Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I did really enjoy my X, although I felt like Apple neglected it by discontinuing almost every single case for it at the launch of the XS, as well as making battery cases for the XS/XS Max and specifically stating that the case would not work on the X (though it did work mostly ok). It felt like a slap in the face...Apple drew us in with the fancy new design and then punished us a year later for buying it by canceling anything specific to it. And then they only supported it for 6 iOS versions instead of 7 like the 6S series, and current XS/XR families. It should have at least got iOS 17.

The X was overall my most problem-free phone with a good balance of battery life and a changed design that was changed enough to make it interesting. Still only used it for 3 years though. I find they don't work well enough for me after about 3 years.

Personally I liked the 5.8" screen and I still think that is what the normal Pro size should be. Not 6.1" or 6.3". The new 6.3" Pros are almost as large as the original 6.5" Max was, and at the time of the Max launch, many people thought it was too big....I have grown to like the Max in it's 6.7" and 6.9" forms, but not everyone wants that.
I want to point out my biggest pet peeve with the X not getting iOS 18.
The iPhone that introduced Lock Screen controls and a redesigned Control Center will forever be stuck with that very same Lock Screen and Control Center.
The supposedly biggest iPhone since the iPhone will forever be a testament to Apple‘s stubbornness and their restrictive design choices. It really is sad.
 
Is it just me, or do a lot of these posts now days sound like they’re AI generated? Maybe it’s just not my style of writing but it sounds very sterile.

(No offense to the author of this post)
 
Agreed. It's not just the shape. It's the size. It's the absence of a horrendously protuberant camera bump.
 
Is it just me, or do a lot of these posts now days sound like they’re AI generated? Maybe it’s just not my style of writing but it sounds very sterile.

(No offense to the author of this post)
I never got that impression.
 
Yes maybe. I had an XS (recently replaced it with a 16) and due to those famous rounded glass edges it's the only phone I repeatedly dropped *and* the screen broke. The glass edges make it easier for it to slip *and* the glass is directly exposed. The metal edged phones are somewhat protected.

I could have got more than 5.5 years out of it if the cracks hadn't started to expand...
 
Agree 100%. The iPhone X and 11 pro were designed with such intention, there was still that Jony Ive magic in them.

The newer ones look and feel like they were designed to be cheaper to manufacture, above all else.

The X felt like a piece of jewelry, like it was most definitely worth the extra money for the pro model. Just a gorgeous, gorgeous design…
 
Yes maybe. I had an XS (recently replaced it with a 16) and due to those famous rounded glass edges it's the only phone I repeatedly dropped *and* the screen broke. The glass edges make it easier for it to slip *and* the glass is directly exposed. The metal edged phones are somewhat protected.

I could have got more than 5.5 years out of it if the cracks hadn't started to expand...
You were holding the phone wrong.

LOL Sorry, couldn't resist that joke. But seriously it seems like there are some people that struggle with the rounded sides, I don't know if it is a lack of hand strength/grip or what. I have never had a problem dropping phones regardless of rounded or flat sides. Now I also know a lot of people, myself included, that find the phones with flat sides to be very uncomfortable to hold and at times physically painful to do so, while other people can hold a phone with flat sides with no physical pain at all.

Seems like people in the world fall into one of the two groups.
 
Agreed. The X was peak. The current design is more aesthetic's than comfort. The square edges just dont feel right in your palm. But if history repeats itself, they will cycle back to round edges soon, and then back to square 5 years later.
They aren’t even an improvement in aesthetics, in my opinion. The X and 11 pro were beautiful devices, almost sensual with the way the glass curved into the metal.

Now they look so boring, just flat pieces of glass with a metal strip wrapped around them :(
 
  • Like
Reactions: ab2c4
I've never held an X, and only knew one person that owned one..and he kept it in a Otterbox, so..

I do really miss the non-bulky camera bump, and the rounded sides. Oh how I miss them! I've never gotten used to square sides.
 
  • Love
Reactions: ab2c4
I feel the same when having a 11 pro in my hand, vs the 13pro. 13pro feels clunky, heavy and a step in the wrong direction.
Feels like they are taking steps backwards so they can slowly improve the design again :)
 
Has anyone held a iPhone 3GS recently? I held one again a couple years ago and it blew my mind how naturally it felt in your hand. Every phone I hold now is a disappointment. I wish we could go back that far.
 
Has anyone held a iPhone 3GS recently? I held one again a couple years ago and it blew my mind how naturally it felt in your hand. Every phone I hold now is a disappointment. I wish we could go back that far.
I haven't held one in a long time but what is sad is that not that long ago some of the android phones had that same curved back. This entire phone industry has gone to crap over the last 5 years or so.
 
I maintain the iPhone 4S (old era) and iPhone X (modern era) are peak iPhone designs that haven't really been matched or exceeded.

They're also the only phones i got in white which made me love them more. I still miss them and somewhat regret trading them in.
 
Product Design 101: Its very difficult to build a design that achieves instant brand recognition. This can happen with logos, products, urban design (see: US cities) and signage. Familiarity becomes a reason for people to keep buying a product, where significant change invites backlash. There is a reason Porsche let you listen to a soundbite of the engine noise when browsing their model 911 webpage and people baulked at Jaguar's tone-deaf rebrand last year.

