So, I did a thing yesterday:
This wasn't a lightly made or whimsical decision. My wife and I own 3 coupes, and with a kiddo planned for a couple years from now, and her Beetle paid off, we figured we want to keep the Beetle as long as possible but we will still need a family hauler. So we figured it might be best to get something sooner than later and get it paid down as far as possible before we have a kid. What we were originally planning to do was do this, but then also get my wife a replacement for the Beetle when the kid arrived (the thinking being that we didn't want to be on the front end of two car loans with a new kid). But with how easy the Tiguan is for my wife to drive, we might not even do that - might just keep the Beetle as long as possible even after having a kid and just switch off who drives what depending on who has the kid, at least until the Tiguan is paid off also. So taking a long term view of future finances here with this decision.
I know there's a new Tiguan on the horizon, I've seen it, and I know it has double the warranty. It's nice, but I'm sure there will be teething issues and it's going to be a lot bigger since we are getting the long wheelbase version only. We like the current Tiguan, as old as it is, for its size. So we decided to pull the trigger on a top of the line SEL for me and I traded in the Mustang which was the best car I've ever owned, bar none.
The Tiguan stickered for $37,660, I got a discount of $5,828, meaning I paid $31,832. 15.5% off, so not too bad in a month with bad rebates. They gave me what I wanted for my 5.0 without any back and forth - $22,000 and I kept my Nokian snow tires since they will fit on the Tiguan as they are the same size (meaty 255s on this thing!), so that's like $1500 more saved there since those tires were expensive as hell and only have 4k miles on them. Since money is cheap I decided to pull out the positive equity in my Mustang, and walked away with a check for north of $5,500 that I can do something else with, which is more than I thought I'd be able to walk away with. Throughout the process Inver Grove VW in MN was great and I encountered zero BS from anyone. Price of the Tiguan was good, trade was what I said I wanted with no arguing, and pulling out positive equity was no problem. One thing that was nice about the dealer was they told me since I had DNR license plates on my Mustang that I could actually transfer them to the new car, which I did not expect to be able to do in MN (standard plates cannot be transferred, I didn't know any plates could be transferred at all and I don't think most people know that either). I had just re-upped registration in February, so that saved $500 or so. Only downside is the car looks used since it has real plates already instead of paper tags and a temp permit in the window, lol. Car drives fantastic.
Likes:
-Handling and chassis response
-Size
-Feature content
-Fit and finish
-Good overall packaging for the interior size
-40/20/40 rear seat
-Fender stereo is fantastic once you really dial it in and head unit is great
-Adaptive headlights are really cool and less gimmicky than I thought
Dislikes:
-No homelink (WTF?) - I was sure that was what the button under the mirror was for but it's just the auto-dimming on/off switch
-Can't do voice commands to navigate my iPod on USB, have to use menus via head unit touchscreen (WTF?)
-Would be nice if the front passenger seat could fold flat like the manual ones can on lower trims but alas, I'll sacrifice that for the 12 way power passenger seat instead
-Spongy gas pedal, will need to get used to
-Halogen fogs/no LED tails
I still have some things that I need to set up like my wife's memory settings as well as getting the passenger side mirror to dip when in reverse, but for the most part I have things set the way I want them. Really happy with it, and while it is old, it really doesn't feel that old once you are inside surrounded by all the creature comforts. It still looks and feels good in the flesh, despite looking old as hell in pictures, particularly the interior.