Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

shanson27

macrumors 68020
Nov 27, 2011
2,226
21,145
7B8AC9A5-9182-4B15-A29A-02BF3739DD65.jpeg
 

mollyc

macrumors G3
Aug 18, 2016
8,065
50,755
View attachment 2008018
(right picture was obtained from Instagram @sanFracisco.history)



🗼On the top is The Goddess of Victory statue atop the Dewey Monument. The monument was erected to honor Admiral George Dewey, a hero of the Spanish-American War, for his victory in the Battle of Manila Bay.

The dedication of the monument was President Roosevelt's last official act before leaving San Francisco. Union Square was - and is - the center of San Francisco's retail district, and is located two blocks north of Market Street. Union Square San Francisco, California. 🗼
i’m not sure we are ready to give up the “must be your own work rule” just yet.
 
i’m not sure we are ready to give up the “must be your own work rule” just yet.
Dang, y’all are not playing.

Understood- The rule states:

*All photos should be your own work (unless special circumstances have been agreed).

The picture to the left-hand side is the one I took personally (my own work). If it does not meet the requirements, please kindly let me know. Will be happy to take it down.

Thank you 😃
 

mollyc

macrumors G3
Aug 18, 2016
8,065
50,755
Dang, y’all are not playing.

Understood- The rule states:

*All photos should be your own work (unless special circumstances have been agreed).

The picture to the left-hand side is the one I took personally (my own work). If it does not meet the requirements, please kindly let me know. Will be happy to take it down.

Thank you ?
I'm not aware that it was agreed that historical photos were allowed in this thread. I'm happy to be corrected if the case is otherwise. Clearly you did not take the photo dated from 1903.

We have an occasional participant who is confined to a wheelchair who often sets up a photo and then has a friend/relative push the button on her phone or camera for her. She is physically unable to take a photo, but tells her companion what she'd like to shoot.

To my knowledge, that is the only special circumstance we've so far allowed.

As with the previous topic, discussion is a fair point, and likes/dislikes to responses will be noted.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Clix Pix
I'm not aware that it was agreed that historical photos were allowed in this thread. I'm happy to be corrected if the case is otherwise. Clearly you did not take the photo dated from 1903.

We have an occasional participant who is confined to a wheelchair who often sets up a photo and then has a friend/relative push the button on her phone or camera for her. She is physically unable to take a photo, but tells her companion what she'd like to shoot.

To my knowledge, that is the only special circumstances we've so far allowed.

As with the previous topic, discussion is a fair point, and likes/dislikes to responses will be noted.
Thank you for your reply and clarification.

I remember I did post a historic photo previously and did a small comparison and did not have any issues. It’s just a fair comparison. I think as long the work contains your own work. It’s a fair call to do a comparison. Otherwise, it wouldn’t make any sense to take another photo of the historic picture from your own camera and then compare it with the original photo.

Please let me know if I’m wrong or need to be corrected. Thanks, again. 🙏🏻
 
  • Love
Reactions: bondr006

MarkC426

macrumors 68040
May 14, 2008
3,693
2,096
UK
View attachment 2008018
(right picture was obtained from Instagram @sanFracisco.history)



🗼On the top is The Goddess of Victory statue atop the Dewey Monument. The monument was erected to honor Admiral George Dewey, a hero of the Spanish-American War, for his victory in the Battle of Manila Bay.

The dedication of the monument was President Roosevelt's last official act before leaving San Francisco. Union Square was - and is - the center of San Francisco's retail district, and is located two blocks north of Market Street. Union Square San Francisco, California. 🗼
Well I never knew there was 1.Union Square, 2.Saks Fifth Avenue in San Fran......😜
Thought it was just New York......I am a Brit so forgive me...😬
 

bondr006

macrumors 68030
Jun 8, 2010
2,903
16,819
Cary, NC - My Name is Rob Bond
Thank you for your reply and clarification.

I remember I did post a historic photo previously and did a small comparison and did not have any issues. It’s just a fair comparison. I think as long the work contains your own work. It’s a fair call to do a comparison. Otherwise, it wouldn’t make any sense to take another photo of the historic picture from your own camera and then compare it with the original photo.

Please let me know if I’m wrong or need to be corrected. Thanks, again. 🙏🏻
I like the back story and the comparison photo. Helps put your photo in perspective. I personally don't see a problem with the historic photo for the purpose you used it for.
 

Steven-iphone

macrumors 68000
Apr 25, 2020
1,953
16,490
United States
I viewed a YouTube video last night featuring a photographer who is in the 8th year of a 10-year project documenting the Lifeboat stations in the U.K.

If you are interested in collodion wet process photography (glass plate), this is worth a visit.


 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.