Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

jaduff46

macrumors 6502
Mar 3, 2010
328
187
Second star on the right....


Spring Crop
by Hugh Russell, on Flickr

Sony A7, RMC Tokina 17mm @ f/8

Cheers :)

Hugh
That sir is beautiful! Really nice details in the sky. Lovely... I am l liking ultra wide angle right now.

Only thing on this would be maybe a lower angle and get some foreground detail to give it depth.

Not sure I agree, but you're a demi-god and much more experienced photographer than I.

My take is that the beauty of the photograph lies in the multiple layers of clouds, the clarity of them in the distance and the shadows on the undersides, and less in the orderly rows of crops in the foreground, although they're a nice contrast.

What am i missing? Thanks
 
  • Like
Reactions: kenoh

MacRy

macrumors 601
Apr 2, 2004
4,351
6,278
England
Not sure I agree, but you're a demi-god and much more experienced photographer than I.

My take is that the beauty of the photograph lies in the multiple layers of clouds, the clarity of them in the distance and the shadows on the undersides, and less in the orderly rows of crops in the foreground, although they're a nice contrast.

What am i missing? Thanks
When photographing scenes like this the rule of thirds usually comes into play to ensure that there is balance in the scene and also that it isn't comprised of fifty percent sky and land. This particular shot doesn't adhere to the rule (it doesn't have to - it's only a guideline) and it makes the land feel a little claustrophobic and cropped in my opinion.

Still a lovely shot though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jaduff46 and kenoh

kenoh

macrumors 604
Jul 18, 2008
6,507
10,850
Glasgow, UK
Not sure I agree, but you're a demi-god and much more experienced photographer than I.

My take is that the beauty of the photograph lies in the multiple layers of clouds, the clarity of them in the distance and the shadows on the undersides, and less in the orderly rows of crops in the foreground, although they're a nice contrast.

What am i missing? Thanks

Lol demi-god is a weird title given to people who subscribe. You can see my pictures in here, the title is most definitely NOT a reference to my skill level. Lol.

All I am doing is giving subjective feedback. You not agreeing is a good thing. We all see images differently and everyone has preferences. I am merely showing mine. I like the orderly rows on the field and would maybe like to have that more prominent in the image.

I like what you are saying, it has made me look at the image differently.

Thing is there is a myriad of angles, compositions, treatments, all of which can change this already compelling image.

Cool...
 

Hughmac

macrumors 603
Original poster
Feb 4, 2012
6,001
32,567
Kent, UK
Not sure I agree, but you're a demi-god and much more experienced photographer than I.

My take is that the beauty of the photograph lies in the multiple layers of clouds, the clarity of them in the distance and the shadows on the undersides, and less in the orderly rows of crops in the foreground, although they're a nice contrast.

What am i missing? Thanks

When photographing scenes like this the rule of thirds usually comes into play to ensure that there is balance in the scene and also that it isn't comprised of fifty percent sky and land. This particular shot doesn't adhere to the rule (it doesn't have to - it's only a guideline) and it makes the land feel a little claustrophobic and cropped in my opinion.

Still a lovely shot though.

Lol demi-god is a weird title given to people who subscribe. You can see my pictures in here, the title is most definitely NOT a reference to my skill level. Lol.

All I am doing is giving subjective feedback. You not agreeing is a good thing. We all see images differently and everyone has preferences. I am merely showing mine. I like the orderly rows on the field and would maybe like to have that more prominent in the image.

I like what you are saying, it has made me look at the image differently.

Thing is there is a myriad of angles, compositions, treatments, all of which can change this already compelling image.

Cool...

Well... to be honest, I took a few shots of this location. I tried standing up, crouching down, moving backwards or forwards, and this in my opinion was the best of the bunch. Mainly because I was showcasing the sky, and the green part actually became the edge of the field and a road had I gone backwards any more.
It's nice of you all to comment and discuss this photo; it makes me think more about what I'm doing - thanks :)
I will be going back in a couple of weeks when the daffodils are in full bloom, and I expect the angle of view to change again.

By the way, the term 'demi-god' refers to people who support this forum through subscriptions, not to mean any particular experience in photography. I only picked up a DSLR and started trying to learn seriously 3 years ago, so I'm still very much in my infancy.

Cheers :)

Hugh
 
Last edited:

stillcrazyman

macrumors 603
Oct 10, 2014
5,652
65,073
Exile
The boathouse.
This is an older photo I had never shared before, until I ran it through Luminar. Processing it with some effects, but just a little.

