Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Analog Kid

macrumors G3
Mar 4, 2003
9,360
12,603
So by your guys standard, Apple Book or News+ magazine can show PlayBoy Cover (there are many play covers are not explicit either if you use the dictionary definition) even when parental control is on now. By the way, the example I posted cannot be filter out by parental control.

And we okay kids who many use Apple Book as textbook viewer, see this kind of tasteless stuff day to day? This is on the apple book home page; it is no work around to not see it the moment you open the app.
Yeah, I’m fine with that. There are times parents need to hide the world from kids, but often what is more important is teaching them how to live in the world as it is. Don’t take candy from Montana Sheriffs.
 

WoodTableFromIkea

Suspended
Sep 23, 2022
131
233
Florida
Imagine you want to do a quiet reading of some scientific papers , you get into the mental stage of 100% focus, and the first thing you see by opening the app is this.
How did you notice the semi-naked cowbow if he's at the bottom? Your eyes wandered there for a reason, no? If you wanted to read your scientific papers (weird flex, but ok I guess?) they're at the top of the app, not at the bottom...

But hey, anything to be "outraged" nowadays, right? I guess you close your eyes when you go to the beach (if you even go to the beach...)
 

CMoore515

macrumors 6502a
Sep 27, 2015
765
884
Des Moines, IA
What you're referring to is legitimately a book cover, and part of a book series at that.

My point is a kid could walk into a store where they sell books and see it. Is the retailer, be it B&N, target, Walmart supposed to stop selling books that may offend you because of their cover?? You'd probably get laughed out of the building, tbh.
 

jagolden

macrumors 68000
Feb 11, 2002
1,587
1,501
That is what I am referring to; maybe "explicit" is too extreme but that is the kind of book I assume I have to go to a "Adult Hot Romance" section of a physical book store to see.

The issue of this is that this is at the home page of the book app. The first page when you open the app. I have no problem this in the store and find it by searching or go to the genre myself.

I found it quite tasteless and forced onto the customers. Imagine you want to do a quiet reading of some scientific papers , you get into the mental stage of 100% focus, and the first thing you see by opening the app is this.

Or imagine you go to a physical book store in your neighborhood, when you open the door, there are these type of book covers staring at you, will you feel comfortable?

These book covers are roughy out in the open in almost any bookstore.
Try visiting some.
Nothing hot, dirty, or explicit being shown.
 

Allyance

Contributor
Sep 29, 2017
2,074
7,662
East Bay, CA
Man you are for a shock if you think that cover is going to corrupt the kids of today. You should listen to the conversations of the 9 to 13 year old girl street urchins who play in the streets in my neighborhood, every other word is the 'f' word. Very street smart about sex.
 

Numb3r13

macrumors newbie
Oct 23, 2020
19
20
This is home page of the iOS Apple Book app.
ads is starting to get out of hand.. Parental control set clean content in Apple Book won’t block it as well…
This is quality of first party app now?

View attachment 2140468
I had to sign in and just say ..... what in conservative heck?
Not seeing a problem with this at all, there is nothing graphic about this photo or cover.

I'm Dead . . . Literally Dead.
 

jwdsail

macrumors 6502a
Mar 3, 2004
941
1,102
This is home page of the iOS Apple Book app.
ads is starting to get out of hand.. Parental control set clean content in Apple Book won’t block it as well…
This is quality of first party app now?

View attachment 2140468

While I agree with many here, that what you're finding explicit, specifically a book cover in the "Reads for all ages" section, likely isn't, I understand that you'd like Apple to be paying closer attention to what ends up in the "Reads for all ages" section of the Books app, or more likely, you'd probably prefer more granular controls over what's displayed in the "Reads for all Ages" section added in the Parental Control settings.

That seems like a perfectly reasonable *feature request*. It won't happen overnight, if at all. But, more options/controls in Parental Controls is a reasonable feature request.

Now, I found the book, and I read the description, sorry I'm not buying it just to find the one page with one truly explicit paragraph. The description is... vague.. "Western Romance" ... could be what some parents of *young* children could consider too explicit? Maybe. Reading the synopsis, it reads no more explicit than A CW TV series? Who knows.

