Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

iPad as a laptop replacement

Status
The first post of this thread is a WikiPost and can be edited by anyone with the appropiate permissions. Your edits will be public.
Most of the videos I have seen on YT about the new M4 have done a real disservice to the iPad, in my opinion, because the videos have been framed as a laptop replacement test. The YouTubers are doing it to get revenue and unfortunately, a lot of people will disregard the iPad as a very simple video player, when there is so much more it can do. I think the new iPad can be the main device for many, many people, even on MR.
 
  • Like
Reactions: teralpar, Matz, Kal Madda and 3 others
Apple_Robert said:
Most of the videos I have seen on YT about the new M4 have done a real disservice to the iPad, in my opinion, because the videos have been framed as a laptop replacement test. The YouTubers are doing it to get revenue and unfortunately, a lot of people will disregard the iPad as a very simple video player, when there is so much more it can do. I think the new iPad can be the main device for many, many people, even on MR.
Click to expand...
Agree on this, YouTube reviews are very often terrible. The reviewers want to get their videos out first so they do superficial ones and don’t make any effort to see what’s capable. Some do, but they’re the exception.

It’s the same thing with the durability videos. Why are we seeing people take a naked iPad and intentionally break it? It’s irrelevant to everyday use and there is no meaningful conversion from “full strength grip trying to bend a naked iPad” to “accidentally sat on my iPad while it’s in a case.”
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kal Madda, Arctic Moose and Apple_Robert
Apple_Robert said:
Most of the videos I have seen on YT about the new M4 have done a real disservice to the iPad, in my opinion, because the videos have been framed as a laptop replacement test. The YouTubers are doing it to get revenue and unfortunately, a lot of people will disregard the iPad as a very simple video player, when there is so much more it can do. I think the new iPad can be the main device for many, many people, even on MR.
Click to expand...
This guy at 9to5Mac (Fernando Silva) is my favorite iPad Pro Youtuber. Used to have his own YouTube channel, but is with 9to5Mac now. Give him a try. I think you may like him.




 
  • Like
Reactions: Kal Madda and Apple_Robert
bondr006 said:
This guy at 9to5Mac (Fernando Silva) is my favorite iPad Pro Youtuber. Used to have his own YouTube channel, but is with 9to5Mac now. Give him a try. I think you may like him.




Click to expand...
He is one of the exceptions. I have seen several of his videos and for being a big Apple fan, he does try to be fair and balanced, instead of the typical all is roses with everything released.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kal Madda and bondr006
Apple_Robert said:
He is one of the exceptions. I have seen several of his videos and for being a big Apple fan, he does try to be fair and balanced, instead of the typical all is roses with everything released.
Click to expand...
I don't find this at all - that entire web site is run by hard core Apples fans (which is fine), but unbiased is definitely not their strong suit.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: bondr006
richpjr said:
I don't find this at all - that entire web site is run by hard core Apples fans (which is fine), but unbiased is definitely not their strong suit.
Click to expand...
Nothing wrong with being a fan of the devices you like to use. The world is full of them. Fernando is enthusiastic for sure, but is also very honest, fair, and balanced. He will call out Apple when he see's a need for it, and I have seen him do just that many times.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kal Madda
bondr006 said:
This guy at 9to5Mac (Fernando Silva) is my favorite iPad Pro Youtuber. Used to have his own YouTube channel, but is with 9to5Mac now. Give him a try. I think you may like him.




Click to expand...
I can’t stand the same thumbnails over and over again. Like he is full of himself. I only watch the videos when I don’t see him in de thumbnail. I know.. its a me problem.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: xxFoxtail, richpjr and bondr006
Webcat86 said:
Agree on this, YouTube reviews are very often terrible. The reviewers want to get their videos out first so they do superficial ones and don’t make any effort to see what’s capable. Some do, but they’re the exception.

It’s the same thing with the durability videos. Why are we seeing people take a naked iPad and intentionally break it? It’s irrelevant to everyday use and there is no meaningful conversion from “full strength grip trying to bend a naked iPad” to “accidentally sat on my iPad while it’s in a case.”
Click to expand...
I personally stay away from those durability videos; those are click baits!

But for the most part... I like watching DailyTekk channel, Chris does well when it comes to showing what the iPad is capable of. And Christopher Lawley is a go-to source for iPad-focused content as well. And @bondr006 mentions a good one, I liked when Fernando had his own channel.

He did better when it came to tutorials and stuff, I think now with a bigger audience... it's just not the same anymore. And I can't really decide on why exactly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kal Madda and bondr006
Ludatyk said:
I personally stay away from those durability videos; those are click baits!

But for the most part... I like watching DailyTekk channel, Chris does well when it comes to showing what the iPad is capable of. And Christopher Lawley is a go-to source for iPad-focused content as well. And @bondr006 mentions a good one, I liked when Fernando had his own channel.

