the Apple ecosystem has me pretty well in their corner. I also prefer iCloud and the backing up and syncing.
The best thing about all this is that I know where I stand. I tried the GS3 and have no negative things to say about it. It just didn't fit in with me as well as the iPhone and iOS functionality. So for the OP, it's just about deciding which works best for you. It's very easy to be swayed by a large, excellent display, tons of horsepower, superb battery life and a different experience.
As a side note- the 4S feels positively tiny now and not in a good way. Looking forward to a larger form factor. Too bad I gave the 4S to my wife. Have to use a very crappy go phone in the interim weeks leading up to the new iPhone release.
Hahaha.
Consistent software updates, but you don't get siri nor turn by turn navigation in the iPhone 4, 3gs and iPad 2. But you will great new awesome state of the art Facebook integration and a few new options for safari and mail... oh, and yeah, facetime 3g.
I love Apple updates.
Meanwhile, on Android land. I already have all of those, and I will get Google now and Google new voice search.
Just sayin...
I just cant believe you left T-Mobile for Sprint. Dont care what anyone says, Sprint stinks!
As for the phone, i dont care which one you use....but the GS3 is nice
As for the phone, i dont care which one you use....but the GS3 is nice
If you need strangers a forum to convince you to use a product because you're not satisfied with it chances are you'd be happier with a different product
I never EVER thought I would side with Battling on anything he had to say, but Sensamic, regardless of what you think about the updates, they are PROMPT and every iPhone gets them (excluding older and non supported devices which usually does have at least one or two features included). There is no waiting for Sprint, Telus or whatever carrier to dick around with the software that Google provides them and then finally pass it on to the users.
That was one of the MAJOR reasons I was scared to switch to Android, I had to test the phone to make sure I liked the device AS IS, in the off chance I would be waiting for the second coming of christ to get the updates!
Also, customer service is second to none. Samsung isn't offering anything resembling Applecare, nor do they have a large influx of stores that deal solely with their products.
Also consistent performance and fluidity is a truth also, whether you like it or not. One of the problems with Android (some consider it a strength) is that several manufacturers, use the software, don't best optimize it for the hardware and leave customers hanging because they can't be bothered to address issues: a perfect example of this is the stupid brightness slider newly made available on the GS3 that the European customers got and yet there is no sign of it for North American customers. And certainly not in Canada although we share the same model number as Sprint phones. If it was Apple, everyone across the board would have gotten that incremental performance update.
Just sayin....
Awww, we're still playing the copying game? Seriously, get over it. Companies copy each other all the time and Apple isn't the first one to do it.
Im not saying Apple updates are bad... just they are not that great as people make it seem.
As for android updates, we all know what we are getting when we buy an android phone, but... most of these features iOS is JUST getting we already have on android, so... whats best? To wait years to have this updates and get a lot of updates or having them already and always be ahead in software but with less updates?
Its kind of an illusion. Yes, you get more updates in iOS, but the features they are just getting we already have! Think about it. We may have less updates, but even in ICS we are still way ahead of iOS 6.
And I can have JB today if I want if I root, just not that in a hurry since ICS is way better than iOS.
By consistent I meant prompt and expected. There really is no such thing as a delay when it comes to iPhone updates. It's the smaller and minor stuff in iOS which make it great. An example would be with the HTC Desire where both Telus and HTC said it wasn't getting ICS, then they said it was, then it wasn't when there are phones with similar specs getting ICS. Heck, the Rezound JUST got ICS and it didn't even have Sense 4.0 even though it has a dual-core proccesor and a GB of RAM. If I want the newer version of Sense, I gotta get a One X. If I want the new TouchWiz, I gotta get a Galaxy S3, even though the S2 can handle it. When Google announces a new update (which they do inconsistently), it could be months before devices get the update (except for Nexuses) and even then companies won't announce the update is coming until a few days before. Manufacturers don't even beta test and they usually can't because they put the newer and better software on the newest device.
You just can't sit here and tell me Google and other Android software manufacturers handle OS updates BETTER than iOS because it's not true. I'm not talking about the features of them (I wasn't in the first place), I'm talking about how they handle them.
----------
That's thing, you gotta hack the phone to run the latest OS update. It may not sound ridiculous to you, but to most average consumers, it does because no one should have to do that. Then you gotta rely on a developer to update your phone and then sometimes you gotta wipe everything and sometimes there's a new update every day or every Friday, etc and it becomes a hassle for people who aren't all that tech savvy. XDA is just a minority. Rooting is just an excuse for not having the latest update. I can just bet there are more people using iOS 6 (which is still in beta) now than Android 4.1.x and 4.0.x combined.