The iPhone design slots into this category. It is not 'lazy design'; it has been conditioned that way on purpose. Indeed the image most people have of a generic smartphone is that of an iPhone. Other brands, notably Samsung and Google have actually removed their own brand character of late to align them closer to the aesthetics of the iPhone. This is not outright plagiarism but a calculated marketing move on their part. The reason EVs stick to the familiar car paradigm is to give customers an inviting, familiar aesthetic. Expect the iPhone 25 to, bar the odd nip and tuck largely resemble existing models.

The fast pace of the tech sector had created a user expectation that things should constantly change but the commoditisation of smartphones has meant that have, much like cars and laptops become an archetype. You can make them bend and twist all you like but a folding spoon is still a spoon.
Yes, and I don't disagree... but.... Remember when the design was overhauled every 2-3 years?
  • The original
  • Then the 3G/S
  • The 4/S
  • The 5/S
  • But then there was the 6/S/7/8 (4 years)
  • The X/XR/S paved the way for the 11/Pro (3 years)
  • Which took us to the 12, and it's been a squared off rectangle ever since, going on now 5 years.
Now personally, I enjoy the throwback to the 4's and 5's boxy corners. I agree with a previous poster: they're much easier to pick up off the table. But compared to the earlier years, the designs have grown more stale/lazy (comparably).
 
They aren’t even an improvement in aesthetics, in my opinion. The X and 11 pro were beautiful devices, almost sensual with the way the glass curved into the metal.

Now they look so boring, just flat pieces of glass with a metal strip wrapped around them :(
It’s completely subjective. I like both styles however my preference is for the squared off aesthetics of the newer iPhones. I even like the newer Samsungs which have the exact same design language.

I would say that the black titanium iPhone 16 Pro might be the most beautiful phone I’ve seen to this date.

IMG_0203.jpeg
 
The X was the iPhone I had the longest amount of time (launch day through April 2020). It really was not a great iPhone though. Design wise it was excellent but the beauty was only skin deep. Screen aside, the iPhone 11 (non Pro) I replaced it with was far superior.

iPhones have only gotten better since. What it did do was bring new elements to the table that would not be fully realized until years into the future.

I do think the 17 series could have a similar impact on the industry but it looks to be far more controversial.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Devyn89
As someone who has always had their phone in a case, I can't say that the 'feel' of the phone overly bothers me. I wished Apple had done a 'Max' iPhone X though. I went from a 7 Plus to a X and it felt like a downgrade for me. The screen was smaller, there was no landscape Home Screen. Face ID was slow compared to the muscle memory I'd built up from Touch ID so I swapped it for an 8 Plus and was much happier.

Each to their own though.
 
In a case they all feel a like to me, but I do remember how much I enjoyed how it felt in my hands when the X was out of its case. Newer phones never left that impression with me. Honestly, I think I just prefer the feel of stainless steel to things like aluminum or titanium.
 
Someone turned in a lost iPhone X at work last night. While putting it away I couldn’t help but notice how much nicer it felt in my hand then my 15 Pro does.

It wasn’t just the rounded edges; there was such a precision that iPhones used to have that they just don’t anymore.

I’ve been an iPhone user since the first one 18 years ago. When things slowly change you don’t really notice it, like the analogy of the frog in the pot of water slowly boiling.

The X wasn’t even that long ago in my mind, and I really think that the industrial of the iPhone is deteriorating. They used to feel compact and pleasant and joyful in your hand. They currently feel… just lazier designed.

I’ve got my eye on this Air model for this reason alone. I want to love holding my phone again. I don’t love holding my 15 Pro.
There is absolutely nothing of "higher precision" in the X versus a 15 Pro-- the only difference is the rounded edges. The rounded edges are a subjective thing, but I do find them to feel better in the hand, although they also make the phone more slippery to me (and the rounded edges actually negatively affect the durabilty of the screen, which is one of the reasons they changed it).
 
  • Like
Reactions: nottorp
I do at least like the feel of the rounded corners from the past couple years than the totally flat edges from before.
 
The iPhone that introduced Lock Screen controls and a redesigned Control Center will forever be stuck with that very same Lock Screen and Control Center.
The supposedly biggest iPhone since the iPhone will forever be a testament to Apple‘s stubbornness and their restrictive design choices. It really is sad.
Right, the X honestly could have gotten iOS 18 easily. Remember 10 years ago when an iPhone received only 3-5 iOS versions and started to lose almost half of the new features by the second large update? For example, an iPhone 4 not getting very many features in iOS 6, or a 3G not getting wallpapers/multitasking in iOS 4. The iPhone X was good enough to not suffer any of that. It never had many features cut from its updates or anything like that.

The hardware by the time the iPhone X came out was so good that there is no reason it couldn't have received both 17 and 18. There is nothing inherently hardware intensive in either of those updates that prevented the X from updating. There is AI, but that is limited to 15 Pro series and up anyways, so it's irrelevant. It was literally just Apple's decision to axe it off, just because. It was the iPhone that changed everything, and yet it got less years of support than a 6S or a XR, despite having the same RAM as a XR and barely less of a processor (A11 Bionic vs A12 Bionic). The whole thing just makes zero sense.

I would never run a phone that long anyways, but it was dumb how it played out regardless. There was no reason to kill it, and yet they did.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Apple$ and Parowdy
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.