Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Basic75

macrumors 68020
May 17, 2011
2,099
2,446
Europe
They used to, yes, but it doesn’t look like any newer Precisions have Xeons in them. In fact, it doesn’t seem like Intel is making any mobile Xeons anymore.
Yes, unfortunately. Memory makers can sell their cheap crap to us and we won't even know.
 

Fomalhaut

macrumors 68000
Oct 6, 2020
1,993
1,724
At least those have some, if not all, actual "Pro" features like user upgradable RAM, user upgradable SSD, Kensington lock, ECC memory and/or built-in Ethernet.
I would argue that those are hobbyist or enthusiast features rather than professional ones. Most businesses buy machines with specifications required by the employe’s role and do not permit users to upgrade parts of their work machine, which would be a nightmare for IT support, and might be prohibited by supplier contracts etc.

I have done this in smaller businesses, where I basically took responsibility for maintaining my own machine, but this is not the norm in my experience
 

leman

macrumors Core
Oct 14, 2008
19,518
19,664
Yes, unfortunately. Memory makers can sell their cheap crap to us and we won't even know.

I wouldn’t call fastest and most energy efficient DRAM “cheap crap”. And recent mobile Xeons were just rebranded consumer CPUs anyway. No wonder Intel dropped them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: heretiq

playtech1

macrumors 6502a
Oct 10, 2014
695
889
I would argue that those are hobbyist or enthusiast features rather than professional ones. Most businesses buy machines with specifications required by the employe’s role and do not permit users to upgrade parts of their work machine, which would be a nightmare for IT support, and might be prohibited by supplier contracts etc.

I have done this in smaller businesses, where I basically took responsibility for maintaining my own machine, but this is not the norm in my experience
Different policies for different places, but our IT team did a firmwide RAM upgrade mid-refresh cycle to eke out a bit more performance and to defer the even bigger headache of replacing everyone's machine. In the past we did something similar with a move from HDD to SDD back when we had desktop machines.

More generally I think Apple's lack of RAM and SSD upgradeability (and actively hostile to the latter even when physically possible as in the Mac Studio) should not get a free pass considering on the PC side these things have swung back towards being generally upgradeable in similarly sized and powerful laptops and how stingy Apple's baseline allocation of both are.
 

aeronatis

macrumors regular
Sep 9, 2015
198
152
At least those have some, if not all, actual "Pro" features like user upgradable RAM, user upgradable SSD, Kensington lock, ECC memory and/or built-in Ethernet.

One can call those "Pro" features, while I would call the list below "Pro":

- CPU powerful enough to compete with H series Intel and AMD chips with a max consumption of 35 watts,
- GPU powerful enough to compete with RTX 4070 laptop with a max consumption of 50 watts,
- Up to 128 GB unified memory for both CPU and GPU,
- Max performance being consistent whether it is plugged in or not,
- 120 Hz variable refresh rate screen with HDR 1600 knits support,
- Being able to connect 3 x 6K 60 Hz + 1 x 4K 120 Hz external screen simultaneously,
- Being able to complete an entire video project lasting for 7-8 hours on battery,
- Not ramping up the fan speed to make long work sessions comfortable,
- High-impedance headphone output
 

diamond.g

macrumors G4
Mar 20, 2007
11,437
2,659
OBX
  • Like
Reactions: Adult80HD

aeronatis

macrumors regular
Sep 9, 2015
198
152
Seems similar to the scores in the 16 if it’s the 14. Did the M2 Max have roughly the same scores in the 14” and 16” pros earlier this year?

Yes, their scores are similar on the CPU side with M1 Max and M2 Max. The performance difference are on the graphics performance.

Only when you try to load both CPU and GPU at the same time, you can see CPU performance difference.
 

