Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

onthecouchagain

macrumors 604
Mar 29, 2011
7,382
2
If you guys want to have the Nexus 5, 7 and 10 then go ahead... They may be different devices (tablets, smartphones, etc) but the experience will be identical every time you go from one device to the other... It's redundant.


I thought that was sort of the point, no? To have a more-or-less unified experience.

Much like iOS across the iPhone, iPad Mini, iPad, and even the iPod touch.

No?

EDIT: I see many have pointed this out already...
 

Sensamic

macrumors 68040
Mar 26, 2010
3,072
689
I thought that was sort of the point, no? To have a more-or-less unified experience.

Much like iOS across the iPhone, iPad Mini, iPad, and even the iPod touch.

No?

EDIT: I see many have pointed this out already...

Yeah, I agree with that too, like I've said before.

It's just my personal opinion of course. Everyone has their own. I just would feel like having both the Nexus 7 and 5 in my case would be redundant.

My first post about it was actually referring to my own personal case. I said that after buying my new Nexus 7 I felt no need for the Nexus 5 anymore. I was taking about my personal case.
 

Frankied22

macrumors 68000
Nov 24, 2010
1,789
594
I am not sure if I am buying this new October 15th rumor. That is Tuesday. If they were having an event they would have sent invites out already. I am aware that last year they didn't have an event and it was just a press release, but that was because of Sandy. They had to cancel their event. I don't think Google would want to do that again this year. They probably will want to hold an event.
 

strausd

macrumors 68030
Jul 11, 2008
2,998
1
Texas
I am not sure if I am buying this new October 15th rumor. That is Tuesday. If they were having an event they would have sent invites out already. I am aware that last year they didn't have an event and it was just a press release, but that was because of Sandy. They had to cancel their event. I don't think Google would want to do that again this year. They probably will want to hold an event.

I'm not buying into it either. Artem Russakovskii from Android Police has been posting some interesting rumors he has heard on his G+ page. He hasn't been posting them on Android Police because of his confidence level on these rumors, but he obviously feels some level of confidence to post on G+.

If he had felt more confident about the October 15th date, he probably would have posted that on his G+ page or Android Police. So at this point, it seems he is more confident about an October 31st announcement.
 

atticus27

macrumors regular
Feb 2, 2009
200
0
Pittsburgh, PA
definitely gonna pick one up. I was gonna get a 5S, but even with an at&t early upgrade fee of $450 I'd still have to sign another 2 year contract, so this'll be cheaper for me.
I love my s3 the only thing I hate is waiting for updates (I'm still on 4.1) which I won't have to worry about on the nexus 5
 

boateng

macrumors 6502
Sep 8, 2012
440
10
definitely gonna pick one up. I was gonna get a 5S, but even with an at&t early upgrade fee of $450 I'd still have to sign another 2 year contract, so this'll be cheaper for me.
I love my s3 the only thing I hate is waiting for updates (I'm still on 4.1) which I won't have to worry about on the nexus 5

is it better to get the nexus on contract?
 

Stooby Mcdoobie

macrumors 6502a
Jun 26, 2012
834
45
is it better to get the nexus on contract?

If you're on post-paid and your carrier subsidizes it, sure. But, to manage expectations, T-Mobile was the only US carrier to offer the Nexus 4. One of the selling points of the Nexus line is that it's SIM unlocked at a cheaper price than the big name flagships.
 

boateng

macrumors 6502
Sep 8, 2012
440
10
If you're on post-paid and your carrier subsidizes it, sure. But, to manage expectations, T-Mobile was the only US carrier to offer the Nexus 4. One of the selling points of the Nexus line is that it's SIM unlocked at a cheaper price than the big name flagships.

i am from the uk....

nearly all the major networks in england do the nexus...but most say its better to buy the phone and go on a ''sim only'' plan
 

Stooby Mcdoobie

macrumors 6502a
Jun 26, 2012
834
45
i am from the uk....

nearly all the major networks in england do the nexus...but most say its better to buy the phone and go on a ''sim only'' plan

It really depends on your monthly plan/carrier. Many like the freedom to be able to jump from carrier to carrier, or to use when traveling abroad, which an unlocked phone would allow. Difference would be negligible to me as I'm on a family plan with 4 lines, so I'd probably go with the subsidized option if it was available on my carrier.
 

sentinelsx

macrumors 68010
Feb 28, 2011
2,004
0
is the nexus gonna be better than the htc one? is it worth waiting for?