DSC06697-X2.jpg
 

Hughmac

macrumors 603
Original poster
Feb 4, 2012
6,001
32,567
Kent, UK
Well... to be honest, I took a few shots of this location. I tried standing up, crouching down, moving backwards or forwards, and this in my opinion was the best of the bunch. Mainly because I was showcasing the sky, and the green part actually became the edge of the field and a road had I gone backwards any more.
It's nice of you all to comment and discuss this photo; it makes me think more about what I'm doing - thanks :)
I will be going back in a couple of weeks when the daffodils are in full bloom, and I expect the angle of view to change again.

By the way, the term 'demi-god' refers to people who support this forum through subscriptions, not to mean any particular experience in photography. I only picked up a DSLR and started trying to learn seriously 3 years ago, so I'm still very much in my infancy.

Cheers :)

Hugh
As an aside, and looking back, I think I've been mostly using the rule of fifths rather than thirds in my landscapes, although the photo in question seems more like a rule of sevenths ;)

There are no rules if it looks right as it is, however a 7th is maybe a tad shallow in this case.

Cheers :)

Hugh
 

jaduff46

macrumors 6502
Mar 3, 2010
328
187
Second star on the right....
As an aside, and looking back, I think I've been mostly using the rule of fifths rather than thirds in my landscapes, although the photo in question seems more like a rule of sevenths ;)

There are no rules if it looks right as it is, however a 7th is maybe a tad shallow in this case.

Cheers :)

Hugh
I thought about the rule of thirds when I first replied to @kenoh, but thought that 1/3 of crops would have taken away from the gorgeous sky. Agree with your point on say 1/5 being not quite as shallow.

Thanks for the feedback and guidance from all!

John
[doublepost=1487607484][/doublepost]Love the pictures of Sam! We had a Lab/Setter rescue as a first dog who lived to 16 1/2. Sweet mellow girl in good health who passed away in her sleep.

Latest family member is another rescue. Lab and supposedly Sharpei but seems to have some Pitt Bullin the face. She'll be 9 next month. View attachment 689400 View attachment 689400 View attachment 689400
IMG_0089.JPG
 

kenoh

macrumors 604
Jul 18, 2008
6,507
10,850
Glasgow, UK
I thought about the rule of thirds when I first replied to @kenoh, but thought that 1/3 of crops would have taken away from the gorgeous sky. Agree with your point on say 1/5 being not quite as shallow.

Thanks for the feedback and guidance from all!

John
[doublepost=1487607484][/doublepost]Love the pictures of Sam! We had a Lab/Setter rescue as a first dog who lived to 16 1/2. Sweet mellow girl in good health who passed away in her sleep.

Latest family member is another rescue. Lab and supposedly Sharpei but seems to have some Pitt Bullin the face. She'll be 9 next month. View attachment 689400 View attachment 689400 View attachment 689400 View attachment 689401

Excellent! rescues before pedigrees. Give them a chance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hughmac

Hughmac

macrumors 603
Original poster
Feb 4, 2012
6,001
32,567
Kent, UK
Yep, ours is a dalmatian / labrador cross (rescue, although we know his history and he wasn't ill treated). They're generally more robust than highly inbred pedigrees, and the few times we've seen a vet it's usually from some sort of reckless act on his part rather than illness.

Cheers :)

Hugh
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MacRy and kenoh

Doylem

macrumors 68040
Dec 30, 2006
3,858
3,642
Wherever I hang my hat...
Beautiful. How long did you wait for the train?

I had a timetable, so could work out when the train would arrive... giving me a few minutes to 'set up'. I stayed on, hoping to catch the train on the way back, but the light returned to 'gloomy'. But I got chatting to a guy flying a drone, with video camera. Amazing to watch the drone's progress (on his iPad), as he explored the line to the north. If he lost touch with the drone, it was programmed to return to him of its own accord! Neat...
 

Apple fanboy

macrumors Ivy Bridge
Feb 21, 2012
57,003
56,027
Behind the Lens, UK
I had a timetable, so could work out when the train would arrive... giving me a few minutes to 'set up'. I stayed on, hoping to catch the train on the way back, but the light returned to 'gloomy'. But I got chatting to a guy flying a drone, with video camera. Amazing to watch the drone's progress (on his iPad), as he explored the line to the north. If he lost touch with the drone, it was programmed to return to him of its own accord! Neat...
Yes they are clever. Not so good if you're on a Royal Navy Vessel though. When they return to base, they end up crashing into the sea!
 

Apple fanboy

macrumors Ivy Bridge
Feb 21, 2012
57,003
56,027
Behind the Lens, UK
Oh, sorry :oops:

Cheers :)

Hugh
It's okay.It sounds like a joke!

Had a fun day shooting yesterday at Knowsley Safari park with Janet and David of the Wild Arena Events people http://www.wildarena.com/home. They really look after you well if you are looking for something a bit different to shoot. They are photographers as well as animal owners (they look after everything you photograph), so have lots of great tips as well as all the gear.
Crested Gecko
_DSC2241 by apple fanboy1, on Flickr
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.