Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,181
47,565
In a coffee shop.
There is nothing wrong with Chinese pens in general. If you want something that is high quality (higher than many entry level 'Western' pens), but different in design and colours, then look at the PenBBS range.

As for the old myth of 'copying' designs, then MontBlanc copied the designs of Sheaffer pens and Parker copied elements of early model Waterman pens.

There are several types of IP (Intellectual Property) protection. The three of interest here are Design, Patent and Copyright.

Design refers to the shape of something (like the iconic Lamy Safari). It only lasts 20 years, and cannot be renewed. Consequently a week or so after the Lamy Safari design expired there were a whole heap of cheap imitations that were perfectly legal.

Patent refers to a novel invention, such as a new way of filling a pen, such as a lever fill, crescent fill, converter, piston, vacuum, etc. Patents can be licensed to other entities and can be used by them, but patents also expire, and can then be used by anybody without restriction or cost. Such is the patent for the Pilot Vacuum Filler mechanism and the Mont Blanc screw-in converter.

Copyright refers to a design feature such as a snowflake or arrowhead clip. These stay valid while you pay the fee. Mont Blanc continually keeps the snowflake copyright active, but Parker have given up on the arrowhead clip. You can't use the snowflake without getting into trouble but you can make an arrowhead clip.

There are only so many ways to make a pen, with only a limited number of shapes. Of the several dozen pens I have, only a handful (Parker 5, 51, 75 and 100, Lamy Safari and 2000, PenBBS 323) have elements of originality. Only the Lamy Safari and PenBBS 323 are truly unique, not borrowing elements from previous designs.

I have never had to throw out a Chinese pen because of low quality, but I have disposed of a Skynn 'ergonomic' fountain pen that simply had no intention of ever writing.

I have also thrown out a Parker that was made in India but was also so dreadful I couldn't use it. However, one of my best pens is a hand-made pen from India.

Some of the older, vintage, Chinese pens are a bit dodgy as far as quality, but I have not had any problems with any of the current Jinhao, Kaigelu, Crocodile or Wing Sung pens that I have.

The current Jinhao 82, X350, X850, X159, 9019, Wing Sung 699 (Vacuum Filler and Piston Filler) and Wing Sung 630 (large piston filler) are all excellent pens and well worth your money. I have also heard good things about the Mahjong P136 but I haven't got one yet.
Fascinating post.

I must say that I really love this thread: So interesting, so courteous and respectful in tone and content, so many pleasant people, and always, there is so much to learn.

Wonderful.
 

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,181
47,565
In a coffee shop.
Don't forget to include Parker and Mont Blanc in the knock-off brands, as both copied elements from Sheaffer and Waterman.
I had forgotten both Shaeffer and Waterman; my dad had several Shaeffer pens, and I recall that he gave me a couple of them when I expressed a wish to start writing with fountain pens, and I always found them excellent.

Some years later, I treated myself to a Waterman pen or two, but, while they looked beautiful, I must say that I never actually enjoyed the physical act of writing with either of them.
 
Last edited:

WriteNow

macrumors 6502
Aug 27, 2021
383
397
Waterman pen or two, but, while they looked beautiful, I must say that I never enjoyed actually writing with either of them.
I became aware of Waterman through magazine ads. I remember one that ran around 1990 or so. I can't remember it exactly, but the ad had with a woman talking about all the things she'd given up from her previously exciting and probably lavish life. But she was keeping the Waterman fountain pen, because she needed something thrilling to use to document her boredom. Or something like that.

Fast forward to the late 1990s. I decided to buy a fountain pen. A local stationery store carried a few, including Waterman, at well under $100. Nothing terribly exotic probably, but it would seem exotic to those whose vision of a pen is a 25 cent Bic.

I'm sure I remembered those Waterman ads I'd seen. (It certainly was something i remembered when I bought the Allure.) I was fired up to get a Waterman, at least. But I examined the pens. They didn't have inked demonstrators, but they did let customers handle the pens. And I found I much preferred a Cross they had. I'm not sure I even necessarily knew the name, then. If I did, it certainly wasn't as known a name in my mind as Waterman, let alone Sheaffer (which was the brand that--to that point--had been almost all my fountain pen experience, apart from one vintage Parker desk pen I had.) But I liked what I saw of the Cross, so I got it. It turned out to be a very good pen.

Interestingly, given how much I like Pilot now, I have wondered if the nib on that Cross was a Pilot nib. The pen was made in japan, and I've heard that Pilot provided at least some nibs to Cross.

One might wonder why I got the Allure years later when I passed on Waterman. One factor was the realities of the different eras and different situations. In the late 1990s, I was buying a pen that i knew I'd use a lot. In late 2022, I was in place of thinking: "I don't really write much by hand anymore, and any pen is good enough. But a fountain pen would be fun to have again and use for some stuff like Christmas cards!" The Allure was cheap and I figured would be good enough. Plus...I remembered the ads, and it sort of amused me thinking of getting a thrilling pen to document my boredom as I wrote Christmas cards.
 