He did better when it came to tutorials and stuff, I think now with a bigger audience... it's just not the same anymore. And I can't really decide on why exactly.
Click to expand...
This gent is excellent. He mainly does tips and tutorials. In less than 6 months, he has gone from about 56K followers to over 356K. No hype, no fancy camera angles showing unnecessary Apple bling products to show off.

 
  • Like
Reactions: bondr006 and Ludatyk
Ludatyk said:
I personally stay away from those durability videos; those are click baits!

But for the most part... I like watching DailyTekk channel, Chris does well when it comes to showing what the iPad is capable of. And Christopher Lawley is a go-to source for iPad-focused content as well. And @bondr006 mentions a good one, I liked when Fernando had his own channel.

He did better when it came to tutorials and stuff, I think now with a bigger audience... it's just not the same anymore. And I can't really decide on why exactly.
Click to expand...
Yep those are some exceptions, I’m a big fan of Lawley too
 
Apple_Robert said:
This gent is excellent. He mainly does tips and tutorials. In less than 6 months, he has gone from about 56K followers to over 356K. No hype, no fancy camera angles showing unnecessary Apple bling products to show off.

Click to expand...

I find the tips and tutorial videos to be useful at time. I skip the review videos as I really don't care what their opinion on the device is - I'll make my own judgement for myself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kal Madda, bondr006, Apple_Robert and 1 other person
Apple_Robert said:
This gent is excellent. He mainly does tips and tutorials. In less than 6 months, he has gone from about 56K followers to over 356K. No hype, no fancy camera angles showing unnecessary Apple bling products to show off.

Click to expand...
Yeah, I came across his channel before... I believed I watched his iPadOS 18 video.

I like it when reviewers take their thoughts away from the video (be critical of the device, but not overcritical of it) ... not to say I don't care for any kind of personality but showcase the tips and any new tutorials. That's it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kal Madda and bondr006
I will no longer be using my iPad as a laptop replacement after getting my S9 Ultra. The experience and functionality is night and day. I can't believe I wasted this much time with the iPad when a far better experience has always been on the other side. I guess better late than never but boy I have been missing out all this time. S9 Ultra has a perfect file management system and can easily replace my laptop. Full mouse support on Android, I will never use a mouse on any iPad again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bondr006
DeepSix said:
I will no longer be using my iPad as a laptop replacement after getting my S9 Ultra. The experience and functionality is night and day. I can't believe I wasted this much time with the iPad when a far better experience has always been on the other side. I guess better late than never but boy I have been missing out all this time. S9 Ultra has a perfect file management system and can easily replace my laptop. Full mouse support on Android, I will never use a mouse on any iPad again.
Click to expand...

I'm happy I returned my S9 Ultra.
 
DeepSix said:
I will no longer be using my iPad as a laptop replacement after getting my S9 Ultra. The experience and functionality is night and day. I can't believe I wasted this much time with the iPad when a far better experience has always been on the other side. I guess better late than never but boy I have been missing out all this time. S9 Ultra has a perfect file management system and can easily replace my laptop. Full mouse support on Android, I will never use a mouse on any iPad again.
Click to expand...
Considering you have been posting relentlessly about the same subject for what seems like an eternity, with a misguided hope you could convince others that your purchase would persuade others (or more likely - convince yourself), we can only hope that you will now leave the iPad forum and frequent the S9 forum.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
  • Wow
Reactions: teralpar, eltoslightfoot, Kal Madda and 8 others
NastyMatt said:
Considering you have been posting relentlessly about the same subject for what seems like an eternity, with a misguided hope you could convince others that your purchase would persuade others (or more likely - convince yourself), we can only hope that you will now leave the iPad forum and frequent the S9 forum.
Click to expand...
me peers taught me to recognise the presence of a master… I am taking a bow @NastyMatt -san. 🙇‍♀️😁
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: Kal Madda, NastyMatt and bondr006
Apple_Robert said:
Most of the videos I have seen on YT about the new M4 have done a real disservice to the iPad, in my opinion, because the videos have been framed as a laptop replacement test. The YouTubers are doing it to get revenue and unfortunately, a lot of people will disregard the iPad as a very simple video player, when there is so much more it can do. I think the new iPad can be the main device for many, many people, even on MR.
Click to expand...
I totally agree with you. 👍🏻. I moved to an iPad Pro as my primary computer a few years ago, and I haven’t looked back since. I do still have a Mac Mini, but don’t really need it for my workflow, just is more a nice-to-have thing to stay current on macOS and to save local backups of my iPad to when I’m testing betas on my iPad. 👍🏻
 
  • Like
Reactions: bondr006
bondr006 said:
This guy at 9to5Mac (Fernando Silva) is my favorite iPad Pro Youtuber. Used to have his own YouTube channel, but is with 9to5Mac now. Give him a try. I think you may like him.




Click to expand...
I second this, I really appreciate his approach. He’s definitely my favorite YouTube iPad reviewer. He tends to be very fair and balanced, and also careful to not overstate his position in either direction. He’s able to strike a really good balance. 👍🏻
 
  • Like
Reactions: bondr006
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back