Are HTC features more important or is an updated android as soon as Google updates it more important?

All a nexus needs is a proper camera and for my use case, all OEM skinned devices are useless. I already enjoy the Google play ROM on my s4 with none of the s-jizz and updates just a tad slower than pure nexus, but I hate the screen so I hope I can swap it for a nexus 5 in future.
 

boateng

macrumors 6502
Sep 8, 2012
440
10
Are HTC features more important or is an updated android as soon as Google updates it more important?

All a nexus needs is a proper camera and for my use case, all OEM skinned devices are useless. I already enjoy the Google play ROM on my s4 with none of the s-jizz and updates just a tad slower than pure nexus, but I hate the screen so I hope I can swap it for a nexus 5 in future.

tbh that made no sense to me lol! I havent owned an android phone and currently have an iphone 4s...
I am due an upgrade from now and have decided maybe to go android as the new iphone is just too expensive for a student like myself...:(:mad:

I was thinking of getting the htc one...but people are saying wait for the nexus. This phone has to last me two years so i want to get the best phone I can. What concerns me is the fact people say android phones start to lag after a while and also iphones tend to hold value more imo...

----------

It really depends on your monthly plan/carrier. Many like the freedom to be able to jump from carrier to carrier, or to use when traveling abroad, which an unlocked phone would allow. Difference would be negligible to me as I'm on a family plan with 4 lines, so I'd probably go with the subsidized option if it was available on my carrier.

Yeah i guess so...

Dont really want to have to pay £300 in one go for a phone tbh

The problem I have is that i have a huge itunes collections with thousands of songs from the itunes store....

Whilst the nexus 5 is a great phone...it isn't suited to be used a main music player compared to the iphone and even htc one because the sound quality will not be as good as those two devices....

If i get the nexus i will have to buy a separate ipod i think
 

Nermal

Moderator
Staff member
Dec 7, 2002
21,023
4,609
New Zealand
If he had felt more confident about the October 15th date, he probably would have posted that on his G+ page or Android Police. So at this point, it seems he is more confident about an October 31st announcement.

Personally I'll be happy if it's available to order by the second week of November; I'm heading to the US soon and will finally be able to access the geoblocked Devices section in Play.

Of course, it'll be better if NZ is supported officially this time around; we got Music earlier this year and Books a few weeks ago, so hopefully Devices will be added alongside the N5 :)

So long, 4S, we hardly knew thee... :p
 

THE JUICEMAN

macrumors 68020
Oct 3, 2007
2,371
1,122
As long as the camera improves, I actually prefer LG over moto or Samsung for the nexus.

That way I know it won't be yet another android phone with that AMOLED screen that I despise. There is already a line of such devices from multiple manufacturers, a solid LCD offering wouldn't hurt too.

This!^^^^^^^^^^^^
 

iEnvy

macrumors 65816
Jun 25, 2010
1,224
336
DFW
I hope this phone is announced soon, I'm getting impatient.

Might as well just keep using my i5. :(
 

whoknows87

macrumors 6502a
Aug 8, 2012
676
31
S.Florida
I hope this phone is announced soon, I'm getting impatient.

