If you say so.
"Save image as" is not "Save to Files". They are two different OSs. I wish my iPad had macOS.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPad as a laptop replacement
- Thread starter Omar Comin' Yo
- WikiPost WikiPost
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
- Status
"Save image as" is not "Save to Files". They are two different OSs. I wish my iPad had macOS.
well it doesn’t, get over it.
They are functionally identical, you save an image with a name to an arbitrary location on the file system.
Complaining that they have different names is silly.
They’re trolling, not remotely interested in learning what iPad can actually do.
Better off with 13” if replacing a laptop, 11” too small imo.
I have a iMac too so 11” suits me as a hand held iPad.
I have a iMac too so 11” suits me as a hand held iPad.
I’m considering getting the 11” and keyboard as an occasional laptop, but still use my MBA M2 as the main day to day work laptop.
What would be nice is to take an iPad to a coffee shop and do some light stuff, or if I’m on holiday etc.
I do a lot of Keynote stuff. The only concern I have is that iPad Keynote is clearly built for touch, and compared to Mac Keynote, it’s pretty average.
Other than that, I do a lot of branding consultations. Viewing websites, etc.
Just wonder whether my use case is alright for iPad. I want the 11” so that I can use it as a tablet on holiday too.
What would be nice is to take an iPad to a coffee shop and do some light stuff, or if I’m on holiday etc.
I do a lot of Keynote stuff. The only concern I have is that iPad Keynote is clearly built for touch, and compared to Mac Keynote, it’s pretty average.
Other than that, I do a lot of branding consultations. Viewing websites, etc.
Just wonder whether my use case is alright for iPad. I want the 11” so that I can use it as a tablet on holiday too.
For very light typing, nothing heavy, 11” + Magic Keyboard would be OK though, wouldn’t it?
I just picked up the 11” Magic Keyblard and trying it out for the first time. It’s not bad, a lot more usable than I first thought it would be. The keys are a bit mushy and I can’t type as fast as I can on a regular Apple keyboard but it’s a nice experience overall. The trackpad is small, yeah, but very usable with default tracking speed settings. Overall it’s a good buy, I won’t be returning mine.
I also found iPad + keyboard to be a better vacation travel companion (w/light work) than my MacBook Air.
I did find the Magic Keyboard a little too compromised, however. Instead I started taking my MX Keys Mini and returned the MK. Much nicer keyboard experience and no need to swap back and forth on the folio covers.
The new MKB for the 13" M4 really does make it feel like a true laptop in many ways. HOWEVER by many accounts it is still quite lousy to use on a lap and that is going to matter for some people, myself included. I use my MBP often in bed on my lap.
You also have to factor in price. If I was forced to get a new laptop tomorrow I'd get the base model M2 MBA for $850 brand new. That is nearly half the price of the 13" base model M4 iPP plus MKB (both at retail granted). And while you also do get a tablet to boot with the iPP I'm personally not a fan of using the 13" size in-hand. So in reality if I did get the 13" iPP it would exclusively be used with the MKB. And if that is the case, the MBA is the clear choice, at least for me.
I think this also applies to countless consumers. They would be better off, for example, getting a base model M2 MBA plus a base model 11" iPA versus a 13" iPP with the MKB. You'd be saving money along the way as well.
You also have to factor in price. If I was forced to get a new laptop tomorrow I'd get the base model M2 MBA for $850 brand new. That is nearly half the price of the 13" base model M4 iPP plus MKB (both at retail granted). And while you also do get a tablet to boot with the iPP I'm personally not a fan of using the 13" size in-hand. So in reality if I did get the 13" iPP it would exclusively be used with the MKB. And if that is the case, the MBA is the clear choice, at least for me.
I think this also applies to countless consumers. They would be better off, for example, getting a base model M2 MBA plus a base model 11" iPA versus a 13" iPP with the MKB. You'd be saving money along the way as well.
That’s looking at the situation with a bias for Macs though (understandable considering this is MacRumors).
These stats are pretty interesting.
Tablet Screen Resolution Stats United States Of America | Statcounter Global Stats
This graph shows the stats of tablet screen resolutions in United States Of America based on over 5 billion monthly page views.
gs.statcounter.com
A lot of iPad users are likely still on 7.9/9.7” and the next largest share is for the 10.2” (7th - 9th gen) followed by 10.9” (10th gen, Air 4-5). Most people simply aren’t buying iPad Pros. Those that do probably have their own reasons unrelated to Macs.
I have the M1 MBA which just sits unused and I expect the same will be the case if I were to upgrade to the M2/M3 MBA. MacBooks are just a waste of money for me.
Meanwhile, I use every one of my primary iPads for at least 10 hours a week. Admittedly, the Mini is getting the brunt of usage at 8+ hours daily. The M1 12.9 is averaging ~30-40 hours a week (typically used as 3rd display for email, Google Meet/Chat, PDF markup, etc. while I have other things on the dual monitor desktop).
No it's not. There are still concessions being made with respect to iPadOS vs macOS and also the ergonomics of the MGK. While I do think the function row and larger trackpad are especially awesome on the new MGK, by all accounts I've read it still isn't as functional when not used on a hard flat surface. A lot of consumers don't exclusively use their laptops on a hard surface.
