Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

thebeautyisfake

macrumors regular
Original poster
Mar 4, 2010
109
0
I’ve been a fairly happy Apple/OS/X user for the past three to four years. Before that, I was a Windows user that finally became disgusted enough to finally make the jump.

Most computer users are well aware of the arguments, both pro and con.

Up until now, I’ve been happy. Up until now, everything simply worked. Ahem, up until now…

What is different now? It’s called Lion. Depending on what you use your machine for, Lion can be great. However, there’s a dark side to Apple’s latest feline incarnation. If you use a wide variety of software with your particular Mac, chances are Lion is going to break things – perhaps things that you rely on. Say, a podcasting application called “Ubercaster” that no longer functions 100% for starters, or how about a Verizon USB 3G aircard that worked fine in both Leopard and Snow Leopard, but Lion somehow just cannot recognize?

Being a long-time Windows user, I’m used to the new version of the O/S screwing things up, sometimes royally. However, that bad Microsoft habit of releasing half-baked, buggy operating system updates seems to have migrated from Redmond down to Cupertino.

It wasn’t as if I expected something like this might happen. I’m prepared – I have a backup machine in the form of a 13” white plastic Macbook that I purposely kept on Snow Leopard. Unfortunately, the most recent Snow Leopard updates Apple has sent out have broken Ubercaster entirely on that machine, rendering the backup machine rather useless at the moment for podcast recording. The Ubercaster application will no longer load, even the latest updated version.

Ubercaster still works on my Macbook Pro running Lion, but the setup is now unreliable.

Also, Lion seems to not even work properly with Apple’s own hardware. When I touch the touchpad on my 3-year-old Macbook Pro 17 it no longer makes the screen wake up after it has turned off – it’s now necessary to hit a key to make the screen come back on.

What was Apple thinking? Probably of money.



http://www.geeknewscentral.com/2011/07/30/is-apple-turning-into-microsoft/
 

MacDawg

Moderator emeritus
Mar 20, 2004
19,823
4,504
"Between the Hedges"
Tripe like this always accompanies a new OS release
New release bashing is a sport and you have to do it to be cool
Where is the fun in writing about "it just works"

When SL was released there were screams emanating from the pits of hell
Now SL is hailed as the greatest OS and Lion is the spawn of Satan
 

r0k

macrumors 68040
Mar 3, 2008
3,612
76
Detroit
Lion broke a few things around here as well...

1 - NAS - easy fix with new LaCie firmware

2 - Crashplan - easy fix with JVM download

3 - VNC - none of my iPad VNC apps work with Lion yet

Lion is not the first Apple OS that has caused me to run out and buy hardware to install it. Leopard was the reason I found out about putty knives to upgrade Mac Mini memory. Lion has led me to upgrade the memory in all our Minis again. I don't see Apple turning into Microsoft because of this. I picked up the phone, called AppleCare and found out I get 90 days "grace period" on all my 4+ year old hardware because I purchased Lion. Try that with Microsoft.
 

thejadedmonkey

macrumors G3
May 28, 2005
9,240
3,496
Pennsylvania
Lion broke a few things around here as well...

1 - NAS - easy fix with new LaCie firmware

2 - Crashplan - easy fix with JVM download

3 - VNC - none of my iPad VNC apps work with Lion yet

Lion is not the first Apple OS that has caused me to run out and buy hardware to install it. Leopard was the reason I found out about putty knives to upgrade Mac Mini memory. Lion has led me to upgrade the memory in all our Minis again. I don't see Apple turning into Microsoft because of this. I picked up the phone, called AppleCare and found out I get 90 days "grace period" on all my 4+ year old hardware because I purchased Lion. Try that with Microsoft.

Microsoft gives you "90 days of Microsoft Support Services included" with a copy of Windows, too. You don't need to try anything, it's included ;)
 

robgendreau

macrumors 68040
Jul 13, 2008
3,471
339
New stuff breaks old stuff on computers. Always has, always will.

