I don’t post frequently, but I wanted to chime in on the Safari URL address bar situation. I think that Beta 6 is a step back in many ways, but it can be made to work well if some critical adjustments are made. I have outlined them below.
First, the URL and the whole tab bar section is very large and takes up a lot of screen real estate. It would be good to find a way to “shrink” the amount of space it takes up when on-screen to something closer to what was in prior betas.
Second, the iconography is unintuitive. The “aA” button on the left side implies only text size adjustments, however it has a long-press reader mode behind it as well as an entire menu system to adjust how the page was loaded (with or without blockers, desktop or mobile, etc.). This does not make much sense and if it is to remain this way the icon should be changed to something that indicates this is a menu. Rather than making this an all-encompassing menu, I think there is a better approach outlined below, while changing this icon to reflect reader mode and related text adjustments only. That is, just make it a dedicated reader mode icon with related actions.
Third, it would be wise to move the “Turn Off Content Blockers” and “Requested Desktop Website” as long press context menu on the “Reload” button as these both reload the page anyway.
Fourth, “Website Settings”, “Privacy Report”, “Hide Toolbar”, and text size adjustments should be moved to the long press context menu of the URL, together with the copy and other features as they pertain to the page in general.
Fifth, “Move to Tab Group” should be removed from the URL context menu. It is already on the tab button when long pressed and unnecessary.
Sixth, “Show Top Address Bar” should be only in Safari Settings with the default set to the tab mode, otherwise too many will likely just switch back to “old and familiar”, negating the benefits of the change. The key to adoption is to leave the new tab mode the default and require the user to make the change in Settings explicitly.
Seventh, the tab bar should automatically hide and stay hidden even if the user scrolls up. The current implementation where the bar expands when scrolling up severely reduces screen real estate when using the tab bar to a point of affecting usability and usefulness of this mode. The bar should unhide only on user tap as it is now when collapsed and scrolling down on the page.
I have sent this feedback to Apple and am posting it here for anyone else that agrees and would like to echo the feedback to Apple.
Thanks all!