Nah. I think it'll be good. They're going to still most likely have Apple IDs attached to them and host them.
This could open doors to plugin frameworks for desktop class apps on the iPad.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iOS 17 to Support App Sideloading to Comply With European Regulations
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
This could open doors to plugin frameworks for desktop class apps on the iPad.
Let's just hope the apps that we need to use don't back out of the app store and make us hunt them down one by one in third party stores and their own sites, with no checks for security and user experience.
But I think it will happen for many of the apps that people use.
Last edited:
I wouldn’t be getting too excited if not in an EU country, they’ll easily lock this down somehow if on a carrier provided phone for example.
You get the problem and illustrate it perfectly.
You build a competitive advantage (this isn't a monopoly) and a government gets to take it away.
Add to their forcing USBc - which I would like apple to do but forcing them to do it I don't. What if they had decided back when that all phones had to accept USB-a (or whatever the fat one is called.)
If you cheer the government forcing businesses to do things one day you may find the pigs standing on their feet.
Two close friends. Tee shirts with a custom local design (which they stole the design and and were sued), and deer stands. These were both at local Walmarts, not corporate.
I wonder how app developers feel about it. Yeah, sure, you don't have to pay Apple's fees on transactions but now people will be able to download cracked versions of your apps. Not sure if it will be beneficial to everybody.
Until the day you can’t find your favorite app on AppStore any longer except you have to sideload it.
Not sure how I feel about that. I do 'side load' most of my apps on my Mac even when the same app is available on the App Store, but my iPhone has been working just fine and it stores an incredible amount of sensitive information, and it's much more portable than my Mac. I guess I'll just have to take it slow.
Right now, if an app attempts to circumvent those technical restrictions by doing dodgy/hacky stuff, the App Store review usually filters them out (yes, sometimes things get through, but given the number of app rejections versus the number of malware on iOS vs android, rarely). When there's sideloading, that barrier disappears.
Does anybody have a suggestion for an alternate OS that’ll keep me safe? Looking for an OS where I can’t do literally anything other than use the built-in stock apps and cry.
Exactly!! If a developer wants me to use their app and give them my money it will be through the App Store. Full stop.
warranty will expire as soon as someone sideloads it. Apple would do that
This is by far my biggest issue with it. My parents and Grandparents believe every damn thing they read online. Many time before have they asked me to fix their laptops as they are taking ages to turn on and open thing and each time there are dozens of apps installed that claim to speed to the device.
Since getting iPads I haven't had one of those calls.
I'm really hoping the option to allow side loading is buried deep in settings and gives multiple prompts about how it is potentially unsafe and not to do it if you are being pressured by someone over the phone etc.
And so iOS became Android. Now we are going to need to install a virusscanner on or iPhones just like you have on Android. The OS will be less secure and privacy will be less protected.
Good job EU!
I am going to import my next iPhone from the US.
Good job EU!
I am going to import my next iPhone from the US.
This is complete BS. You’re confusing Apple-imposed App Store restrictions with a full-on system exploit/jailbreak.
Yet another example of Apple caving to EU government tyranny. I'm looking forward to when they force iMessage to be fully interoperable with SMS and I can buy a cheap Android that will send/receive blue iMessages.
Since the App Store review has let entirely scam apps thru reviews and apps that deceive and charge insane monthly fees, my opinion of the "safety" of the app store has dramatically declined. So this might not be any worse for users, at least savvy users. I hope.
well, it certainly has not happened with Google PlayStore. Only apps that would not have been approved anyway are using 3rd party stores only. Any normal app is available at multiple stores. Would be stupid to drop the one with most reach
Excellent news! Well done EU. Will be nice to have more options for developers and consumers. Those who want to just stick to App Store can.
I expect not. It’s an EU law.
And before everyone gets too excited, this is just a different way to buy an app. Apple can still dictate standards that apps need to achieve. This will probably lower costs a bit. But that’s all I expect.
I wonder if sideloading will be enabled here in the states?! I just want to side load game emulators lol
Sideloading doesn’t mean full unrestricted access to the system. You can’t sideload any random app and suddenly have access to every apps on the system. Sandboxing is still in place and enforced by the system on a deeper level that no apps will have access to.
The benefit of sideloading is the freedom to install apps that Apple would reject because of their own competitive interests and unreasonable review process.
Imagine Microsoft’s GamePass App Store, nothing malicious about it and yet Apple refuses it.
The benefit of sideloading is the freedom to install apps that Apple would reject because of their own competitive interests and unreasonable review process.
Imagine Microsoft’s GamePass App Store, nothing malicious about it and yet Apple refuses it.
The real question is what it means to side-load an app. Specifically, can apps be loaded directly to the phone? Or does it mean allowing third-parties to install their own app stores on phones? If it's the latter then Apple could comply by only approving third-party stores in the App Store which pay a commission to Apple for each sale.
Best guess, this will be like in days past, where financial apps detected if the device was jailbroken and wouldn't work. I know my Bank of America app did that. Guessing something similar will happen. If you sideload apps, it will detect that and tell you it won't run due to security issues.
This is a terrible idea and only justified by governmental authorities who want access to the encryption of Apple devices.