Of course, I grew up reading every comic book I could get my hands on, along with every Nick Carter, James Bond, Doyle, Asimov, Heinlein, Star Wars, and Star Trek book I could afford back then.

So, my views re: "explicit" likely are a bit different from yours.

And, given recent news events, I'm extremely disappointed that I've yet to become a master detective, super spy, violin player, star ship captain, time traveler, settler of some far off planet, nor have I slept with a single green skinned woman!


I demand my money back.


But, I digress.


As with all things we wish Apple would do differently...


apple.com/feedback
 

Shirasaki

macrumors P6
May 16, 2015
16,263
11,764
This post reminds me of another one which someone else questions the explicit nature of a well-known woman (somebody says her name is Dolly Parton) with ordinary red dress and exposes reasonable amount of b***a. Replies are more or less The same.

I immediately realise what OP referring to is that cowboy with shirts open and nipple exposed. Thing is, no matter how hard parents want to protect the kids from harmful online contents, they are inherently smarter than you to find out those naughty things. Besides, nudity is but a tiny fraction of “not suitable for kids” content that I don’t even really bother censoring For my kids than a plethora of harmful speculations, misinformation, accusations and so on, all of which are created with all age contents but have far more serious ramifications and consequences.

While you are free to suggest Apple not putting these images in the Apple Books app recommendation page for kids, what you really need to pay attention to is somewhere else. Negative impacts of the social media being the worst example, and majority of harmful contents are not sexual related. It’s better to teach kids how this cruel world works than being Paranoid and trying to shield the kids from “harmful contents”.

Just my 2c and by no means judging OP or anyone’s way to educate their kids.
 
Last edited:

BarredOwl

macrumors 6502
Apr 24, 2015
427
1,097
NC
I can't help but be reminded of the post where the OP equated Dolly Parton with porn.

I'm interested in the how repressed and sheltered folks like that are. I wonder what dogma they force on themselves in every facet of life. Genuinely curious.
 

Howard2k

macrumors 603
Mar 10, 2016
5,699
5,645
That is what I am referring to; maybe "explicit" is too extreme but that is the kind of book I assume I have to go to a "Adult Hot Romance" section of a physical book store to see.

The issue of this is that this is at the home page of the book app. The first page when you open the app. I have no problem this in the store and find it by searching or go to the genre myself.

I found it quite tasteless and forced onto the customers. Imagine you want to do a quiet reading of some scientific papers , you get into the mental stage of 100% focus, and the first thing you see by opening the app is this.

Or imagine you go to a physical book store in your neighborhood, when you open the door, there are these type of book covers staring at you, will you feel comfortable?


Surely you jest?

Men (and in some civilized countries, women too) can walk topless on the street. There's nothing wrong with it.

It's totally ok for you to be sensitive about it but Apple cannot possibly cater to everyone's sensitivities.

No matter what you can think of there is probably someone who finds it offensive. It's simply not possible to ban absolutely everything. You can't cater to every single minority, nor should you.
 

NEPOBABY

Suspended
Jan 10, 2023
697
1,688
This is home page of the iOS Apple Book app.
ads is starting to get out of hand.. Parental control set clean content in Apple Book won’t block it as well…
This is quality of first party app now?

View attachment 2140468


Doesn’t look like explicit.

It looks like all those fake books that are uploaded on Amazon. Some of them have a cheesy cover that looks like a romantic novel.

Search ‘Amazon fake books’ to learn more.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jwdsail

profcutter

macrumors 68000
Mar 28, 2019
1,550
1,296
I dunno, man, when I read scientific papers, I'm usually on EBSCO Host, JStor, or Worldcat. And I wouldn't be horrified and shocked if I saw a person without their shirt on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: strongy

ANDJOE

macrumors 6502
Aug 3, 2010
265
371
Curious if this book cover would be present in an elementary school’s iPads. The book itself would be out of place in a library in a childrens school.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.