Nope.....at least it will take much longer to get the same ‘effect’. IMO the Bareneia leather is much more 'open' and therefore more vulnerable to external influences like dirt, grease, water etc. Probably also UV.
The Apple Classic Band feels and behaves more like plastic, at least if seems to unnatural in many ways. It does not smell like leather and it really takes some time to get in supple. But for that reason it is also the perfect companion to Hermès owners who do not like to wear the Barenia every day. Also mind you, leather needs rest - as your leather shoes - so never ever wear it day after day.
Last but not least: don’t mess around with any Hermès band and please ask Hermès what to do.
I made a photo for you: from the left to the right.
1) Hermès Fauve Barenia (not much use)
2) Hermès Fauve Barenia with deployment buckle (unused)
3) Apple Classic Buckle (unused)
4) Apple Classic Buckle (pimped and used)
5) Apple Classic Buckle (pimped and unused)
The Hermès Fauve Barenia is clearly darkened, probably by UV and vinger grease.
For pimping the Apple Classic Buckle see here:
https://forums.macrumors.com/thread...sic-buckle-band-thread.2080208/#post-25296150
View attachment 728343