Might as well just keep using my i5. :(

read somewhere that it might be sometimes in Nov :confused::confused: and that the Oct 14th is just a device submission date, something along those lines

I'm tired of using my perfectly fine Nexus 4, just itching for a new device lol
5S :confused: G2 :D
 

iEnvy

macrumors 65816
Jun 25, 2010
1,224
336
DFW
read somewhere that it might be sometimes in Nov :confused::confused: and that the Oct 14th is just a device submission date, something along those lines

I'm tired of using my perfectly fine Nexus 4, just itching for a new device lol
5S :confused: G2 :D

I don't see why Google would release a product near the holiday rush knowing they won't be able to match demand, (I already know it's going to be like the Nexus 4 considering they just submitted the phone to the FCC about a month ago). I might as well not consider the Nexus 5 because there are other things to buy.
Good luck to the rest of you.
 

Dave.UK

macrumors 65816
Sep 24, 2012
1,290
482
Kent, UK
tbh that made no sense to me lol! I havent owned an android phone and currently have an iphone 4s...
I am due an upgrade from now and have decided maybe to go android as the new iphone is just too expensive for a student like myself...:(:mad:

I was thinking of getting the htc one...but people are saying wait for the nexus. This phone has to last me two years so i want to get the best phone I can. What concerns me is the fact people say android phones start to lag after a while and also iphones tend to hold value more imo...

----------



Yeah i guess so...

Dont really want to have to pay £300 in one go for a phone tbh

The problem I have is that i have a huge itunes collections with thousands of songs from the itunes store....

Whilst the nexus 5 is a great phone...it isn't suited to be used a main music player compared to the iphone and even htc one because the sound quality will not be as good as those two devices....

If i get the nexus i will have to buy a separate ipod i think



I don't use itunes, but apparently theres a variety of ways to access your collection, main one being through Google Music.

How do you know the sound quality wont be as good, the phone hasn't even been announced yet!

As for the lag, this is something I haven't experienced and ive had a variety of android devices. I suppose its what you do with it. Search for iphone lag on this forum and you will see ios has exactly the same issue.

As for resale value, my partner has the Samsung Galaxy Nexus. She paid £250 for it new and its currently worth £90. So its roughly cost her £1.50 per week and with that she has had all the latest Android updates. I really wouldnt worry about resale value. Why buy I phone worrying about how much it will be worth in 2 years time.

Latest doesn't always mean greatest. If music is very important to you, then look for a phone that specialises in music - Go for the the HTC One.
 

hotleadsingergu

macrumors newbie
Oct 2, 2013
2
0
The problem I have is that i have a huge itunes collections with thousands of songs from the itunes store....

Whilst the nexus 5 is a great phone...it isn't suited to be used a main music player compared to the iphone and even htc one because the sound quality will not be as good as those two devices....

If i get the nexus i will have to buy a separate ipod i think

I have multiple of each device, and I can say there's no issue with using iTunes content on Android phones. Google Music automatically uploads everything to the cloud and it can all be used on Android devices. I have in the neighborhood of 32,000 songs in my iTunes library, and I can pull every single one up on my Galaxy S4 right now and listen to them. I can do the same on my iPhone or iPad. Google Music makes it easy to bring it all together.

And it's definitely just as suited to be a music player. With the later iterations of Google Music on the devices, the application works perfectly. It works well enough that Apple copied pretty much the entire look of it on their iOS7 Music app (sitting them side-by-side they look almost identical). It works great.

And the sound quality is definitely not an issue...the HTC One is the best-bet right now if you want to play music from the speakers (not using headphones), since the speakers are *loud* and pretty solid...otherwise the output sound is the same from all of these devices.
 

Lava Lamp Freak

macrumors 68000
Jun 1, 2006
1,572
624
Last edited:

strausd

macrumors 68030
Jul 11, 2008
2,998
1
Texas
I have multiple of each device, and I can say there's no issue with using iTunes content on Android phones. Google Music automatically uploads everything to the cloud and it can all be used on Android devices. I have in the neighborhood of 32,000 songs in my iTunes library, and I can pull every single one up on my Galaxy S4 right now and listen to them. I can do the same on my iPhone or iPad. Google Music makes it easy to bring it all together.

Google music does an awful job on keeping playlist updated.

If I make a new playlist in iTunes with songs that have already been uploaded to Google music, it normally won't show up. And in the rare case it does show up, the songs in the playlist aren't the same.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.