Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Abstract

macrumors Penryn
Dec 27, 2002
24,889
921
Location Location Location
Thanks for the reply. :) It was really useful.

I haven't been on Sheldon Brown's website since I purchased a hybrid 5 months ago, but I'll definitely look again. And I think my current hybrid has a horizontal dropout. I have a Shimano 8-speed internal gear hub, which usually requires a horizontal drop out to be easily installed, no? I'm currently in Japan, so I can't even check my bike. :rolleyes:


Before I seriously considered building my own single speed last month, I thought I really wanted a road bike. After a few months of owning my hybrid (my first bike in 20 years (I'm 30)), I still love it, but I find that my bike is really heavy (Cromoly frame, 8-speed internal hub, rear rack, chain guard, mud guards, and anything else you can find on a commuter bike ;)), and I also realised that I usually want to ride fast. I see people dressed up in all this cycling clothes, and many of them seem to ride so casually. What's the point of dressing up if you're going to ride slower than a guy wearing a down-filled vest and brown corduroy pants. :p

Anyway, I found 2 types of road bikes, and I think one was for racing, while the other was for longer-distance endurance rides, which seem to be built slightly more for comfort than a true racing road bike. I think I want the frame built for endurance. :) I live in Melbourne now (originally from Toronto!), and I'm not sure how willing bike shops would be of selling me just a frame without all the other components.
 

hmai18

macrumors 6502
Mar 26, 2008
270
0
Buying a frame only and building it up is usually not a cost-effective solution. It's great if you know exactly what you want on it, but you're going to get better value for your money buying a complete bike (unless you've got the knowledge and patience to source everything from eBay etc). If you really want a specific frame with a specific build kit, you'll probably still end up ahead by buying the complete bike and selling the parts off.
 

3lionsbecks

Suspended
Jul 19, 2010
607
119
Ontario, Canada
2007 Cervelo P2C -- Got it for my 1st 70.3 ironman race. Love it so much.
 

Attachments

  • DSCN0598.JPG
    DSCN0598.JPG
    1 MB · Views: 153

GoCubsGo

macrumors Nehalem
Feb 19, 2005
35,742
155
Buying a frame only and building it up is usually not a cost-effective solution. It's great if you know exactly what you want on it, but you're going to get better value for your money buying a complete bike (unless you've got the knowledge and patience to source everything from eBay etc). If you really want a specific frame with a specific build kit, you'll probably still end up ahead by buying the complete bike and selling the parts off.

Sometimes personal trumps cost effective. If I look at my bike I would change a few parts that I believe are personally better. Cost effective, no. I think I may spend a bit more but when it comes to a bike, especially a fixie, I think you have to be comfortable. To me there is no price that can be put on comfort.
 

cleanup

macrumors 68030
Jun 26, 2005
2,643
10
Toronto
Sometimes personal trumps cost effective. If I look at my bike I would change a few parts that I believe are personally better. Cost effective, no. I think I may spend a bit more but when it comes to a bike, especially a fixie, I think you have to be comfortable. To me there is no price that can be put on comfort.

I think what he means is that if you just end up buying parts of comparable quality to build up your frame (as opposed to buying the bike complete, assuming its offered as such), you're going to end up spending more on your own. You're likely better off buying the bike complete the changing then 1 or 2 things that you'd prefer to be different. "Comfort" on a bike comes down to contact points and sizing. If you're buying a bike complete and find that you hate the handlebars, the reach is too long, you hate the straps and the saddle is uncomfortable, then you just bought the wrong bike (for you). It doesn't mean you need to go ahead and build one up from scratch.

However, building a bike is a learning process that teaches you more than buying and riding a bike ever could. And if you're patient, of course, you can still make it cheap. Just have to wait for the good deals to roll by.
 

Xavier

macrumors demi-god
Mar 23, 2006
2,829
1,610
Columbus
However, building a bike is a learning process that teaches you more than buying and riding a bike ever could. And if you're patient, of course, you can still make it cheap. Just have to wait for the good deals to roll by.

Word.

I built up my bike. I really enjoy the process and getting very "hands on." It does feel different when you personally assemble and tune your bike as compared to a prebuilt one.
 

Cliff3

macrumors 68000
Nov 2, 2007
1,556
180
SF Bay Area
As long as I disassembled and cleaned the drivetrain today, I figured I may as well take a new photo of my main ride. Especially since the last photo was almost 10 years old. It's a Waterford 2200 with a steel fork, MY2000 Chorus 10 speed group, Record/Open Pro wheels built by Excel last year, and a mix of other parts. It weighs a bit under 20 pounds without the frame pump and seat bag.
 

Attachments

  • waterford-7573.jpg
    waterford-7573.jpg
    728 KB · Views: 133

comictimes

macrumors 6502a
Jun 20, 2004
874
1
Berkeley, California
My Raleigh Sojourn and I just before Hoosier Pass, Colorado, a little over halfway through my girlfriend and my trans-America tour. It's finally unloaded so I'll get a picture later today.
 

Attachments

  • bike.jpg
    bike.jpg
    1 MB · Views: 135

mtbdudex

macrumors 68030
Aug 28, 2007
2,896
5,265
SE Michigan
How to send $450+ in a blink of an eye

This happened 2 months ago and I posted in my local bike forum.

Q: How to send $450+ in a blink of an eye
A: Forget your $$$ Ti MTB bike is on your roof rack and try to park inside your garage.
$250 lease car deductible, + $100 new bike seat, + $100 for new roof rack cross bars.

Boy am I mad at myself, came home from riding ILRA tonight, wife/kids at Grandmas for the nite, so I figured why not park inside the garage?
Yea, if my bike was not on top no problem......Luckily nothing else on the bike appears damaged besides the seat.

I feared the worst, after hearing the horrible sound it made inside. I sat there 3-4 minutes before going out to look.


The LH bar end crashed into the wood header of the garage, and then the roof rack bars plain sheared at all 4 ends and the whole thing came crashing backward.
Believe it or not, besides the bike seat appears no other bike damage.....
IMG_5760.jpg



See that mark up on the wood? Crash!!! LH Bar end slammed right there.
You can see the roof rack cross bars sheared at each end. Very lucky the bike did not break the back window glass.
The top of the hatchback got dented pretty badly.
IMG_5762.jpg



Big dent in top of hatchback, $250 deductible on company lease vehicle.....ugh....money I'd rather use on family stuff!!
IMG_5763.jpg


The seat broke off its rails upon falling down, I did mini test ride in driveway and front forks appear ok, all shifters/brake levers work, etc. $100 for new bike seat.
IMG_5765.jpg



Yea, I learned my $450 lesson here. We're going on vacation in 2 days for 1 week, so at least I can order a new seat, it'll be here when we are back for me to install.
 

hmai18

macrumors 6502
Mar 26, 2008
270
0
And that right there is why I will always go trunk mounted carrier or just throw the bike in the trunk itself.
 

OllyW

Moderator
Staff member
Oct 11, 2005
17,196
6,800
The Black Country, England
This happened 2 months ago and I posted in my local bike forum.

Q: How to send $450+ in a blink of an eye
A: Forget your $$$ Ti MTB bike is on your roof rack and try to park inside your garage.
$250 lease car deductible, + $100 new bike seat, + $100 for new roof rack cross bars.

My friend owns a bike shop. The car park behind the shops has height restriction barriers.

What happened to you is a regular occurrence, the worst one so far was £10,000 worth of damage to a brand new Audi S4 Avant.

My friend doesn't mind too much because he gets paid to fix the bikes.:)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.