If the new MKBs were ideal to use in all physical situations, then I would be more open to the idea of them as a laptop replacement for many (assuming you are cool with using iPadOS over macOS). But that isn't the case. And like I said prior, the MBA will work better as a laptop in such scenarios so you are better off with an M2 MBA and an M2 iPA (assuming you want a tablet as well).
What exactly do you use your iPads for and why do you have more than one?That’s looking at the situation with a bias for Macs though (understandable considering this is MacRumors).
These stats are pretty interesting.
Tablet Screen Resolution Stats United States Of America | Statcounter Global Stats
This graph shows the stats of tablet screen resolutions in United States Of America based on over 5 billion monthly page views.
A lot of iPad users are likely still on 7.9/9.7” and the next largest share is for the 10.2” (7th - 9th gen) followed by 10.9” (10th gen, Air 4-5). Most people simply aren’t buying iPad Pros. Those that do probably have their own reasons unrelated to Macs.
I have the M1 MBA which just sits unused and I expect the same will be the case if I were to upgrade to the M2/M3 MBA. MacBooks are just a waste of money for me.
Meanwhile, I use every one of my primary iPads for at least 10 hours a week. Admittedly, the Mini is getting the brunt of usage at 8+ hours daily. The M1 12.9 is averaging ~30-40 hours a week (typically used as 3rd display for email, Google Meet/Chat, PDF markup, etc. while I have other things on the dual monitor desktop).
Mostly reading (novels, fanfics, comics, etc), anime and browsing. Plus the usual stuff - shopping, banking, paying bills, taxes, etc. Basically almost all the same stuff I do on the laptop.
The 12.9 also gets used as an office companion device (PDF markup, checking emails, instant messages, video conferencing, etc).
I don’t like using my iPads while charging. The cable gets in the way plus I feel like I’m gonna break the USB-C port so I just swap iPads when my current one needs to be charged.
Before (especially when iPads were RAM-starved and sometimes even now), dual iPads was also my “multitasking/split view”.
I also like to optimize screen sizes based on the content I’m viewing.
mini: webcomics
10-11”: manga
13”: American comics
Last edited:
Here in Canada you can get a brand new M3 Air with 16GB ram for the same price as the 13" M4 iPad with pencil 2. Then you have to get a keyboard on top for the ipad. A no brainer which id choose.
Of course, there is a bias. You are clearly coming at it from a Mac perspective... I use my MGK on the bed and on my lap, not entirely on hard surface. And I have no issue with the ergonomics, but I think what you are omitting here is I don't have to exclusively use it as a laptop.
I can take it off and use it as a tablet if I so choose, which using an MBA... is a no-go.
Now, for a value or cost perspective... buying a M2 MBA and M2 iPA totally makes sense. But this whole "ergonomics of the MGK" situation is something that an individual need to experience for themselves.
This is not at all what I have read in reviews, on this forum, and on Reddit. The overwhelming consensus is that the MKB with the 13” M4 iPP is not comfortable to use whatsoever on a lap, etc.
I'm not saying you are wrong, or the reviews are... my point is that it's a case-by-case situation.
And at this point, there's plenty of naysayers against using an iPad as laptop replacement to begin with. So, they employ use whatever reason to discredit the use of it.
Last edited:
I agree. But honestly you in the small minority that say the MKB works well on a lap.
It's a generic problem with tablets with keyboards and 2-in-1 laptops. Standard laptops have weight in the keyboard body while tablets and 2-in-1's have the weight in the vertical display - they are inherently unstable in your lap and you need to use the palm rests to steady them. My Pro & MKB are no worse - or better - in this regard than my Surface Pro. The SP may be more difficult as it has the kickstand extending its length.
Heck, I'm in the small minority who believes in an iPad as a laptop replacement lol.
But it's one of those situations where the user hands are placed on the palm rest; they have a trackpad to navigate around iPadOS. And then the screen is titled to where it's viewable... I personally think it's much ado about nothing.
A user encounters an issue when they decide to use it as a touchscreen while docked to the MGK (because it do have a potential of tipping over) ... when the point of the MGK is to use it as a laptop, not a tablet.
I have both at home and I use my 13” with Magic Keyboard more or less only in my lap. The macs try to slide off my lap while the iPad stays put so my iPad is comfortable to use in a lot more situations.
That’s the reason I sold my own MBP, it was way more annoying to use when not on a table.
No, I don’t think you are the only one. And you and I know that.
My iPad replaced my MacBook as of iPadOS 16 beta 2. The week of WWDC I bought my M1 iPP and sold my Air4.
Being honest some of the times, especially in the early days’, I had some minor issues With iPadOS, but hey, after all it still was beta and with the release of iPadOS 17 beta 1 all was smooth sailing form there.
I still hope Rapid weaver comes to the iPad because this and Altstore are the only apps I still need my MacBook for. I don’t see myself ever buying a new MacBook As long as I can get by using my old MacBook for the Altstore function of Sideloading.
I even introduced the iPad in the workplace and put all my co-workers on one.
My office space. Me and my co-workers all have the “same” setup. They have the Air 5 with a 25” ultrasharp monitor and the apple keyboard and trackpad combo. For the out of office time they have a MKB knockoff That works on BT, but gets the job done.
Last edited: