It is, which makes me worry about dropping it, which forces me to put an Otterbox Commuter case on it, which makes it heavier still ...
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Other The joy and agony of having a Max sized phone
- Thread starter dragon4ever
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
It is, which makes me worry about dropping it, which forces me to put an Otterbox Commuter case on it, which makes it heavier still ...
I've gone back and forth with plus size phones and just purchased the Pro Max after having the X for almost 2 years. I was definitely apprehensive to get the larger phone but after having it almost a week now it doesn't feel that much larger than the X. In fact I would need to hold the X to remember the size it was ( I traded it in). The Max feels the same size. I don't, however, like the idea that next year will be even larger.
One thing I have learned is that I rarely use a phone with one hand. Even with the 11P if I need to swipe back to a previous screen it takes a ‘shift’ with my hand. My thumb can’t quite get all the way to the left side without shifting my hand/wrist. I never type one-handed.
I love this 11P and I love that it disappears in my pocket. My 11 either lived in my back pocket or had to be put somewhere..front pocket not an option and I don’t wear tight pants. I LOVE the battery life of the 11P. Yesterday (technically today) it was after midnight and I had over 40% remaining. Today, with light use.. off the charger at 7AM and I am at 98%.
What I am not loving is pictures. Pictures I take or get from people.. I find myself zooming to see them as I am used to them being bigger. When I edit I am zooming to see more of what I want to change. Pictures taken in portrait/vertical aspect are fine. It’s the landscape images that are not leveraging the size of the screen. The 11PM does this as well.. but you do get a bigger image. My vision is fine.. just smaller pictures on a smaller phone. Still not in a rush but the 11PM is not out of the question. I need to go back to the store give the 11PM some time.
I love this 11P and I love that it disappears in my pocket. My 11 either lived in my back pocket or had to be put somewhere..front pocket not an option and I don’t wear tight pants. I LOVE the battery life of the 11P. Yesterday (technically today) it was after midnight and I had over 40% remaining. Today, with light use.. off the charger at 7AM and I am at 98%.
What I am not loving is pictures. Pictures I take or get from people.. I find myself zooming to see them as I am used to them being bigger. When I edit I am zooming to see more of what I want to change. Pictures taken in portrait/vertical aspect are fine. It’s the landscape images that are not leveraging the size of the screen. The 11PM does this as well.. but you do get a bigger image. My vision is fine.. just smaller pictures on a smaller phone. Still not in a rush but the 11PM is not out of the question. I need to go back to the store give the 11PM some time.
One handed - I would if I could but it hasn't really worked for me since the 4, possibly the 5/5S. I have big hands (XL gloves) and a lot of manual dexterity (multiple musical instruments). Just doesn't work for me (YMMV), so on that score the Max phones are not different than any other iPhone. I will say that the FaceID UI made it even harder (swipe down), but that applies to the whole range.
I think the max is particularly worse if you’re a woman, since the pants can’t accommodate it (though you do have a purse at times so that helps).
For me it comes down to what devices you own. I have the 12.9” iPad Pro so have no need for the max phone. I can see where people without iPads might want it so that’s that.
I am pretty sure I am switching to the 11PM. I had the XR for a year and loved it. The 11P has blown me away, especially with battery life but the screen just isn’t enough for me. The screen is everything. I keep looking at pictures and thinking how small they are, for me.
One thing that helps with iOS 13 (Apple Store Reps did not know this) is that when you are editing in Photos (and Lightroom) you can zoom the image to the entire screen. This resolves the tiny image to edit in landscape view. It will just be bigger on the 11PM.
One thing I will be investing in is a sheath case. The MAIN time I don’t like having a big phone is when my wife and I are out and I have to put the big honkin’ phone on the table because it won’t fit in my pockets. With a sheath I can just toss it in her purse and not worry about scratching the display.
I tried to go small and the 11P is awesome but I will have to suffer through the agony for the screen real estate I want.
One thing that helps with iOS 13 (Apple Store Reps did not know this) is that when you are editing in Photos (and Lightroom) you can zoom the image to the entire screen. This resolves the tiny image to edit in landscape view. It will just be bigger on the 11PM.
One thing I will be investing in is a sheath case. The MAIN time I don’t like having a big phone is when my wife and I are out and I have to put the big honkin’ phone on the table because it won’t fit in my pockets. With a sheath I can just toss it in her purse and not worry about scratching the display.
I tried to go small and the 11P is awesome but I will have to suffer through the agony for the screen real estate I want.
I am considering doing the same, going to 11Pro Max from 11 Pro.
I’m new to the IUP, how was the process? Did they hit your credit twice? That’s my concern.
Thx!
today i tested both sizes in Bestbuy for like 10minutes.
At first i was leaning towards the Max size because ive used a Plus phone for the past 5 years, so naturally they are the same size. But then because the screen truly stretches from bottom to top unlike the 8+ ive been using it makes a huge diffewrence in usabilty. Whereas i can reach the home button before, and the top of the screen, i cannot do that now. if i want to reach the bottom to close an app i need to adjust my hands. and if i need to reach the top i have to adjust holding it again.
So i went with the smaller size.
At first i was leaning towards the Max size because ive used a Plus phone for the past 5 years, so naturally they are the same size. But then because the screen truly stretches from bottom to top unlike the 8+ ive been using it makes a huge diffewrence in usabilty. Whereas i can reach the home button before, and the top of the screen, i cannot do that now. if i want to reach the bottom to close an app i need to adjust my hands. and if i need to reach the top i have to adjust holding it again.
So i went with the smaller size.
This is the reason I have never considered the MAX size. I was pleased to move from the 7 PLUS to the X and have found that the perfect size for me balancing portability with view-ability. If you are going to carry the phone around in bag, then you might as well carry an iPad instead - and that is what I do if I have any real work while out and about.
To me, it seems that the best solution is to just get the Apple Watch. Most notifications can be handled on the watch, and thus the phone can be inside a bag or whatnot, and its size won't be as debilitating.
I mean, my Max does take up more pocket room but I deal with it 'cos the phone is so much more enjoyable to use than a 'non' Max....
If it's causing that much of an issue or you're finding yourself buying new clothes just to house your phone.... Then you probably shouldn't have a Max sized phone.
Just my opinion.
If it's causing that much of an issue or you're finding yourself buying new clothes just to house your phone.... Then you probably shouldn't have a Max sized phone.
Just my opinion.
100% agree; the phone must fit your lifestyle, not the other way around
Max size is great while using but not pocketable plus I always use a bulky case so I go with the regular size, I can also use it one handed which you can’t really do with a max
One-handed use strategies:
- Enable the one-handed smaller keyboard
- iOS shortcuts on widget screen
- use iEmpty.com to create space at the top of the screen, pushing your most-used apps to the bottom where they are reachable
- Reachability
- Use Siri to launch apps
- App switch by dragging your thumb along the base of the iPhone
- Enable AssistiveTouch and set it up with actions that are normally hard-to-reach
I personally love the Max / Plus sized phone. I have fairly big hands and it fits perfectly in them, and I haven't had an issue with it falling out of my pocket or not fitting in there. The size is perfect for me.
I'm still trying to decide between the 11Pro and regular 11 (not interested in the Max) and what you just mentioned is being factored into my decision making. 6.1 supposedly will still be made next year while the 5.8" is supposedly being downsized to 5.4" (too small IMO). This could be my last chance to get the 5.8" size for many years.
I had the XR and loved it. I had the 11P for a few days and if I had to decide between the 11P and 11 it would be the 11P. I left the XS for the XR because the XS battery was just not enough IMO. I recently gave the 11P a chance but went with the 11PM but I have been a Plus user since Apple made them.
The 11P is the sleeper of the bunch. Great fit in-hand and ridiculous battery life. The screen of the 11 is great and I have preferred the LCD screen in the past but I have to say I love the clarity and color of the Pro line. Yes, they are slightly warmer screens but I think they are accurate and I love reading on them. One thing that irked me with the XR/11 was the smaller default text in Safari. The screen is bigger but smaller text size? Not a deal breaker but annoying, for me.
I think the 11P battery is better than the XR and 11. I know specs say it but that doesn’t always mean it’s real. The battery life I got from the 11P on just the second charge cycle was insane.