Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Notch versus Pill+Hole


  • Total voters
    185
What if the bezel was uniform like the iPad lineup?

View attachment 2037101
Now this is actually iconic. If their was some other game changing thing/feature Apple had that literally blew other smartphone makers out of the water and made up for this design? Maybe like some 3D Hologram thing? Then I would buy this. If you’ve ever seen a 3D photograph it is kinda game changing.
 
What if the bezel was uniform like the iPad lineup?

View attachment 2037101
Except for the notch, that's a black XR. 😀

35204a2c05918c82ad43336f88dfb9de.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lioness~
Now this is actually iconic. If their was some other game changing thing/feature Apple had that literally blew other smartphone makers out of the water and made up for this design? Maybe like some 3D Hologram thing? Then I would buy this. If you’ve ever seen a 3D photograph it is kinda game changing.
I absolutely love stereoscopic 3D. But the technology isn't quite there yet for the polish that Apple likes to offer. I still have my pink 3DS.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Bobcat32
Notch versus Pill+Hole

iPhone-14-Pro-rumored-to-replace-notch-with-dual-pill-and-hole-cutouts.jpg
I never really minded the notch. It doesn't take up any significant real estate and it doesn't draw attention to itself like the Pill+Hole design probably will. Most of what I use my iPhone for is texting, watching videos, and playing app games. Maybe scrolling Google News. But the notch never ONCE got in my way or distracted me.
 
I absolutely love stereoscopic 3D. But the technology isn't quite there yet for the polish that Apple likes to offer. I still have my pink 3DS.
No way! I Love 3DS! Too bad that era is over. And right? Increase that stereoscopic ppi up and couple that with all those cameras we have on the back our phones? Not that .3 mp nintendo got? And Instant seller. In no way a gimmick
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yr Blues
In the future we will all look back on this time of notches and holes as crappy and primitive.

And once notch/hole-free iPhone/MacBook designs come out, all our tech will become junk overnight.
I think the leap won't be that quick. We like our separation from technology. Watches and glasses are as far as most will go. Some will go further, but not the majority.
 
I would enjoy a hole punch design in the corner. In the centre it’s just as obtrusive as the notch so what is gained by it? Stick with the notch until they can get rid of it entirely imo.
NO!
It HAS TO BE SYMMETRICAL!
:p
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: har9020
The screen looks more uniform with the pill and hole punch than the notch. The main issue with it is the fact it's lower into the screen and might cut off videos more etc.
 
Might as well make it one big capsule. The tiny gap between the pill and punch hole doesn’t really gain anything. But I think the bigger issue is with the ongoing pandemic, maybe it’s time they add Touch ID to the power button. I am sick of having take my mask off or having to enter my passcode. And no, the Apple Watch unlock only chooses to work when it wants to.
Haven't you heard? As of a recent iOS 15 update the iPhone 12 and later Face ID is already compatible with masks.
 
Among the two options, I’m for the pill. It looks bad, but not horrible. I still prefer bezels and won’t buy a phone with a notch or a pill/hole. Bezels add structural integrity, like a frame on a photo. They also make the phone easier to hold.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yr Blues
Our eyes are adapted to psychologically fill in holes like the pill/hole because our eyes have a blind spot naturally and our brains are always doing this below the level of conscious awareness.

In actual use the pill will be a huge psychological improvement because there’s content all around the area for our brain to fill it in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1557750
i actually think the pill+hole have a modern look to them, while the notch has a very conservative look to it. Not horrible, and still classy, but old.
In use i don't notice it too much though (other than having to swipe down for the battery percentage)
 
i actually think the pill+hole have a modern look to them, while the notch has a very conservative look to it. Not horrible, and still classy, but old.
In use i don't notice it too much though (other than having to swipe down for the battery percentage)
It's asymmetrical, just like the MacBook Keyboard. 😩
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.