Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MattG

macrumors 68040
May 27, 2003
3,869
568
Asheville, NC
This is a good one. I've been wondering though, I had so many problems with XP on my old Dell, so if that was so bad for me I can't even imagine how bad Vista must be. (My logic being XP is said to be relatively good and Vista is relatively widely accepted as not yet up-to-par.)

It really can't even be explained...you just have to try it to see how bad it is. I use XP on a daily basis, and in relative terms it's not so bad. It works, it really doesn't crash much, with all the latest patches and fixes it runs relatively solidly. Vista on the other hand is just a complete trainwreck. Every time I use it makes me feel like most people probably do the first time they use a computer, where you just can't find your way around anything and feel confused in general. It's actually kind of embarrassing for me when I go to help someone with a Vista machine, and I look like I don't know what I'm doing, because some things are just hidden so deep within the OS that it takes forever to find them. It's so bloated and over-complicated; to me a good application is one that minimizes the number of clicks to get to something, and Vista does just the opposite.
 

thejadedmonkey

macrumors G3
May 28, 2005
9,240
3,499
Pennsylvania
Sadly, we've had more stability issues with Tiger than Vista within our organization. While the problems in vista seem to be more driver availability and some incompatabilities with older software, with Tiger, we've had all kinds of weird issues with finder content not refreshing, printing not working at all (to any printer) until reboot..etc. Just weird things that seem silly in this day and age.

We even had two machines side by side looking at the computers on the network and one would see machine called "X" lets say and the other would not show it in the list. No matter what we did it wouldnt show. Even upon reboot it failed to show. Very weird. Both were running 10.4.x at the time. It was a 2K3 server that failed to show but other 2k3 servers we had still were there.

Anyway from my experience in our environment where we have 100+ XP stations, 10-15 Vista stations and 20 OSX stations (10.4) I can honestly say that Apple is grasping at straws with the ads. You may not like the UI but all the talk about stability and viruses and all that being a major issue is a farse. In the 4 years of being at the company, I have yet to see 1 comprimised computer (Virus, Trojan or Malware). All the ads are doing is annoying the people who are computer literate enough to use both platforms and the ones that fine them believable are the inexperienced and gullable. Thats my take on things. Even speaking to the hard core designers who have used both platforms, they find the ads unprofessional.

If you've ever seen a really small cocky guy being all loud mouth and pushy even towards the big guy... Well you know where I might be going with this. I believe in speak softly and carry a big stick. The ads IMO show apple as the 'little' guy who makes a lot of noise. One day he's gonna get hit. LOL.

Really, with MS office being such an important software for a lot of people, all MS would have to do is stop development of that product on the apple platform and it would do major damage. Not sure if anyone else feels this way but I think its retarded to poke the sleeping bull with a big stick....

Tiger was a train-wreck of an OS. Tiger on my friends G4 is always running slower then slow, and Tiger on my MBP was always crashing. Upgrade to Leopard, it's way better.
 

thingamajigidid

macrumors member
Nov 9, 2007
67
0
luv it..

luv it, but with the recent post of the imei on the iphone, i fear big brother might be doing the same thing on the macs.... or r they doing so right now..

*runs and hides*
 

x86isslow

macrumors 6502a
Aug 10, 2003
889
11
USA
Tiger was a train-wreck of an OS. Tiger on my friends G4 is always running slower then slow, and Tiger on my MBP was always crashing. Upgrade to Leopard, it's way better.

Leopard, definitely way better, but man it has some teething problems too. Granted, most of that had to do with not releasing GM-build Leopard to developers until retail release.


Unsanity, hurry up… me hates me some uglydock and menubar.
 

stevearm

macrumors 6502a
Nov 15, 2007
992
91
Not only is this ad another funny mock of Windows, I think it will actually be quite effective.

It's funny everyone is praising this ad and how clever it is, when the majority of people on here didn't even spot the banner at the top of the screen.
 

michaelsviews

macrumors 65816
Sep 25, 2007
1,494
477
New England
This has to be one of the best ad's going. at least IHMO, as for PCMAG and John Dvorass and his trivial opinions . Apple the way to go and I went over a year ago. Never looked back once, and will NEVER EVER load winblows on any MAC I own.

One thing I noticed about the PC Ragazine years ago was who ever PAID the most for advertising got the best ratings and reviews. Just MY Opinion and thats that

As for the ones out there feeling insecure about an IMEI number and are reading in between the lines , oh well , get over it. VZW and AT&T have both sub come to the government so if your doing something illegal well sooner or later your going to be caught but more than likely the IMEI thing is nothing more than tracing/tracking what devices are out there and where are they?
 

happydude

macrumors 65816
Sep 2, 2006
1,199
806
a gasping dying planet
true

I doubt it'll make the 95+% of people in the world who are happy with their PC's switch however.

when i say its the "best ad out there" or whatever i said, i'm going with how clever it was to have to dual banner thing going, the humor and the general idea. as far as reaching switchers . . . obviously getting the other 95% to swtich is never going to happen, but just getting people to enter the site, browse around and keep the possibility of buying a mac in the future is definitely there. maybe they'll get an ipod while they are there too. regardless of marketing, i still give this ad a 11 out of 10 just because it's clever and funny and breaks the mold.
 

Jetson

macrumors 6502a
Oct 5, 2003
617
112
The ironic part is, if I load it in Safari it crashes my browser. Way to go Apple.:mad:
Apple really needs to get it's act together.

Safari bugs and other things people have pointed out show that Apple isn't perfect by any means, so these ads poking fun at Windows stretch credibility to say the least.

It's like the left hand doesn't know what the right hand is doing.

Still, the ads ARE working, judging by the growing number of Mac customers, so I don't blame Apple for continuing this frequently humorous ad campaign.
 

AtHomeBoy_2000

macrumors 6502a
Feb 3, 2005
879
0

billystlyes

macrumors 6502a
Jul 5, 2004
569
6
I rolled back to Tiger! I hate to say it, but Vista is more stable than Leopard. Leopard is very buggy.
 

msharp

macrumors regular
Jul 10, 2004
212
9
This is Brilliant!

That made me laugh! (Although I didn't get it for the first time).

I think this is gonna cost Apple some money for nothing because everyone of us who already is a Mac owner needs to watch that twice (at least).

:D
 

AeronPrometheus

macrumors newbie
Mar 24, 2006
22
0
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Apple deserves an award for creative advertisement for this. No other company has made me look forward to the next commercial or avalanche ad.

The ironic part is, if I load it in Safari it crashes my browser. Way to go Apple.:mad:

It's you, reinstall Safari.

edit: Ok, I just successfully played the ad on the Safari 3 beta... on Windows... Vista... x64. And it played just fine. It's definitely you.
 

Steve Works

macrumors newbie
Oct 24, 2007
26
0
ok it was rather funny....but it's getting a bit dull these ads...always the same thing... ok we know microsoft sucks...
but leopard sucks as well....so you should make a banner saying "please don't give up on leopard...just wait untill there's a real update..."

geez...i'm really tired of these ads...
 

smueboy

macrumors 6502a
Oct 30, 2006
778
1
Oz
Pretty clever!
[But i'm sure i would have ignored it (like i do all ads on webpages) if it wasn't posted here.]
 

whistlerpro

macrumors newbie
Jan 9, 2007
13
0
lol, fantastic ad, the problem is though, lots of people who are seeing it are having to force quit their browsers, mac or pc, safari, ie or firefox. Engadget have even posted an article telling people how to block flash. I thought it was a fluke, but it kept happening. Apple may have made a wrong move.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.