GerritV

macrumors 68020
May 11, 2012
2,264
2,729
Gorgeous.

Well wear.

I look forward to reading about how they write, and what they feel like in the hand (ergonomically), ease of writing, and so on.
Not really a rollerball person, but I did ink up the fountain pen with Quink black.
The nib has "W GERMANY" engraved in it, so it might be a Jowo or a Bock - but I'm not a nib connaisseur.
I also did some research on Bugitron. They seem to have offered a wide spectrum of products, and fountain pens were just a small part of their business . So the pens might have been outsourced to a third party.

Either way, the writing experience is OK, not WOW but fairly nice for what appears to be an Extra Fine nib.
Well balanced pen (impossible to post the cap), not too heavy and with a comfortable section.

Since both the barrel's thickness and length are ideal for me to hold it loosely and relatively high up (as if it were a brush), I like the pen more for drawing and specifically for hatching and cross-hatching, so that's what I ended up doing the past few days.

Maybe I'll take it with me for outdoors urban sketching in the Summer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe

Sunset Cassette

macrumors member
Dec 9, 2021
34
126
Canada
Oh, I’m rather pleased to find fellow fountain pen users here on this forum.

Please forgive my less than elegant photo, but pictured is my Pilot Vanishing Point decimo with a medium nib, my daily driver at work.

Anyone else have experience with retractable fountain pens such as the Platinum Curidas or the Lamy Dialog lineup?
IMG_5632.jpeg
 

GerritV

macrumors 68020
May 11, 2012
2,264
2,729
Oh, I’m rather pleased to find fellow fountain pen users here on this forum.

Please forgive my less than elegant photo, but pictured is my Pilot Vanishing Point decimo with a medium nib, my daily driver at work.

Anyone else have experience with retractable fountain pens such as the Platinum Curidas or the Lamy Dialog lineup?
View attachment 2356643

First of all, welcome to this thread of fountain pen lovers.
Secondly, congratulations on your gorgeous looking Pilot VP. I love its deep blue color.
I once tried a Pilot VP when visiting my stationary shop. Guess it was a <M> as well, very smooth writer indeed and a gusher. But the "upside down" clip hasn't yet grown on me.
 

GerritV

macrumors 68020
May 11, 2012
2,264
2,729
What started as a dilemma between the Asvine P36 and the TWSBI Diamond 580 ended in me purchasing a TWSBI VAC700 R. I ordered it online, at a brick and mortar stationary shop not too far from where I live.
The pen was delivered within 24 hours, and came gift wrapped, along with a handwritten "Thank You" note, some candies, and a catalogue. Really a very nice unpacking experience indeed.
This is my first TWSBI, my first vacuum filler and my first #6 nib. Guess I'm in for some fun playtime :)

Thanks to all who commented on buying Chinese products (or not), but so far I'm happy with my choice.

TWSBI-1.jpg


TWSBI-2.jpg
 

GerritV

macrumors 68020
May 11, 2012
2,264
2,729
My wife and I were going through some old cardboard boxes in the cellar, when all of the sudden we found a nice white paper box that looked almost like a MacBook Air box. Inside, wrapped in a black cotton sack, there was this fancy "croc" leather A5 notebook cover from a brand I never heard of, but is still around : Matras (apparently based in Turkey).
This must have been a New Year gift or something from way back when. I thought I'd share our little discovery.

matras.jpg
 

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,181
47,565
In a coffee shop.
What started as a dilemma between the Asvine P36 and the TWSBI Diamond 580 ended in me purchasing a TWSBI VAC700 R. I ordered it online, at a brick and mortar stationary shop not too far from where I live.
The pen was delivered within 24 hours, and came gift wrapped, along with a handwritten "Thank You" note, some candies, and a catalogue. Really a very nice unpacking experience indeed.
This is my first TWSBI, my first vacuum filler and my first #6 nib. Guess I'm in for some fun playtime :)

Thanks to all who commented on buying Chinese products (or not), but so far I'm happy with my choice.

View attachment 2356800

View attachment 2356801
Have you any Japanese fountain pens, paper, or products?
 

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,181
47,565
In a coffee shop.
My wife and I were going through some old cardboard boxes in the cellar, when all of the sudden we found a nice white paper box that looked almost like a MacBook Air box. Inside, wrapped in a black cotton sack, there was this fancy "croc" leather A5 notebook cover from a brand I never heard of, but is still around : Matras (apparently based in Turkey).
This must have been a New Year gift or something from way back when. I thought I'd share our little discovery.

