The Turtle Beach headset is my first one ever so I can't compare them to anything else. But, from what I've experienced I don't know how I ever played video games without a headset. They do intensify the gaming experience.
The headset is equipped with two volume controls, one for game sound and the other for speech (speech volume is for how loud you want your friends/teammates to hear you. You can't hear your voice through the headset).
The only negative thing I have about the Turtle Beach headset is the cable that connects to the controller to the amplifier for speech. It seems quite flimsy or too pliable and maybe the cause of people losing the speech function of the headset over time of use. Another negative point, and it really isn't Turtle Beachs fault, is that the headset is always "on" even though the 360 is turned off. Turns out the 360 USB ports have a constant power supply even with the 360 off. No big deal, I just unplug the USB connector.
I was considering the Tritton but the price and needing two adapters to power that beast on scared me away.
i think the price is justified considering the other headset options e.g. Tritton