Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

rockitdog

macrumors 68030
Mar 25, 2013
2,724
1,241
More than half of the S4s features are in the phones software value-adds. The physical hardware on the S4 isn't that great of a jump from the S3. I think a vanilla S4 wouldn't appeal to the masses if you lose all of those elements that the S4 brings to the table.
 

0dev

macrumors 68040
Dec 22, 2009
3,947
24
127.0.0.1
Where are you located Odev? I'll be headed to Italy next weekend and am trying to figure out the best prepaid option for my Nexus 4. Heard 3 was one of the best.

I'm in the UK. Three is excellent in the UK. I've never used them in Italy but compare the deals, if they're as great for value as they are in the UK I fully recommend it.
 

jrswizzle

macrumors 603
Aug 23, 2012
6,107
129
McKinney, TX
That sounds like a hack to me man...

Right now we have EE with LTE speeds of up to 120Mbps. There are people already getting 60Mbps on LTE in some places. On DC-HSPDA people are getting 30Mbps.

I underestimated the speeds in that last post, I'll go edit it now...

AT&T Unlimited users don't require any "hacks". Every time I upgrade they transfer it over.

And there's quite a bit of difference in network coverage area between the US and any of the European countries......costs quite a bit more for carriers to build out and maintain our networks.

At any rate, it will always be that way - more people in the US = more congestion on the network = slower overall speeds. Not really a big issue. People whine and complain about cell phone carrier prices.....it is what it is. T-Mobile's un-carrier plans will likely help drive costs down some, but we can't expect 100% coverage of our entire country with LTE speeds and not think we're gonna pay $20/month like other countries.

Too many people, too big a coverage area. Costs money.

----------

I'm in the UK. Three is excellent in the UK. I've never used them in Italy but compare the deals, if they're as great for value as they are in the UK I fully recommend it.

Cool - looking at grabbing a pre-paid sim that I can use for the 2 weeks we are there.

Would love to spend around 10 euros....being their webpages are in Italian, I have a hard time navigating :p
 

0dev

macrumors 68040
Dec 22, 2009
3,947
24
127.0.0.1
AT&T Unlimited users don't require any "hacks". Every time I upgrade they transfer it over.

And there's quite a bit of difference in network coverage area between the US and any of the European countries......costs quite a bit more for carriers to build out and maintain our networks.

At any rate, it will always be that way - more people in the US = more congestion on the network = slower overall speeds. Not really a big issue. People whine and complain about cell phone carrier prices.....it is what it is. T-Mobile's un-carrier plans will likely help drive costs down some, but we can't expect 100% coverage of our entire country with LTE speeds and not think we're gonna pay $20/month like other countries.

Too many people, too big a coverage area. Costs money.

I get that, but at any rate, it seems to me that there's no excuse for them to rip you off. If they're going to charge you a lot of money they should let you have more for that money. Even if you have a grandfathered plan, fact is no one else can get those anymore. Considering the prices there's no reason why not, they're just being super greedy and taking advantage of the lax telecoms regulation you have over there.

I also don't fully buy the whole "it's a big country so we need to charge more" argument. The fact it's a big country means they have more subscribers and therefore more revenue by default. Also if T-Mobile can offer better value why can't the rest of them?

Plus even when you buy a phone on a new 24 month contract you're expect to pay ~$200. That's insane. Over here if you sign a contract you can get any phone you want for free.

Cool - looking at grabbing a pre-paid sim that I can use for the 2 weeks we are there.

Would love to spend around 10 euros....being their webpages are in Italian, I have a hard time navigating :p

Google Translate man! And enjoy Italy, I've been there a few times, it's an amazing place :)
 

skratch77

macrumors 65816
Mar 20, 2013
1,241
5
That sounds like a hack to me man...

Right now we have EE with LTE speeds of up to 120Mbps. There are people already getting 60Mbps on LTE in some places. On DC-HSPDA people are getting 30Mbps.

I underestimated the speeds in that last post, I'll go edit it now...

How is it a hack? It tooke 5 min to order my phone online without even the need to talk to anyone and its coming in the mail ready to be used as soon as Verizon releases it.

I can buy any 4g phone on craigslist and just pop my sim into it and off I go with a new phone and keep my unlimited plan

And to your some people getting speeds my phone has never seen 3g and I get the speeds I told you everywhere I go.I hit 66mb in Vegas and 50mb all the way across the country in boston
 

paulsalter

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Aug 10, 2008
1,622
0
UK
Right now we have EE with LTE speeds of up to 120Mbps. There are people already getting 60Mbps on LTE in some places. On DC-HSPDA people are getting 30Mbps.

I must be living in the past where I am in the UK :(

Mostly only get gprs for my mobile and at home I get 2MB connection if it's a good day (and always only before 5pm)

on the plus side, it is unlimited, lol
 

0dev

macrumors 68040
Dec 22, 2009
3,947
24
127.0.0.1
How is it a hack? It tooke 5 min to order my phone online without even the need to talk to anyone and its coming in the mail ready to be used as soon as Verizon releases it.

I can buy any 4g phone on craigslist and just pop my sim into it and off I go with a new phone and keep my unlimited plan

And to your some people getting speeds my phone has never seen 3g and I get the speeds I told you everywhere I go.I hit 66mb in Vegas and 50mb all the way across the country in boston

You need to create new lines and swap crap around, it's a hack. And if I hop on a plane and walk into a Verizon shop tomorrow can I get unlimited data? No.

The bottom line remains. £15 a month prepaid for 300 minutes, unlimited texts, and unlimited DC-HSPDA and, in just a few months, LTE data is a far better deal than anything you can get in the US. And if you pay an extra tenner you get unlimited tethering too, so you literally don't need home broadband.
 

0dev

macrumors 68040
Dec 22, 2009
3,947
24
127.0.0.1
I must be living in the past where I am in the UK :(

Mostly only get gprs for my mobile and at home I get 2MB connection if it's a good day (and always only before 5pm)

on the plus side, it is unlimited, lol

Yeah rural areas need to catch up. I think they're trying to roll out LTE in rural areas for this very reason, but there's no point at EE's prices, you want to wait for Three to do it.
 

Dontazemebro

macrumors 68020
Jul 23, 2010
2,173
0
I dunno, somewhere in West Texas
You need to create new lines and swap crap around, it's a hack. And if I hop on a plane and walk into a Verizon shop tomorrow can I get unlimited data? No.

The bottom line remains. £15 a month prepaid for 300 minutes, unlimited texts, and unlimited DC-HSPDA and, in just a few months, LTE data is a far better deal than anything you can get in the US. And if you pay an extra tenner you get unlimited tethering too, so you literally don't need home broadband.

My god I'm jealous. You're right though, carriers over here are raping us royally..
 

jrswizzle

macrumors 603
Aug 23, 2012
6,107
129
McKinney, TX
I get that, but at any rate, it seems to me that there's no excuse for them to rip you off. If they're going to charge you a lot of money they should let you have more for that money. Even if you have a grandfathered plan, fact is no one else can get those anymore. Considering the prices there's no reason why not, they're just being super greedy and taking advantage of the lax telecoms regulation you have over there.

I also don't fully buy the whole "it's a big country so we need to charge more" argument. The fact it's a big country means they have more subscribers and therefore more revenue by default. Also if T-Mobile can offer better value why can't the rest of them?

Plus even when you buy a phone on a new 24 month contract you're expect to pay ~$200. That's insane. Over here if you sign a contract you can get any phone you want for free.



Google Translate man! And enjoy Italy, I've been there a few times, it's an amazing place :)

T-mobile can do so because they've been losing customers like crazy.....lol they need to do something!

A bigger country does mean more subscribers for sure.....but its not just the population that's larger - its the area of coverage needed. I mean each of the big 3 over here covers something like 99% of the nation.....even many rural areas. The money needed to build out and maintain that vast network is likely more than needed in other smaller countries.

I'm not saying they do make a lot of money too......but the whole idea that profit is a dirty word is ridiculous to me. If I really think about it, I pay more per month for my house, my electricity, my cable, gas in my car, life insurance, home/car insurance, food, random things....etc. Being that my smartphone is a very important part of my life and has become integral in most everyone's work and everyday doings, I think the money it costs isn't all that big a deal.

Also gotta take into account average yearly salaries for each country. Sure there are some places with lower costs for cell phones where people make MORE than us in the US, but there aren't many.

Plus, you guys get screwed in other ways! lol....taxes, tariffs, etc. There's always something ;)
 

Dontazemebro

macrumors 68020
Jul 23, 2010
2,173
0
I dunno, somewhere in West Texas
I'm with AT&T and even gave up my grandfathered plan because it wasn't worth it. I was getting throttled sometimes after only 1.5gb.

Hell, I much rather pay the extra 10 bucks for 1 more GB of LTE than unlimited turtle speeds.
 

0dev

macrumors 68040
Dec 22, 2009
3,947
24
127.0.0.1
T-mobile can do so because they've been losing customers like crazy.....lol they need to do something!

But they won't be doing it at at a loss, clearly they can make money that way even if it does mean slimmer margins. The problem in the US is lack of competition, so there's no incentive to drive down prices like there is here.

A bigger country does mean more subscribers for sure.....but its not just the population that's larger - its the area of coverage needed. I mean each of the big 3 over here covers something like 99% of the nation.....even many rural areas. The money needed to build out and maintain that vast network is likely more than needed in other smaller countries.

Yeah the costs are higher to maintain a network in a bigger country, but for the very reason it's a bigger country, they also have a lot more revenue to fund that kind of thing with.

I'm not saying they do make a lot of money too......but the whole idea that profit is a dirty word is ridiculous to me. If I really think about it, I pay more per month for my house, my electricity, my cable, gas in my car, life insurance, home/car insurance, food, random things....etc. Being that my smartphone is a very important part of my life and has become integral in most everyone's work and everyday doings, I think the money it costs isn't all that big a deal.

Don't get me wrong, profit isn't a dirty word to me, but I see your plans and my jaw drops :p

Also gotta take into account average yearly salaries for each country. Sure there are some places with lower costs for cell phones where people make MORE than us in the US, but there aren't many.

The average wage in the US vs. the UK is pretty similar I'd imagine. They're both developed first world countries after all.

Plus, you guys get screwed in other ways! lol....taxes, tariffs, etc. There's always something ;)

Oh yeah, you mentioned gas before, we get screwed over royally for that over here don't you worry :p
 

Hastings101

macrumors 68020
Jun 22, 2010
2,355
1,482
K
Three FTW! Can't wait until I get my free update to unlimited LTE on their network :D

Just to gloat a little to our American friends, here's my data usage for the past four months (when I last restored the phone fresh):

Hey now, I technically have unlimited data on AT&T... I just get throttled down to unbearable speeds if I go over the 3GB monthly limit :(
 

Tig Bitties

macrumors 603
Sep 6, 2012
5,517
5,692
Sounds cool, if even true, but need more details ? I doubt this will be like a "Nexus" device with updates direct from Google ?

I could see it being shipped with Android 4.3, and being stuck on 4.3 for awhile,waiting for Samsung to push the newer OS update months later. And I agree, would be sold in very limited quantities, near impossible to find. So maybe T-Mobile gets it, ok, T-Mo blows, and I would still think would be scarce and hard to get at T-Mobile stores.

And the price for such a phone ? If it's in the crazy $650 range, no way then. With the current and still fresh Nexus 4 selling for just $349, no way is this special edition S4 worth 75% more, just for LTE, and expandable storage ? LOL, that's not worthy of a 75% price increase. The Nexus 4 is no slouch, hardware wise compared to the S4, is not that much different, sure the S4 is a better device, but not night and day radically better, if anything this S4 Google Edition would be like a Nexus 4.5.

At this point, I'd just wait for the Nexus-Five, will be cheaper, and have better spec's than the S4, and run the latest Android OS.
 

0dev

macrumors 68040
Dec 22, 2009
3,947
24
127.0.0.1
It's real, wow!

FPe8voQ.png


Selling through the Play Store unlocked, updates fresh from Google. Hope it's not limited to just the US...
 

jrswizzle

macrumors 603
Aug 23, 2012
6,107
129
McKinney, TX
I'm extremely interested in how this Nexus GS4 came about.....was it a Google idea, Samsung idea.....what's the purpose of such a device?

Very interesting.....if I had $650 to blow, I'd buy one for sure.
 

MRU

macrumors Penryn
Aug 23, 2005
25,370
8,952
a better place
It's real, wow!

Image

Selling through the Play Store unlocked, updates fresh from Google. Hope it's not limited to just the US...


Yeah shame play-store sales are limited to very few countries. Basically it'll never see light of day here. :( If it was - I could be tempted.
 

0dev

macrumors 68040
Dec 22, 2009
3,947
24
127.0.0.1
Yeah shame play-store sales are limited to very few countries. Basically it'll never see light of day here. :( If it was - I could be tempted.

I wouldn't be so sure, although Google likes neglecting Europe they're usually not bad bringing stuff to the UK. I think they might bring it here in the near future. My biggest fear is they'll just do a direct conversion on the price and overcharge us for the hardware.
 

MRU

macrumors Penryn
Aug 23, 2005
25,370
8,952
a better place
I wouldn't be so sure, although Google likes neglecting Europe they're usually not bad bringing stuff to the UK. I think they might bring it here in the near future. My biggest fear is they'll just do a direct conversion on the price and overcharge us for the hardware.

Even when it's available in the UK, you can't order it from the Ireland store, even though google are based in Ireland for everything european. Get's quite frustrating.
 

0dev

macrumors 68040
Dec 22, 2009
3,947
24
127.0.0.1
Even when it's available in the UK, you can't order it from the Ireland store, even though google are based in Ireland for everything european. Get's quite frustrating.

That's a shame and makes little sense... silly Google. Surely it can't be too hard to get one imported from England though?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.