View attachment 2365505
Now, that is absolutely beautiful - simply gorgeous - and is just begging to be used as part of one's life on a regular basis.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GerritV

GerritV

macrumors 68020
May 11, 2012
2,264
2,729
Have you any Japanese fountain pens, paper, or products?
I don’ have any Japanese fountain pens, too conservative design for my taste I guess.
As for paper, Midori MD (Japan) is my favorite brand. In both their own notebooks and the Traveler’s C° refills.
And Pilot Iroskizuku Tsuki-Yo (Japan) is my favorite ink.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe

GerritV

macrumors 68020
May 11, 2012
2,264
2,729
I don’ have any Japanese fountain pens, too conservative design for my taste I guess.
As for paper, Midori MD (Japan) is my favorite brand. In both their own notebooks and the Traveler’s C° refills.
And Pilot Iroskizuku Tsuki-Yo (Japan) is my favorite ink.
Oops, I must apologize here. I actually do have a Japanese pen: the Traveler's C° Brass Fountain Pen.
But let's admit, that's a different league from the typical Pilot, Platinum, Sailor...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe

stanza.richi

macrumors 65816
Dec 5, 2019
1,108
1,700
Italy
Oh, I’m rather pleased to find fellow fountain pen users here on this forum.

Please forgive my less than elegant photo, but pictured is my Pilot Vanishing Point decimo with a medium nib, my daily driver at work.

Anyone else have experience with retractable fountain pens such as the Platinum Curidas or the Lamy Dialog lineup?
View attachment 2356643

You aren’t alone 👍🏻 my actual daily is a Capless Carbonesque Blue!
IMG_4108.jpeg
 

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,181
47,565
In a coffee shop.
Oh, I’m rather pleased to find fellow fountain pen users here on this forum.

Please forgive my less than elegant photo, but pictured is my Pilot Vanishing Point decimo with a medium nib, my daily driver at work.

Anyone else have experience with retractable fountain pens such as the Platinum Curidas or the Lamy Dialog lineup?
View attachment 2356643
May I join with @GerritV in extending a warm welcome to you.

I am delighted that you have discovered this quite lovely thread of fountain pen lovers, some of whom have considerable expertise on the subject and who have been wonderfully generous sharing their knowledge (and experience) with the rest of us.

Please feel free to join us with any thoughts, comments, questions, queries that occur to you.
 

WriteNow

macrumors 6502
Aug 27, 2021
383
397
I love a nice Mont Blanc, but considering I work in IT I just don't think the pen would ever get used!
I think I've mentioned this before here... But I had a period of not using a fountain pen for many years, and I thought it seemed pointless to consider using one. How much do I actually use a pen? Then I had weak moment in 2022, when I got a fountain pen (on the excuse of "Christmas cards"). I quickly realized that I used a pen a lot more than I'd thought...

It's also worth noting that there are nice pens that are considerably cheaper than Mont Blanc...
 

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,181
47,565
In a coffee shop.
I love a nice Mont Blanc, but considering I work in IT I just don't think the pen would ever get used!

I know a lot of people that working in IT or at least a lot with PC/tablet that still prefer a fountain pen to take notes about their work :) give it a chance!
The use of (and/or working with) computers in a professional capacity does not necessarily mean that fountain pens cannot play a role.

Many of us both use computers, and regularly write with fountain pens (in my case, a nice Mont Blanc).

Actually, I find fountain pens superb for when taking notes, and sometimes, (in my experience) writing things down by hand is the only way to think something through and be able to fully comprehend it.
 

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,181
47,565
In a coffee shop.
I've been eyeballing the Caran D'Ache 849 fountain pen for a while.
A few days ago, I discovered this lovely red one on Amazon, and couldn't resist.
It goes well with my recently acquired Edelweiss pencils. Both will be my set for urban sketching.

View attachment 2393605

View attachment 2393604
Well wear, I love the colour.

Is it comfortable to write with?
 
  • Like
Reactions: GerritV

GerritV

macrumors 68020
May 11, 2012
2,264
2,729
Well wear, I love the colour.

Is it comfortable to write with?

Thanks for your nice comment. I too love this red, but mostly because it's Caran d'Ache 's brand colour.

As for the writing comfort, CdA fountain pens are known (liked/disliked) for their relatively skinny section. That doesn't bother me, since I hold my pens higher up (around the barrel stepdown), and because I also frequently use pencils, who are thinner anyway.
What struck me immediately, was the very nice feel of the lacquer. It's kind of satin, quite soft to the touch, not metallic cold at all. And it looks gorgeous IMHO.
The nib is simple, no frills, slender and relatively long. The pointy shape will probably be well suited for sketching and drawing.
 

GerritV

macrumors 68020
May 11, 2012
2,264
2,729
I love a nice Mont Blanc, but considering I work in IT I just don't think the pen would ever get used!

In case you attend meetings: taking notes and writing down tasks
In case you're a programmer: writing down ideas perhaps combined with schemes, mind maps
In case there are no circumstances within your daily job, and you'd like to use a pen: writing a journal, taking notes on your reading

Of course, all of the above are merely suggestions - coming from someone who's always looking for ways to use his fountain pens :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.