Actually he sent me a picture of the Blu-ray slip and it definitely listed HD. It turns out there is some glitch when redeeming the movies on Flixster because others had this same problem. I emailed WB and they added the HD version to my account. Took less than a day so I'm pleasantly surprised.Not sure exactly why some redeem as SD. I've only bought 2 flixster glitches but both redeemed in HD.
Thinking the buyer maybe just mistaked it for HD. Most listings I see specify either SD or HD.
I think it's only Warner and Lionsgate movies that have the glitch. Also some tv series.
-Kevin
The odd thing is that now I have doubles of each movie in my UV library. One that is "SD, HD" and one that is just "SD." The OCD part of me is going to delete the SD copies since the HD version already includes SD, but is there any way I can just gift the SD version to a friend?