I’m sure you’ll get a range of answers, but for me even the Mini is too big, so… 😆
I still use my smartphone like how they were initially used back in the day—useful but occasional and quick interactions, usually one-handed. Those initial 3.5” - 4” displays were purposely optimized for that type of usage, so it’s still the best size for me. Obviously I just have to make do with what’s available, but everything bigger than 4”, even the Mini with its longer display, becomes only a comparable disadvantage to me, as one-handed usability quickly drops off as screens grow above 4”, and all advantages of a bigger display/device are wasted on me (even with typing I’m pretty equally proficient with one-thumb swipe typing on a small screen as I am with two thumb tap typing on a big screen).
Not to say I don’t do a lot of consumption too. But the difference is while people want a big phone mainly so that they can consume anywhere any time, I prefer to do all of my consumption at home and work (during breaks of course 😆). I make it a point to only consume there, actually. And coincidentally, these places are where I have other devices that are much better suited for consumption (iPad, computer, TV). So a phone reallllly doesn't need to be a good consumption device for me. In fact, I want it to be as physically unsubstantial as possible (but still functional). I dislike things in my pocket, so the less metal and glass I can carry in there, the better.
But there aren’t a lot of people like me, it seems pretty clear.