I had the Griffin Elan Hoster for 2 days and the returned it. I didn't like how high the clip sat on the back - it kept jabbing into my side when I would sit down. Didn't like that the clip wasn't removable either. Waiting patiently for my Orbino now.
I too had the Elan Snap-In holster for a week and it dug into me. I liked rotating the phone 90 degrees landscape with my belt, and even put a felt furniture pad on the back of the clip, but it still dug in. Great case still and it fits securely.
But I have found what I consider to be
THE BEST SOLUTION.
1.
www.bestskinsever.com this skin is $9.99 shipped, tacky/grippy so that the phone is less slippery, and wraps all the chrome too (that is the curved chrome, doesn't cover the tiny flat sliver on the front around the screen). Do yourself a favor and get this, better than the Invisivle Sheild.
2. I don't care for the tackier bestskinsever on the screen, so I continued using my
www.powersupportusa.com Crystal Film Set which is available at Apple stores for $14.95 and keeps the same feel and look to the screen. Really except for the home button and ear speaker holes, you cannot tell it's there.
3. Lastly, the case. Forget the holsters. And once you have the Bestskinsever, you don't need a Speck or Incase rubber anything. Get yourself a
foofpod.
www.foofshop.com These cases are handmade in Australia, price is about $21-24 shipped (after $AUD to $USD conversion) and are excellent. Took about a week to arrive. They have great corduory and Japanese cottons, and Irish tweeds. Slip the iPhone in, top first, speaker out so you can hear it ring, and slide it in your pocket.