Basic75

macrumors 68020
May 17, 2011
2,099
2,446
Europe
One can call those "Pro" features, while I would call the list below "Pro":

- CPU powerful enough to compete with H series Intel and AMD chips with a max consumption of 35 watts,
- GPU powerful enough to compete with RTX 4070 laptop with a max consumption of 50 watts,
- Up to 128 GB unified memory for both CPU and GPU,
- Max performance being consistent whether it is plugged in or not,
- 120 Hz variable refresh rate screen with HDR 1600 knits support,
- Being able to connect 3 x 6K 60 Hz + 1 x 4K 120 Hz external screen simultaneously,
- Being able to complete an entire video project lasting for 7-8 hours on battery,
- Not ramping up the fan speed to make long work sessions comfortable,
- High-impedance headphone output
Yeah, I was surprised how few "Pro" PC laptops go up to 128GB of RAM.
 

Basic75

macrumors 68020
May 17, 2011
2,099
2,446
Europe
I wouldn’t call fastest and most energy efficient DRAM “cheap crap”. And recent mobile Xeons were just rebranded consumer CPUs anyway. No wonder Intel dropped them.
It's like with SSDs, the industry is chasing fast and cheap, with just good enough, probably-slash-hopefully?, quality.
 

Basic75

macrumors 68020
May 17, 2011
2,099
2,446
Europe
I would argue that those are hobbyist or enthusiast features rather than professional ones. Most businesses buy machines with specifications required by the employe’s role and do not permit users to upgrade parts of their work machine, which would be a nightmare for IT support, and might be prohibited by supplier contracts etc.

I have done this in smaller businesses, where I basically took responsibility for maintaining my own machine, but this is not the norm in my experience
There are many different kinds of "Pro" users, if you're thinking of, say, large scale enterprise deployments then yes, nobody is ever going to upgrade a machine.
 

Basic75

macrumors 68020
May 17, 2011
2,099
2,446
Europe
They don’t have ECC memory. As to the rest, performance and ergonomy is much more important to me than the ability to upgrade RAM. Why would I ever buy a slower and objectively crappier computer just because the RAM can be upgraded?
If Apple would support CAMM we could get the best of both worlds (upgradable RAM in a good computer), but of course that's never going to happen. And we've been through the ECC discussion, and why it should be ubiquitous from the Watch to the Mac Pro.
 

Basic75

macrumors 68020
May 17, 2011
2,099
2,446
Europe
I would argue that those are hobbyist or enthusiast features rather than professional ones.
Ethernet is definitely (also) a professional feature, you don't want 10s or 100s of laptops all using WiFi next to each other in one office.
 

altaic

macrumors 6502a
Jan 26, 2004
711
484
Are the 2 versions of the M3 Max based on binning of a single M3 die product?
Unlikely— the M3 Max SoCs apparently have different CPIDs (6031 and 6034). Likewise, the M3 Pro only has one CPID (6030) and is binned. I’d very much like to see a die shot of the 6034 M3 Max-lite…
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chuckeee

Pressure

macrumors 603
May 30, 2006
5,178
1,544
Denmark
Just wondering if this is the 16 core cpu m3 max in the 14 inch pro.

14” MacBook Pro M3 Max 16 Core CPU and 40 GPU Geekbench?

Mac15,8
3208
Single-Core Score
21274
Multi-Core Score

Seems similar to the scores in the 16 if it’s the 14. Did the M2 Max have roughly the same scores in the 14” and 16” pros earlier this year?
Mac15,8 is the MacBook Pro (14-inch) M3 Max with all CPU/GPU cores enabled and 400GB/s memory bandwidth.
 

Pressure

macrumors 603
May 30, 2006
5,178
1,544
Denmark
Unlikely— the M3 Max SoCs apparently have different CPIDs (6031 and 6034). Likewise, the M3 Pro only has one CPID (6030) and is binned. I’d very much like to see a die shot of the 6034 M3 Max-lite…
It's the same chip just with a memory channel unoccupied on the interposer. Probably due to yields of the TSMC N3B fabric node.
 
  • Like
Reactions: komuh and Chuckeee
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.