Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I agree, That mtr licensing protection scheme is way to complicated.
You are required to make a gift or donation, I think the magic number is $50.

Yes it a bit of a process but the directions are all spelled out for you step by step... ... Also $50 bucks is the "suggested gift" amount.
 
Yes it a bit of a process but the directions are all spelled out for you step by step... ... Also $50 bucks is the "suggested gift" amount.

Seemed more than a 'suggestion' to me. Though when I inquired, it was only $40, but I was under the impression that $40 is what I had to 'donate' to get it.
 
Sorry to be so late to this thread, but I'm not a frequent forum-goer. Anyhow, people who defend MacTheRipper's developer are funny.

Here is an application devoted to negating user-hostile anti-copying measures and onerous DRM.........which requires jumping through Kafkaesque user-hostile hoops as bad or worse as those that the application itself was made to work around. And then he complains when users break them and copy his software.

"Delusional" doesn't even begin to cover it.

a big +1

I've never gone to the trouble of upping from mt2.6 to mt3.
 
Gave up + VM Ware + Fab Decrypter

I finally gave up and used VM Ware/WinXP to run DVDFab Decrypter...It was so easy to set-up a virtual WinXP install I don't know why I didn't do it before.

Anyways, I installed the free version of DFD and it worked like a charm...bye-bye MTR
 
MTR 2.6.6 vs 3

I'm not sure I want to go the hassle of paying and licensing MTR. I've heard a lot people have had issues with having to repay, re-up, phoning home, etc.

Is is worth it to go through all the crap to obtain MTR3 or is there a better alternative?

Also does MTR 2.6.6 work okay under leopard on an intel mac? Is there a big speed difference between 2.6.6 and 3.x?

I used to use MTR a couple years ago, but then started to just use HB. I'd like to start ripping multiple DVD's and queue encodes in HB.

Any thoughts?

[I have only used 2.6.6, but can state that it works flawlessly under OS 10.5.5 on an Intel iMac. It is a slow process, however. While it varies, a typical DVD may take 40 minutes to rip. The burning, of course, is extra.]
 
Why not just use BootCamp? It'll be wayyy faster than any virtualization solution, and you can use it for free (other than the cost of Windows, which you have to get for virtualization too). It only takes 30 seconds to switch OS's.

-Biggie!
 
I was just reading about FairMount and I'm going to give it a try. Not sure if it's better, worse, or the same as far as disc compatibility, but it's truly free, GPL, and easy to get. I also like the idea of it just auto mounting decrypted media, so it's worth a shot.
 
I tried FairMount last night and it's pretty decent. Works as advertised, but since it was a pretty limited testing I'm not sure how good the compatibility is. It's based on VLC though which is big enough and cross platform that I assume it gets updated regularly so I'm hoping it'll be a MTR replacement for me (it's a lot simpler to use - not that MTR was difficult, just that this is really straightforward).
 
Use older version for Disney

Disney Pixar are the worst for putting bad sectors on their DVD's to defeat ripping.

I have found that using the older version (2.0.2 works for me) is what works on those trouble DVDs - I have yet to find one that crashed with the newer one that didn't work with the older one. I always keep a copy of this so I can back up my daughter's DVDs since they tend to get scratched the fastest, not to mention having them available on the AppleTV.
 
I'm not sure I want to go the hassle of paying and licensing MTR. I've heard a lot people have had issues with having to repay, re-up, phoning home, etc.?

We're not planning on going through the big hassle. They have this very unprofessional attitude about giving them a 'gift' :rolleyes: All they want to do is nickel and dime you to death, which is why everyone has problems with them. 2.6.6 has always worked fine.
 
Fairmount + DTOX

DVD2OneX might be pricey compared to other software just to get around ARccOS or RipGuard, but it seems to work well. Mac the Ripper might be good software (I've never used it), but the licensing system is a deal breaker for me. I'm just not comfortable with it and I certainly can't recommend it to anyone else.
 
I agree with the VM route. I just run a VM using Fusion2 and my Boot Camp partition and use DVDFab Decryptor to do the disc. Then just put the resulting folder into OS X for HandBrake.

I'm with others, the idea of gifting is ridiculous considering the point of the application. Somebody needs to get off their high-horse and come back to reality. Hell, Shrink was never more than free and it was a way more useful app than MTR.
 
I agree with the VM route. I just run a VM using Fusion2 and my Boot Camp partition and use DVDFab Decryptor to do the disc. Then just put the resulting folder into OS X for HandBrake.

I'm with others, the idea of gifting is ridiculous considering the point of the application. Somebody needs to get off their high-horse and come back to reality. Hell, Shrink was never more than free and it was a way more useful app than MTR.

Have you tried the DVDFab Decryptor with Crossover?
 
MTR Donation

In my experience, MTR (2.6 and 3.0) is the best program to dupe commercial discs for safe-keeping. What's the big deal of supporting the programmer if the software works as well as it does. My only complaint--and I've offered this before--is that although he/she asks for a donation, he offers no instruction on how to make it. I'd gladly send him/her a check if I knew to whom and where to send it!

MTR is a fantastic program!
 
If you have access to a window's machine then go with DVDFab HD Decryptor. Its free, its updated, and it hasn't failed me yet. I've ripped all my movies now converted them to mpeg2 so I can stream them to my TiVo.

Can you please give me a step-by-step on how to transfer a movie file to TiVo? I've never found out how to do this.
 
What's the big deal of supporting the programmer if the software works as well as it does.

DVD2OneX costs a good bit itself, but it doesn't come with a convoluted asinine registration system.

I don't think many have a problem making a donation even if it is mandatory, but the system they use for registering the software is so bad it makes the WGA from Microsoft look quite workable.

I can't even comment on the software itself because I have never been willing to put up with the registration system. Fairmount + DTOX + Handbrake can handle every disk I've tried to watch on my AppleTV.
 
Handbrake gives you a choice of encoders, and quicktime is one of them.
No, there is no "quicktime" encoder. Quicktime is a movie player. .mov is a container that is native to QuickTime and is not available within HB since its not open source. However note that almost all iTunes and ATV/iPod movies from the iTunes store are .mp4/m4v which *is* not only available in HB but is likely the most developed.
 
No, there is no "quicktime" encoder. Quicktime is a movie player. .mov is a container that is native to QuickTime and is not available within HB since its not open source. However note that almost all iTunes and ATV/iPod movies from the iTunes store are .mp4/m4v which *is* not only available in HB but is likely the most developed.

Actually, Quicktime is a system api for encoding/decoding video files. QuickTime.app is a application that uses this api to let users play and re-encode videos. Apps like iMovie use the API for exporting to a variety of formats.

But, I was wrong too. I just looked at HB, and didnt see the option to use the quicktime api for encoding. Maybe I was thinking of VisualHub, which let you pick the encoder you wanted to use?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.