Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Galaxy S4
- Thread starter Chris092881
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I'll repeat this as much as I have to.
There's a reason why people respond to Samsung's [if true] minor S3-to-S4 upgrade differently than they do to Apple's minor upgrades.
Samsung's smartphone lineup is so much more versatile than Apple's. Samsung has a wide range of phones to cover different sizes and price levels, many of them are current generation, and offer different experiences but still remain smartphones.
With Apple, there is only one screen size that is of current generation. The smaller option is over a year old, and there's no larger screen size at all.
Also, just taking their phones at face value, the S3 offers so much more packed into it than the iPhone 5 -- in other words, it truly is hard for Samsung to introduce many hardware changes (and again, they have other lineups to cover other ground in the smartphone world). Apple, on the other hand, intentionally withholds hardware changes (they don't believe wireless charging is worth it, nor in screen size options, nor NFC, nor notification lights, nor expandable memory, etc.).
Likewise, Samsung doesn't recycle their design for two years, as Apple has been doing, and will likely continue to do with the 5S.
So, is the S3-to-S4 upgrade small? Sure -- as small as the 4S-to-5 upgrade, if you want to really compare. But does Samsung take two years to do it? No.
TL;DR: No one is giving Samsung a free pass. Samsung just has their bases more covered.
Come on guy, thats clearly just the back case not being fully snapped on.
True, but the dent in the metal on the left that is more of a puzzle/concern.
Because one unit must mean all units are either dented, blemished or just poor QC.
I wasn't calling the GS4 a minor upgrade. Just making fun of people that made fun of the iPhone 5 saying it was just an iPhone 4/4S just thinner and taller......
I wasn't using it as a serious knock against the phone itself. More towards the people who made fun of the iPhone 5's external design......
No there does appear to be a dimple/dent there bottom left. Look at the finger/thumb and look down towards the back panel.
Who knows. But bad QC especially on phones that the press are going to be photographing and examining in close up.
can you guarantee that it came from the factory like that? and the dent DID NOT come from the hundreds of journalists playing with the phones (and dropping them)?
Just goes to show that metal has nothing whatsover to do on the exterior of a phone. Just look at any iPhone that has been used without a cover - not a pretty sight.
To my eyes it looks like a reflection of a camera being horribly distorted by the angle of the bend of the aluminum. Note the corresponding bending of light directly atop that band.
IDK, I trust a major company like Samsung enough to ensure their PR blitz is properly equipped with grade a phones. Why would anyone working the event allow a damaged phone to be photographed instead of swapping it out with one of the other dozens of placeholders on hand? It doesn't make sense to me that this would be a dent.
That said, what is the hole to the left and why does it look so janky?
Then that's a major fail on Samsung for allowing those poor pics to go out like that. Samsung read those reviews well ahead of time along with seeing those pictures. I'm sure Samsung would have told CNET that those pictures do not represent their product correctly.
I'm not impressed, sadly. I was ready to be thrilled with this launch, but it made me love my iPhone 5 all the more. And on the Android front of things, I find the HTC One to be quite desirable, and may check it out once it's released. Samsung has gotten overly confident, and are releasing a sub-par product because of it. Sure it has a gorgeous display and powerful processor, but so does the One. I guess there's always the Note 3, and next year...
And if you read my post, you'll see why there's a perfectly good and legitimate reason to react to the iPhone 5 upgrades in such ways.
My guess is that it is the IR-transmitter.
I personally applaud the comeback of this feature in phones (first the HTC One and now in the S4). Used it a lot back in the day before IR to my great disappoinment stopped appearing in phones a few years ago.
Now that I'm caught up on the thread, it sounds like it's a good thing I missed the presentation!
These are photos that Cnet has taken themselves of a pre-production unit.
Thank god we are past the times when reviewers are forced by corporations to use pre-approved and photoshopped photos in their first look/hands-on-articles.
Because its a bit unbecoming to snatch a phone out of a reviewers hand. You've got to remember the people handing these things out to reporters are not high level execs, they are the equivalent of booth people at trade shows. There to highlight the product, but probably paid like ****.