The reason we get pissed is because we hate to be surprised when it's our stuff, our important stuff that breaks. And Apple, because they are a big uncaring corporation in it for the $$, rarely acknowledges any problems. They are now much bigger than MS, and they act like it.

Take the OP's example: Apple hasn't acknowledged a problem, but the developer of Ubercaster has, and immediately committed to working on a fix to what appears to be Apple's mistake. Same is true with VNC (although more of a change in procedure than a bug); the small developers have been far more helpful than Apple.

I like Apple's stuff. But the more they control, the worse for us. Sure it makes for a uniform user experience, but they are now the drones on the screen, not the hammer thrower.

Rob
 

Jagardn

macrumors 6502a
Apr 18, 2011
668
2
New stuff breaks old stuff on computers. Always has, always will.

The reason we get pissed is because we hate to be surprised when it's our stuff, our important stuff that breaks. And Apple, because they are a big uncaring corporation in it for the $$, rarely acknowledges any problems. They are now much bigger than MS, and they act like it.

Take the OP's example: Apple hasn't acknowledged a problem, but the developer of Ubercaster has, and immediately committed to working on a fix to what appears to be Apple's mistake. Same is true with VNC (although more of a change in procedure than a bug); the small developers have been far more helpful than Apple.

I like Apple's stuff. But the more they control, the worse for us. Sure it makes for a uniform user experience, but they are now the drones on the screen, not the hammer thrower.

Rob

Aren't corporations supposed to make money? Yeah, by the looks of Apples stock price, they must not be making their customers happy. :rolleyes:
 

*LTD*

macrumors G4
Feb 5, 2009
10,703
1
Canada
I'm not sure how that's even possible product-wise. The two companies hold radically different philosophies when it comes to how people should be using tech. MS, as you might have guessed, has the wrong one.
 

AppleScruff1

macrumors G4
Feb 10, 2011
10,026
2,949
Apple could give 90 days of support too if they charged what Microsoft does. :rolleyes:

How much is it to buy OSX to use on Asus notebook? Could you just pop in the disk and do a clean install? Or since Lion isn't on disk, can you download it from the app store? How well does it work on non Apple hardware?
 

Kimbie

macrumors regular
Jan 6, 2010
175
24
UK
I'm not sure how that's even possible product-wise. The two companies hold radically different philosophies when it comes to how people should be using tech. MS, as you might have guessed, has the wrong one.

Care to elaborate on why you think Microsoft has the wrong philosophies when it comes to how people should be using tech?

From an enterprise point of view, Microsoft wipes the floor with Linux and OSX, I am not saying they are not used in enterprise, but the sheer ease of deploying oh I dont know a service pack or new software to multiple machines is an utter doodle compared to OSX.

Granted apple have got a good mobile space with the iphone, but that is stagnating, its closed, it has had no innovation since the original release, a speed bump and features added that have been around for years on other phones.

I would say neither of their philosophies are wrong, just people use technology in different ways.

Kimbie
 

KingCrimson

macrumors 65816
Mar 12, 2011
1,066
0
Care to elaborate on why you think Microsoft has the wrong philosophies when it comes to how people should be using tech?

From an enterprise point of view, Microsoft wipes the floor with Linux and OSX, I am not saying they are not used in enterprise, but the sheer ease of deploying oh I dont know a service pack or new software to multiple machines is an utter doodle compared to OSX.

Granted apple have got a good mobile space with the iphone, but that is stagnating, its closed, it has had no innovation since the original release, a speed bump and features added that have been around for years on other phones.

I would say neither of their philosophies are wrong, just people use technology in different ways.

Kimbie

I'd say the introduction of Retina Display in 2010 was a big innovation. Who knows what Apple has up it's sleeve for the IP5? Guaranteed it's something none of us could imagine and it will "change everything again".
 

TheSideshow

macrumors 6502
Apr 21, 2011
392
0
I'd say the introduction of Retina Display in 2010 was a big innovation. Who knows what Apple has up it's sleeve for the IP5? Guaranteed it's something none of us could imagine and it will "change everything again".

