My wife has only had hers a few days, but she switches between it and the bumper with the cross body several times a day and it’s still nice and tight.
Mine for my 17PM is perfect too. I’ve heard about creaking and a loose fit, but mines perfect. It’s actually difficult to remove.
One other issue I noted with Horween leather is it can stain some surfaces it comes into contact with, at least when it’s new. It has a great feel and aroma though.
For the second time this year I received a used case that was sold as new on Amazon. Has anyone else experienced this? It seems to be getting worse lately.