Got my fully maxed-out 15" 2016 tMBP last night. Updated to 10.12.3 and finished transferring everything over and am now in the process of nuking my 2012 rMBP to a clean Sierra install so the girlfriend can finally get on the MBP bus!
So far, so good, I like the new system. I haven't done anything 'crazy' with it, haven't sniffed it, haven't shaken it, haven't dropped it from any heights...
First impressions are largely positive.
Things I like:
- The CPU is a minimum of 20% faster than my 2012's 2.6 i7, the 460 graphics are a good 55-60% faster than my 2012's 650 GT and the SSD is blazing fast, at least as quick as the older one is, in real world use and significantly quicker when moving large files around. The added 1TB of space on the new unit is going to ensure this machine gives me a good few years' use, my 2012's 960GB SSD was very nearly full.
- The sound from the speakers is amazing for such a thin, light, thing!
- I like the keyboard, it makes my 2012's keys feel spongy and wobbly. (Funny how using something new can make something older feel instantly strange, even though you never thought anything wrong with it until the new system came along!). The slightly clickier sound from this keyboard does not bother me at all.
- The thing feels like it's absolutely solid in terms of build quality. The small changes in overall footprint, thinner bezels, slightly thinner and lighter body, together with the newer space grey colour gives it a very nice, premium 'feel'.
- It runs cool, a fair bit cooler than my 2012 when doing even moderately intense work.
- Touch ID is a nice feature to have.
Things that feel largely the same:
- The screen is nice and sharp and has a higher max brightness and a slightly warmer colour than my 2012's retina screen. Nothing to complain about here. It seems a little less reflective too, which is nice.
- The SSD, while clearly faster, does not 'feel' like it's 4-5x the performance of the older SSDs in the 2012 MBP.
- The touch bar has worked just fine for me so far, no real quibbles with it and no glaring bugs like on-screen touch bar graphics etc
Things I'm not a fan of:
- Battery life has definitely gone down. It currently lasts around as long as my 2012 does, which isn't great, given that it has a brand new battery and the 2012 is coming up on 5 years old. This isn't that big a deal to me, because I don't do heavy CPU or GPU work on the road very often.
- The lack of legacy ports is an annoyance. I've got all the necessary adapters to ensure my work is uninterrupted, but using all these dongles is not ideal.
- Absolutely no way to upgrade anything on this model now. This is Apple's planned obsolescence hitting full steam.
- I've hit the Siri 'button' on the touch bar at least 3 or 4 times already today when trying to hit delete. This is annoying.
- The price is unreasonable, given that you have to fork-out for several accessories in addition to paying the Apple tax for upgrade options.
- No MagSafe with the built-in charge indicator.
Things I'd have liked:
- I'd have been just fine with a 2012-2015 style body, with a larger battery, at least one USB-A port, MagSafe, and an SD-card slot.
- In the absence of the older body style, I feel Apple should have at least included a USB-A to Thunderbolt 3 / USB-C adapter with each unit. As an aside, I got an adapter extension cable with my MBP. I had ordered one, thinking I wouldn't get one with my adapter, so now I have two! Dunno how that happened.
- Haptic feedback on the touch bar would have been nice. I'm sure this is gonna be added along the way over the next few years.
Overall:
All-in-all I'm happy with the thing, having had it for just under 24 hours! Hopefully it will be reliable and the software will continue to improve things like battery life and touch bar utility. Is it perfect? No, it's not, there's room for improvement here and Apple will improve it bit by bit. The battery will get larger, the lack of legacy ports will be less important as time goes on, it will get faster and further improved with things like haptic feedback on the touch bar. I think the long-time fans' concerns will be addressed in subsequent iterations, so if you can wait for the 2017 or 2018 upgrades, that may not be a bad idea.As is, though, it is a very capable, if slightly flawed and definitely pricey, high end device.