How is an improved screen resolution innovative?
 

Rodimus Prime

macrumors G4
Oct 9, 2006
10,136
4
I'd say the introduction of Retina Display in 2010 was a big innovation. Who knows what Apple has up it's sleeve for the IP5? Guaranteed it's something none of us could imagine and it will "change everything again".

To be fair they were not the first to do a hi rey screen and greater dpi screens on phones were out before hand.

But giving the iPhone changed smartphones apple has not really added anything innovating since thing on phones. That has gone to everyone else who has done that. Apple has either been playing copy cat/adding things that should of been there on day 1.
The os and the device has changed very little since the first iPhone in terms of ui
 

chrono1081

macrumors G3
Jan 26, 2008
8,721
5,191
Isla Nublar
Tripe like this always accompanies a new OS release
New release bashing is a sport and you have to do it to be cool
Where is the fun in writing about "it just works"

When SL was released there were screams emanating from the pits of hell
Now SL is hailed as the greatest OS and Lion is the spawn of Satan

This...

Not to mention its the DEVELOPERS responsibility to update their apps, not Apples. Developers had a long time to make their apps compliant.

To be fair they were not the first to do a hi rey screen and greater dpi screens on phones were out before hand.

Actually no there wasn't anything that matched it on the market. This was already beat to death on another thread and the closest handset was I believe a Sony or an HTC but it still didn't match the resolution of the iPhone 4, which did in fact have the densest screen when it was released.
 

maflynn

macrumors Haswell
May 3, 2009
73,682
43,740
How is an improved screen resolution innovative?

Because there's a fruit logo on the back. ;)

Seriously when apple release a product or an update, people crow and go on how innovative it is. Just look at how people received iOS 4's multitasking. From the sounds of a number of folks, its like they invented multitasking.
 

Shrink

macrumors G3
Feb 26, 2011
8,929
1,727
New England, USA
Tripe like this always accompanies a new OS release
New release bashing is a sport and you have to do it to be cool
Where is the fun in writing about "it just works"

When SL was released there were screams emanating from the pits of hell
Now SL is hailed as the greatest OS and Lion is the spawn of Satan

This ^ :D

Nothing wrong with well-considered, constructive criticism. The problem is that it is only cool to criticize. Anything supportive makes you a fanboy. :rolleyes:
 

vincebio

macrumors 6502a
Jun 27, 2005
792
48
Glasgow
unreal....are these bloggers complete idiots?

try and find out if the apps you have installed will be stable under Lion first before you jump into it and install it...

:rolleyes:
 

marcellus7

macrumors newbie
Mar 6, 2011
25
0
Not to mention its the DEVELOPERS responsibility to update their apps, not Apples. Developers had a long time to make their apps compliant.

Exactly. Lion was released in beta for developers months ago. If Apple or Microsoft would stop updating technology in order for all old applications to work, we would still be in the dark ages. New operating systems have always broken old stuff. (Unless it was just a 'touch up' upgrade.)
 

Steve121178

macrumors 603
Apr 13, 2010
6,463
7,170
Bedfordshire, UK
I'm not sure how that's even possible product-wise. The two companies hold radically different philosophies when it comes to how people should be using tech. MS, as you might have guessed, has the wrong one.

I look forward to reading your reasons why you think MS have it wrong.
 

rhett7660

macrumors G5
Jan 9, 2008
14,377
4,502
Sunny, Southern California
Tripe like this always accompanies a new OS release
New release bashing is a sport and you have to do it to be cool
Where is the fun in writing about "it just works"

When SL was released there were screams emanating from the pits of hell
Now SL is hailed as the greatest OS and Lion is the spawn of Satan

Isn't this the truth. I couldn't agree more.
 

neiltc13

macrumors 68040
May 27, 2006
3,128
28
I bought Lion. I'm still waiting for one feature to appear that is actually useful to me. I think I was a bit hasty in my purchase.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.